A
timely contribution
Sri Lankan Ethnic Crisis: Towards
a Resolution by R. B. Herath. Reviewed by Professor Mahinda Werake.
R. B. Herath's most recent work is a welcome addition to the growing
literature on the ethnic crisis of Sri Lanka and also one of the
few serious studies published so far on the resolution of the conflict
through a federal system. While one may agree or disagree with the
views expressed by the author in this volume, there is no doubt
that he was committed to this study because of his passionate love
for his homeland and the fervent desire to help Sri Lanka find a
peaceful solution to the prolonged civil war that engulfed the country
for two decades.
Although, since
1984, the author has lived most of his life outside the country,
the book shows that he has not lost touch with Sri Lanka and has
been a keen observer of its developments. Through his association
with the South Asian Network for Secularism and Democracy (SANSARD)
in Vancouver, Canada, the author has been able to pursue a serious
academic study of South Asian affairs.
Thought
provoking
As an introduction to his book, the author provides a brief glimpse
of Sri Lanka's past. His discussion of Sri Lanka's post-colonial
history is thought provoking. His comments are worth consideration
in understanding why we have failed to achieve success as a nation.
All citizens concerned should take his main argument that post-colonial
Sri Lankan leaders have failed to recognize the multi-ethnic and
multi-cultural nature of the country and build a nation based on
pluralism and true democracy.
The author's
experience as a politician in Sri Lanka prior to 1983, and as an
engineer, academic, public servant, writer, dramatist, and speaker
in several African and Western countries has provided him with a
broad vision to consider Sri Lanka's ethnic problem in a new perspective.
His criticism
of S.W.R.D. Bandaranaike for promoting Sinhala Buddhist nationalism
may be too strong, for it was not only Bandaranaike but also the
leaders of the UNP who played the Sinhala nationalist card to their
advantage. In that context, we need to understand that in post-colonial
Sri Lanka, while leaders of almost all Sinhalese political parties
promoted Sinhalese nationalism, the leaders of Tamil political parties
in response espoused Tamil nationalism. In other words, leaders
of both Sinhalese and Tamil communities are responsible for not
promoting or supporting a true sense of ‘Sri Lankan’
identity.
Another debatable
point is the political activism of the Sangha. According to him,
the Sangha's entry into politics, which was encouraged by Bandaranaike,
has complicated issues and has made it difficult for any government
to seek rationalistic solutions to the country's problems. While
recognizing the immensely valuable role played by the Sangha in
preserving Buddhism and Sinhala culture during the colonial times,
he argues that in multi-ethnic and multi-cultural post-colonial
Sri Lanka, it was not proper for the Sangha to directly involve
themselves in politics, because it exacerbates the already existing
tensions between Buddhists and non-Buddhists, and thereby directly
contributes to the already existing divisions.
The question
that can be raised here is whether the Sangha should completely
keep away from politics or should confine themselves to a role of
advising the rulers. Realistically speaking, in the present day
highly politicized culture of Sri Lanka, we have to expect the Sangha
to play some role in politics but it may be desirable for them to
restrict their participation to an advisory role as practised in
some Buddhist countries such as Thailand.
True
democracy
The author's contention that democracy in Sri Lanka has so far failed
to achieve its desired results because its political leadership
has remained in the hands of the elitist class who were not interested
in promoting democracy among people but wanted to gain or remain
in power, is a valid observation that can be applied even to the
traditional Marxist parties in the country. In that context, the
rise of the LTTE in the North and JVP in the South can be viewed
as a response to the failure of the Sri Lankan political system
to deliver political and economic freedom to the common man in post-colonial
Sri Lanka. The outcome of this development is that both the JVP
and the LTTE decided to gain such freedom through undemocratic means.
In order to
rectify this situation, the author recommends encouraging direct
participation of people in democratic governance at different levels,
which is an excellent proposal. However, the question is whether
the Sri Lankan political leadership would be willing to overhaul
the present political system and replace it with a truly democratic
one. The irony of the situation is that without such a transformation
in the South, we cannot expect the LTTE to do the same in the North.
