Media
prevented from asking questions at High Commission demo
Amnesty to query Brits about fingerprinting Lankans
Tyronne: “How to offend a friendly country?”
Kadir: “We would have done it differently”
By Shelani Perera
Amidst reports of Amnesty International questioning the British
government's move to finger print Sri Lankans applying for UK visas
as being a violation of human rights, the Sri Lankan government
decided to give the green light as it was unable to say "no"
to a friendly country.
Reports from
London state that the Amnesty International is to take up the matter
with the relevant authorities at the Home office in London. However
Foreign Affairs Minister Tyronne Fernando told The Sunday Times
that when a friendly country makes a request we are unable to refuse.
"We have
to understand that granting of visas is purely at the discretion
of the issuing country and that they can at any time even stop issuing
any more visas. These are days when various methods are used for
better identification, it could be the eyes, the face or the signature,
fingerprinting is just another method an applicant would have to
comply with when obtaining a visa" Mr. Fernando said.
The Minister
added that the government approved the request made by UK on the
basis that it was to be a pilot project which came into operation
last Wednesday and will be gradually introduced and implemented
in other countries too.
"The British
High Commission was not using the usual method of using ink in this
new form of finger printing but it was a technique known as biometrics.
When we were informed by the UK Government of the method being used
and the reasons why this kind of identification was being used we
found no reason to object and further it was to be gradually introduced
to other parts of the world as well.
The misconception
as arisen due to the fact that when we speak of finger printing
we are usually conditioned to think only of criminals and it should
be clearly understood that this system has no such connotations
it is merely a preventive measure to nab illegal immigrants. Once
this system is enforced it will be possible to better screen visa
applicants and distinguish the genuine from the bogus", Foreign
Affairs Minister Tyronne Fernando said.
However Lakshman
Kadirgamar a former Foreign Minister criticised the government on
acceding to this request made by Britain and said that he would
have handled the matter differently.
"If I
was approached with such a request I would have tackled it differently,
I would have opposed the move in the first instance and would have
raised a number of points as to why this should not be adopted.
Though I am
only too painfully aware of the limitations of a small country,
still I did not hesitate to speak out when and where necessary aware
that sucess or failure was quite another matter. I was firmly of
the view that even a small country such as ours must at all times
maintain its pride and dignity" Mr. Kadirgamar said.
The Opposition
has strongly criticised the Government for allowing Britain to implement
this system at the British High Commission in Colombo. Prior to
the commencement of the new system the British High Commission in
Colombo gave an opportunity to the media to witness the system in
operation. However the media were barred from questioning the UK
special projects officer who is currently in Sri Lanka and the only
questions allowed was related to the technique used.
The High Commission
clearly stated that it was only a photo opportunity thus raising
further questions as to the basis on which Sri Lanka was used for
the pilot project.
The criticisms
regarding the use of Sri Lanka sounded questionable when considering
the fact that the UK Home Office has listed countries such as Iraq,
Somalia and Zimbabwe as those with the highest number of asylum
seekers for the 1st Quarter of 2003.
A statement
issued by the Home Office two weeks ago states that "Fingerprint
data will be recorded electronically to help identify the significant
number of Sri Lankans who on or after arrival in the UK, make fraudulent
asylum or immigration applications using a false identity. Fingerprints
will be collected from applicants at the British Diplomatic Mission
in Colombo using electronic data capturing equipment. Data would
be stored electronically on a database and shared with police and
other law enforcement agencies".
The statement
went on to say "for an initial period of six months, we will
collect fingerprints from everyone who applies for a visa in Sri
Lanka. “ This will not only enable us to identify people who
destroy their documents and then claim asylum under another name,
but will also help us to issue new travel documents to those who
are disallowed asylum".
Don't
ask too many questions
A journalist at a press conference presided over by Labour Minister
Mahinda Samarasinghe posed the question to Italian Ambassador Salvatore
Zotta as to why his government cut down Sri Lanka's job quota from
1000 last year to 500 in 2003.
Before the ambassador could answer Mr. Samarasinghe speaking in
Sinhala said "do not ask that because we may lose those jobs
as well". But the minister was polite enough to later explain
to the Ambassador the comments he made.
Not
the best of places
Children of more than 100 schools, from all parts of the country,
visited Parliament as a way of enhancing their education during
the four days the House sat last week. Most of the students were
from the primary section were seen cuddling close together in the
highly air-conditioned chamber of the House.
It is very doubtful
as to what exactly these children stand to gain by being exposed
to the type of behaviour some MPs are known for. Maybe those who
arrange these 'educational' tours should take the young children
to places better suited for their age where they could learn something
worthwhile.
Speaking
out does not pay
The President of the Police Inspectors Association Inspector Dale
Gunaratne was summoned to Police headquarters for an inquiry that
had been initiated against him. His offence was that he had been
found talking to too many journalists and is said to have revealed
the dissatisfaction that is rampant among the junior officers of
the police force.
Fingerprints
for lesser mortals
The weekly PA news conference held on Friday was based on the controversy
surrounding the government's interim council proposals. The PA alleged
the President received a different set of proposals from those sent
to the LTTE.
Presidential
adviser Lakshman Kadirgamar who was answering most of the questions
when asked if the PA came to power and talks with the LTTE were
resumed and Mr. Kadiragamar's reaction to comments made by Dr. Balasingham
during an interview wher it was stated that both the President and
Mr. Kadiragamar should travel abroad for the purpose of getting
the ban on the LTTE removed had said, "One serious problem
exists if we are to visit that particular destination is we would
have to be fingerprinted first and as such going there may not be
possible". The BBC Correspondent present at the news conference
responded to this saying "Diplomatic passport holders are exempted.
|