Southern unity key to Lankan peace
By Anita Pratap
Do nations have tragic flaws? I am inclined to believe they do. Much of
the world would say the US had its tryst with hubris last year. India's
tragic flaw is the tendency to shoot herself in the foot. Every time we
experience relative peace and stability for a few years, and seem just
about reviving up for a take-off, comes a savage self-inflicted wound that
forces us to abort our flight.
Gujarat makes us hang our heads in shame as once again India is reduced
to an ugly theatre of atavistic hatreds. All the gains we made through
mature diplomacy and restrained deployment dissipate as the world sees
us as the conjoined twin of an unstable and fanatical Pakistan.
Since the 1970s, India has been readying for a take off. Then emergency
happened. In the 1980s, the anti-Sikh riots tripped us badly, in the 1990s,
demolition of the Babri Masjid, the Mumbai riots and serial blasts were
setbacks that took years to heal, correct and stabilize. Indeed, we have
been taking so many decades to take off that India Inc. must have the longest
runway in the world!
We love harping about our great past. We love harping about our future
potential. But our stumbling block is our present. If only we could climb
out of the rut of our present, we could harbour hopes of getting to the
future. Instead, the middle class knows where its future lies and it isn't
in India. The fastest growing export in the last three decades must surely
be the swelling ranks of the NRIs (Non-Resident Indians). Is it any wonder
then that nowadays Bollywood, BJP politics and even the Budget is tailor-made
to suit the wants of expatriate Indians?
Our small but beautiful neighbour, Sri Lanka is burdened by its tragic
flaw. Pacts are made only to be broken. When one warring party finally
comes around to offer the olive branch, the other whips out the swords.
One side always manages to let the other side down, ever since this island
nation broke free from the British and had to resolve the Tamil-Sinhalese
divide. Up until 1982, the Sinhalese didn't fulfil their part of the deal.
Since 1985, when the LTTE walked out of the Thimpu talks, the Tigers have
been seen as the wreckers of peace. Now the pendulum threatens to swing
again in the other direction. The recent Norway-brokered ceasefire agreement
is historic. This time around, the Tigers seem willing to play ball. The
tragedy could be that the Sinhalese establishment may let the ball slip
through its fingers.
A Tiger doesn't change its stripes. LTTE boss V. Prabhakaran may be
47 years old, but there is nothing to suggest he is tiring. Still, the
man has tremendous foresight. Back in the 1980s he had said to me in one
of his interviews that his ability to carve a separate Tamil homeland would
depend considerably on international factors. Post September 11 international
climate does not favour him or his pursuit. Under US leadership, the world
has united against terrorism. But give a few years, and this united international
coalition against terrorism will weaken, develop cracks. Already countries
like France and Ireland are ruffled by the US-supported Israeli strikes
in Palestine.
But Prabhakaran will play ball now because he is under tremendous international
pressure. Tamils and Sinhalese may argue till kingdom come that one man's
freedom fighter is another man's terrorist, but India, the US and Britain
have gone ahead and banned the LTTE. This has cramped their movement, functioning
and even fund collection. Prabhakaran knows the only way to salvage his
image and his organization is to make a bid for peace.
Unfortunately, the Sri Lankan establishment is now badly fractured.
They are in throes of "cohabitation", a prickly, unstable situation where
arch rivals, President Chandrika Kumaratunga and Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe,
must share power. The ceasefire agreement was Ranil's triumph, but for
that very reason the President is not pleased. She has already reacted
angrily saying she was not consulted before the agreement was signed, that
it violates Sri Lanka's sovereignty, that she has the power to wreck it.
The agreement is a turning point that has the potential to head Sri
Lanka towards peace. But for that to happen, there has to be political
vision and unity. Dissension and one-upmanship can tragically veer Sri
Lanka to the path of self-destruction.
The second threat to the agreement is the difficulties that always lie
in implementation. If red tape and lack of will and determination stall
the enforcement of the ceasefire provisions, trouble is inevitable. And
the third problem is Sri Lanka's war-battered economy that has slipped
into negative growth.
Economic frustration and rising unemployment in the south can resurrect
the Sinhalese insurrection that had wreaked havoc in the 1970s and again
in the late 1980s. A Sri Lankan government, which has its hands full with
the Tamil problem in the north, can hardly cope with the opening of a new
warfront in the south. In the circumstances, all Prabhakaran needs to do
is sit back in his jungle and watch the troubles brewing in the south,
troubles that have the potential to wreck this agreement. And if that happens,
violence is inevitable.
In early 1983, I wrote an article on an astrologer in Chennai called
D.V. Krishna who designs corporate logos. He warned me that Sunday, the
magazine I was then working for, was doomed. Its masthead's numerological
vibrations were all wrong. It would be beset with labour disputes and would
eventually close down. The prediction came true. He also warned that Sri
Lanka must change its flag - as long as it had a lion standing on three
legs with the fourth holding up a sword, it would be plagued by instability
and bloodshed. Rationalists would scoff, the superstitious would advocate
a flag change and the pragmatists would say if all options fail, give astrology
a try. The solution probably lies in self-correction. But then flaws would
not be tragic if solutions were easy to implement.
(Anita Pratap is the author of "lsland of Blood - frontline reports
from Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and other South Asian flashpoints". She wrote
this article exclusive to The Sunday Times. She can be contacted at post@anitapratap.com) |