It is indeed a challenge to all Sri Lankan political leaders.
The second part
of the book is devoted to a discussion of a federal structure for
Sri Lanka in order to solve the ethnic crisis. The author's brief
examination of the federal systems in the United States, Canada,
India, and Switzerland is quite useful to understand how federal
structures function in other countries which have diverse ethnic
and cultural populations. Because of Sri Lanka's multi-ethnic and
multi-cultural character, he recommends a similar structure, which
he believes, can be established at either provincial or district
level. His idea is to give those entities the power to decide their
own affairs except in matters of national interest such as defence,
foreign affairs, imports and exports, and currency, which would
remain under control of the central government. The author recognizes
the need to adapt the federal structure that he proposes to meet
the needs and aspirations of the people of Sri Lanka.
One interesting
point the author raises in this book is the importance of recognizing
the rights of the Veddahs, who wish to retain their own identity.
As far as I am aware, none of the political parties in Sri Lanka
have recognized them as a separate group of people who deserve respect
as descendants of the first inhabitants of the island. They should
be entitled to equal rights under a truly democratic system.
Another matter
that the author brings to our attention is the urgent need to solve
the citizenship issue of the remaining Indian Tamils who opted to
go to India but could not do so due to various reasons. It is heartening
to note that the present government has already taken steps to solve
this human problem since the publication of this book.
A suggestion
The solution to the ethnic crisis proposed by Herath is based on
the concept of declaring the whole of Sri Lanka as the homeland
of all Sri Lankans, which undoubtedly is an excellent idea. However,
the question that remains is whether the LTTE could be persuaded
to accept such a concept and give up their claim to a separate homeland
in the North and East at this juncture.
In any event,
it goes without saying that the government of Sri Lanka, in finding
a final solution to the ethnic crisis, should make every effort
to ensure that Sri Lankans of any ethnicity be allowed to move freely
and settle down anywhere they like within Sri Lanka.
This is a book
that all Sri Lankans who are concerned about the destiny of their
country should read. The author should be commended for bringing
out this volume at this crucial point in our history.
It is a timely
contribution to finding a lasting solution to the most devastating
problem that Sri Lanka has faced since independence. It is hoped
that the author would successfully bring out the Sinhala and Tamil
versions of his book, as he plans, in the near future.
A
fragrant collection
Fragrance of Springtime Blossoms by W.T.A. Leslie Fernando.
Reviewed by Rohan Jayetilleke.
W.T.A. Leslie
Fernando's ‘Fragrance of Springtime Blossoms’ comprises
six short stories. ‘A Heart That Bleeds’ is woven round
an encounter between a young Sinhalese man Tilak and an old Tamil
man, travelling by train from Colombo to Rambukkana. The author
shows the plight of the indentured South Indian labour, then as
now, with no place of their own, though they have sacrificed much
for the economic growth of this country. In conversation, the old
man says; "Sir, we are from Rambukkana. I went to Lunawa Kovil
to invoke the blessings of Goddess Kali for the welfare of these
two boys (his grandchildren).
When their father
was living, they were well off. He was running a business at Panadura.
During the 1958 communal riots, hooligans attacked the shop, killed
their father and looted the shop. Now I sell gram and their mother
is tapping rubber to maintain the family. With great difficulty
we bring up these two children. My days are numbered and I am really
worried about the future of these two boys". The story portrays
man's inhumanity to man.
In ‘The
Benevolent Thug’, the writer traces the metamorphosis of a
Shelton Almeida of Negombo, who after seven years of rigorous imprisonment
for culpable homicide returns to society, becoming the henchman
of a revolutionary Marxist politician. The concluding paragraph
of this story, is an indictment of present day politicians.
The author
says, “Was it politics that changed this once convicted criminal?
