Telecom
shares: Who cut the foreign call?
For years, the Colombo Stock Market has been endeavouring
to enter the league of international stock markets. The low level
of capitalisation and its iliquidity prevented it from being an attractive
market for foreign investors, though it was for many years a foreign-driven
market.
The entry of
the Sri Lanka Telecom shares, the telecommunication giant, raised
hopes of the market changing its character and turning into a dynamic
international market. By introducing a new sector to the market
and increasing market capitalisation significantly, it was expected
to move the Colombo Share Market towards being a more attractive
one to foreigners.
However this
has not happened. The Colombo bourse has probably missed the bus.
Why?
The size of
the SLT issue and its unprecedented value in the CSE meant that
large investors, who based their decision making on the long-term
earnings potential, were needed to sustain the demand for the share.
This was lacking. A massive Initial Public Offer, such as the Telecom
offer, requires either foreign investors or institutions in the
country to invest heavily. Neither appears to have occurred.
Foreign investments
amounted to only about US$ 4.5 million, much below the expected
US$ 10 million.
Sri Lankan
institutional investors too shied away from the share. Even Unit
Trusts took an insignificant picking. Why? No doubt the speculative
instincts of institutional investors got the better of them on the
SLT issue. They were expecting some shareholders to trade below
the issue price. They therefore expected to pick up shares in the
market below the issue price. They were right in their speculation.
More precisely, they made the speculation come right by their own
action of withholding from purchases in the initial offer. The much
expected oversubscribing did not occur.
In contrast
small investors in the country from even far off places and Sri
Lankans living abroad have bought heavily. Small investors who expected
only a fraction of the shares they applied for may have oversubscribed
in terms of their credit capacity and may have had to shed their
excessive shares even at a loss. This accounts for the share price
declining to around Rs. 13.50.
It is quite
shocking that institutional investors bought only small quantities
of the country's largest share issue that would dominate the market.
This is particularly startling, as the telecom share was very sound
on fundamentals. SLT has capital and reserves worth Rs. 39 billion,
including Rs. 22 billion in retained earnings. SLT reported a 38
percent increase in after-tax profits for the nine months ending
September 30, 2002, an increase in net profits from Rs. 1,763 million
in 2001 to Rs. 2,425 million. Its revenues rose from Rs. 16,159
million to Rs. 18,579 million, 15 percent higher than during the
corresponding period in 2001.
SLT also announced
a three percent interim dividend for the financial year 2002. The
SLT share even at the issue price of Rs. 15 was a good buy. The
intrinsic value of the share has been calculated at around Rs. 27,
the most conservative estimate would place it at about Rs. 23. The
SLT profits, dividends and its potential growth would ensure the
rise in its price over time.
This shows
clearly that institutional investors here did not base their decisions
on the fundamentals of the SLT share, but took a speculative position
based on what they expected would be market sentiments. In the process
they themselves created those market sentiments and squandered an
opportunity to attract foreign portfolio investments -- an opportunity
to be ranked as an international market of consequence.
An important
expectation was that Sri Lanka Telecom would be included in the
Morgan Stanley Capital Index (MSCI) at its next review at the end
of this month. That is now most unlikely. Sri Lanka was removed
from the MSCI regional equity indices last year due to the Colombo
market's small size.
SLT's IPO of
US$ 216.6 million changed that. But the loss in value of the share
has lost us the claim. Those responsible for the country's financial
development should take the responsibility for weakening a strong
claim for SLT and Sri Lanka to be included in the MSCI. We may have
lost the opportunity to put our market in the global market place.
The market
was unattractive to foreigners owing to its low market capitalisation
and its ill liquidity. Before the entry of SLT shares, market capitalisation
was around Rs.160 billion. SLT shares at issue raised market capitalisation
by Rs. 30 billion an increase of around 18 per cent. It rose to
about Rs. 205 billion with the Apollo and the SLT share issue. With
the SLT share price falling and an overall decline brought about
by the war jitters, the market capitalisation has fallen to Rs185
billion.
In this context
it is most improbable that the CSE would be included in the Morgan
Stanley Capital Index this month. We can only hope the future holds
better prospects. Market capitalisation is still less than US$ 200
million. We are still small, but about twice that of 2000. If Sri
Lanka's stock market is to rank among those that foreign investors
have an appetite for, more companies need to list on the stock exchange,
large privatised enterprises must be listed and a large amount of
shares available for sale.
It is important
that major privatisations such as Sri Lanka Insurance Corporation
and other large state entities be listed in the CSE. Even that will
not be sufficient if Sri Lankan institutional investors do not play
an important role by investing in these share issues. Their role
with respect to the SLT shares was rather discouraging. This does
not augur well for the future of share market. They have to play
a significant role in strengthening the market by investing more.
|