Kithsiri cannot understand how politics which make good people bad
could make Shelton Almeida an honourable person devoted to a cause.
But one thing is clear. When compared with those selfish gentry
in the higher strata of society who are supposed to be respectable
and honourable who change their policies and cut the throat of others
to attain their ends - Shelton Almeida who had undergone a sentence
of imprisonment was a better person to be admired.”
I shall not
comment on all the stories in the book, but conclude with an extract
from the foreword by literary critic Stanley E. Abeynayake, "His
(W.T.A. Leslie Fernando) creative works reveal a strong originality,
triumphing over traditional habits. They are concerned with directly
personal embarrassments and delusions of unsophisticated personalities...
They are in fact fictitious prose narratives, portraying characters
and actions creditably representative of real life in contentious
plots or romantic stories.... We live in an age of stress and strain,
inflation, oil crisis, nuclear pollution and what not. Here is a
sincere attempt to help us in our times of crisis - a book worth
reading over and over again to help us to live a life of poise and
equanimity."
Word by
word the book was made
A new book charts the remarkable
story of the Oxford English Dictionary from its beginnings in 1857
to its publication in 1928. Lisa Sabbage reports.
From aardvark
to zoo, from apple to zymurgy, the Oxford English Dictionary has
been helping to define and describe the world since 1928, when it
was first published in 10 volumes as A New English Dictionary on
Historical Principles.
Now, writer
and historian Simon Winchester has taken the dictionary itself as
his subject in The Meaning of Everything: The Story of the Oxford
English Dictionary.
Populated with plenty of British eccentrics and unlikely heroes,
it is a story that starts in the middle of the 19th century and
wends its way from Westminster to Broadmoor Lunatic Asylum, via
a corrugated iron shed in the grounds of Mill Hill School, and the
university town of Oxford.
The idea for
the definitive dictionary of English language was hatched in1857,
when the Dean of Westminster, Richard Trench, delivered an inspiring
speech to the Philological Society at London Library, calling for
the creation of a reference book in which every known English word
would be recorded, along with a detailed account of its origins,
meanings, pronunciation and spelling down through the ages.
Trench was
fed up with existing dictionaries he found lacking at best, and
inaccurate at worst. Even Dr. Samuel Johnson's well-regarded dictionary
was then more than 100 years old and documented just 40,000 words.
Trench proposed a different project that would be the work, not
just of one dedicated author and editor, but of hundreds of volunteers
whose mission it would be to compile words, their definitions, and
examples of their usage.
The goal, says
Winchester, was to record "every word, every nuance, every
shading of meaning and spelling and pronunciation, every twist of
etymology, every possible illustrative citation from every English
author". Indeed, the ‘Big Dic’, as it was sometimes
known, would be a ‘biography’ of every English word.
Within a few
years, six million slips had arrived from contributors and Herbert
Coleridge had been appointed the dictionary's first editor. Sadly,
Coleridge had been at his post only two years and was halfway through
quotations containing words beginning with "a" when he
caught a cold and died, aged 31.
Frederick Furnivall,
a scholarly and energetic member of the Philological Society's Unrecorded
Words Committee, succeeded Coleridge. Furnivall was easily distracted
by other literary activities - including the establishment of the
Early English Text Society - and his passion for rowing with the
Hammersmith Ladies' Club.
With the project
falling behind schedule, the Philological Society realized its ambition
for the dictionary outstripped its resources and approached Oxford
University Press for help. The publishers and the Society eventually
made a deal and in 1879, James Murray became the editor of what
they envisaged would be a four-volume, 6,400-page work that would
take ten years to complete.
The son of
a Scottish tailor, Murray was largely self-educated and had worked
as a bank clerk and a schoolmaster before being charged with the
task of rescuing the dictionary from its verbal tomb. He proved
to be the man for the job.
First, Murray
built what he called a Scriptorium, or Scrippy, in the grounds of
Mill Hill School where he taught. Little more than a corrugated
iron shed, the Scrippy housed two tons of quotations the Society
had collected. When he was not working his way through these, Murray
had to locate the alphabet slips that had gone missing.
After much
searching, he found the slips for ‘H’ in the Tuscan
hills of Italy, where one volunteer had left them after his eyesight
failed. As for the slips for ‘Pa’, they were tracked
down to a stable in County Cavan where they had been used as spills
for lighting fires!
Progress was
slow. By 1884, five years into the project, Murray had been able
to publish only one fascicle or instalment (A to Ant). The publishers
pressured him to work faster and to take a less rigorous approach,
but Murray insisted that contributors be allowed to work at their
own pace. At one point he came close to resigning; at another, the
publishers almost pulled the plug; but somehow the dictionary kept
stuttering on.
By then the
editor had given up teaching and moved his Scriptorium to his garden
in Oxford where he pored over papers sent by such unusual contributors
as William Chester Minor, a convicted murderer incarcerated at Broadmoor
Criminal Lunatic Asylum.
An American
doctor who had served as a surgeon during his country's Civil War,
Minor travelled to London in 1872, perhaps trying to escape the
delusions that, according to Simon Winchester, convinced him the
Irish were trying to kill him. In February that year, Minor shot
and killed a stranger.
Hungry for
‘intellectual stimulus’ Minor answered Murray's request
for contributors and soon became his most productive volunteer.
He often sent hundreds of words a week to Murray. But 13 years of
wordplay could not save Minor from himself. He eventually became
so depressed and disturbed that he cut off his own penis.
Other contributors
included historian Edith Thompson, the former director of the Bank
of England, Henry Hucks Gibbs and Dr. Fitzedward Hall, a professor
of Sanskrit, who wrote to Oxford everyday for 22 years. JRR Tolkien,
best known as the author of The Hobbit, was also a contributor.
Sadly, James
Murray never witnessed the completion of his cherished dictionary.
He died in 1915, shortly before the fascicle for the letter ‘T’
was published. Murray's successors were equal in their devotion,
and in April, 1928, the last volume was published. Instead of 6,400
pages in four volumes, A New English Dictionary on Historical Principles
contained more than 400,000 words and phrases in ten volumes.
It was promptly hailed as the authoritative dictionary of the English
language.
evertheless,
editors William Craigie and Charles Onions began updating the entries,
producing a concise edition and supplementary volumes to the original.
While James Murray and his band of faithful if eccentric contributors
wrestled with words like ‘walrus’, ‘of’,
‘odd’ and ‘paddock’, the latest supplements
to the OED include words and phrases such as ‘chat room’,
‘chick flick’, and ‘munchies’. After all,
English is a living language, constantly changing and adapting to
the needs and experiences of its users.
As Simon Winchester
aptly demonstrates in his informative and entertaining book, the
Oxford English Dictionary really does contain thrills and spills,
drama and intrigue.
Indeed, those searching for the meaning of life need look no further.
Asia Features
Some
interesting snippets
* The longest word in the Oxford English Dictionary is ‘Pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis’,
a lung disease ‘caused by inhaling very fine ash and sand
dust’.
* Originally published as A New English Dictionary on Historical
Principles, the designation ‘Oxford English Dictionary’
appeared for the first time above the title on the cover of the
section ‘deceit to deject’ published in January, 1895.
* In 1898, the publishers were granted permission to dedicate
the dictionary to Queen Victoria.
* On the publication of all 10 volumes in 1928, the first copies
were presented to King George V and to Calvin Coolidge, President
of the United States.
* In the year 2,000, the Oxford English Dictionary was launched
online. Two years later, it was released as a CD Rom.
* The dictionary's longest entry is for the word ‘set’,
which has 430 senses and 60,000 words.
* Shakespeare is the author quoted most often in the OED, with
33,300 references. His play Hamlet alone is quoted almost 1,600
times.
Down memory
lane with bat and ball
At a time when cricket has virtually become Sri Lanka's national
game, sports writer Neil Wijeratne has come out with an interesting
publication in Sinhala, titled 'Deveni Inima' (Second Innings).
He has unearthed a lot of information relating to the pre-Test era
of the game in this country and his references to both famous as
well as little-known Sri Lankan cricketers are fascinating.
How many of
us knew about Fred Perera who scored 352 not out for the Port Commission
against the Excise Department in 1957? Neil quotes the London publication
'A-Z of Cricket Records' which refers to "F Perera's 352 not
out" as "the highest individual score by a Sri Lankan".
Neil met him and discussed his early days. As a 15-year-old, Fred
had played for St. Joseph's College, primarily as a bowler. In the
match in which he created the record, the game started at 1.30 in
the afternoon. When the day ended, Port Commission had scored 449
runs for seven wickets with Perera scoring 283 in 193 minutes. He
went on to score 352 not out in a mammoth score of 526.
Neil recollects
the first century scored by a Sri Lankan batsman against the West
Indies. The honour goes to Mahes Rodrigo, a popular figure both
in cricket and rugger. In the first ever 'unofficial Test' against
the West Indies, opener Rodrigo scored 14 in the first innings.
In the second innings he carried his bat through to score 135 not
out while all the other ten got out!
In the 1950s,
Government Services and Mercantile cricket tournaments were very
popular. Neil refers to an interesting match played in November
1959. It was a one-day game between Cargills and Car Mart. Batting
first, Cargills were all out for 7 runs and Car Mart won by scoring
8 runs without losing a wicket. The match was over in 45 minutes.
He also records
a rare happening when a two-day first class game ended with a day
and 40 minutes to spare. It was a Sara Trophy match played between
Colombo University and SSC. Colombo University were all out for
34 in the first innings due to some hostile bowling by Lalith Ramanayake
and T. M.S. Saldin. SSC openers Mitra Wettimuny (62) and Mohan de
Silva (51) put on 108 for the first wicket. SSC declared at 132
for four wickets. It was 3.20 in the afternoon. Playing for nearly
two hours, Colombo University managed to score only 40 runs in the
second innings. Ranil Abeynayake (3 wickets), Mitra Wettimuny (4)
and Sriyantha Rajapakse (1) were the successful bowlers.
Neil also picks
up a number of interesting incidents in his book including when
Sir Don Bradman's team played a game at the Colombo Oval (P Sara
Stadium). Wicket keeper Dr. H.I.K. Fernando whom most cricket writers
referred to as 'the best in Asia' was in the Sri Lanka team that
won an unofficial test for the first time against India. H.I.K.,
as he was known, played in the same team with Sir Garfield Sobers,
Wesley Hall and Rohan Kanhai in 1961.
'Deveni Inima'
profiles many other players of yesteryear. Neil takes the reader
on many journeys including a trip to the legendary M.J. Gopalan's
residence in Chennai, to Eden Gardens to meet the gutty spectator
who held the placard 'We are sorry, congratulations Sri Lanka' during
the 1996 World Cup semi-final game against India, and to Karachi
to have a chat with Anjelo Rayer, a cricket administrator whose
name was synonymous with school cricket in Sri Lanka.
Neil reminds
us of how former Prime Minister Sir John Kotelawala acted as 'match
referee' accompanying the two captains of the Indo-Ceylon filmstar
charity cricket match played at the Oval in January 1954 - both
teams being led by the most popular duo at the time Raj Kapoor and
Nargis - to toss. He also talks about how another former PM - Wijayananda
Dahanayake who, as President of the Galle District Cricket Association,
was watching Bill Athey of the England 'A' team piling up a near
double century at the Galle Esplanade and sent him a note saying
'Bill athey...athey' (enough of it).
The Godage
publication is easy reading providing cricket fans refreshing memories
of how the game grew to become the most talked-about sport in Sri
Lanka. I wish Neil had included some photographs too.
Ranat |