Sharp
wit, acid tongue and quick repartee
To be a successful criminal lawyer one has to be "absolutely
hard working and have unquestionable integrity,” believes
Daya Perera PC who celebrates 50 years at the bar
By Laila Nasry
The case was small and insignificant. Just another criminal appeal.
But for the 25-year-old acting crown counsel the task of defending
the conviction for murder was nearly killing him. It was his first
day in the Supreme Court and he was up before the most feared judge,
Justice E.H.T. Gunasekera who was renowned not just for his brilliance
and humour but also his razor sharp tongue.
"I
had heard counsel were ripped to shreds by him. My mouth was dry,
my knees were knocking and I could hardly hear myself think. It
was absolutely frightening." But to his surprise the encounter
was uneventful. What he did not realise was that he was being well
and truly assessed by the judge.
"One
week had lapsed and I was doing well." No scolding, no browbeating
questions, no sarcastic comments. "That was when I got all
cocky and invited my friends to come and watch me in court and boy
didn't I regret it. He gave me an absolute ripping that day, the
show ended before it began."
The
beginning
Fifty years down the line President's Counsel Daya Perera,
a name synonymous with criminal law, chuckles at the recollection
adding, "Everyone starts that way." Completing fifty years
in the Bar on March 19, it has been a long road but one not short
of milestones, leading to success.
In
1954 Mr. Perera started out as a civil lawyer. Having completed
the six-month period of apprenticeship under N.E. Weerasooriya,
QC, on entering the profession he found himself out of work. "With
other equally impecunious lawyers I used to just sit and twiddle
my thumbs in the law library drinking a helluva lot of tea."
His
first case came quite by chance, through a relative. Also a civil
matter, for he says, "Back then no one trusted the liberty
of a man in my hands." Although the case was nothing exceptional,
it earned him a handsome fee. "Two guineas, that is twenty
one rupees, which was a big amount at that time, so much so that
I could afford to buy presents for my mother, father and all my
brothers and sisters with my first pay."
Most
unexpected was his entry to the field of criminal law which came
after he addressed the annual 'Voetlights' dinner as the ‘Baby
of the Bar’. "The following morning, it was a Sunday,
I got a call from George Chitty asking me whether I liked to work
in his chambers. I jumped at the opportunity and started work the
next day."
Working
with Mr. Chitty was a treat. He was a brilliant man. And as his
junior Mr. Perera was often left foxed as to how they won in court
because, “half the consultation he spends talking about the
four cameras he has on his table, never discusses the case in the
car but goes into court and pulls out some magic from his hat and
wins the case”. Mr. Perera counts the early years with Mr.
Chitty as the foundation of his success. "When you work with
a senior like that a lot of him rubs off on you, from knowledge
to language to conduct in court. I owe him much."
Moving
on
With marriage on the horizon and not wanting to be dependent
on anyone, Mr. Perera moved on to join the Crown in January 1956.
He says the training one gets in the Attorney General’s Department
is very good and the experience invaluable. Prosecution is a fine
art. The intricacies were so well ingrained that to date he sometimes
thinks like a prosecuting counsel in court. Other than in the cases
in which he appears, he states, "At times when I hear today's
prosecuting counsel asking the wrong questions I feel like passing
them a note with the right ones on it."
Recalling
his 15 years in the Department he says, "There were only around
26 advocates and those were days when the seniors had time to oversee
the work and teach the juniors." Saturdays were working days
at the Department. "We used to congregate in Colombo and discuss
the week's proceedings. Inevitably at those meetings we studied
the law, the judges and our opposing counsel."
Counting
a number of famous cases to his name, Mr. Perera in particular recalls
the Kalattawa murder case. "The non-summary proceeding took
one year and 10 days and the jury trial was fixed day to day for
six months."
In
another case in which he prosecuted, where the accused was sentenced
to a lifetime in prison, Mr. Perera recalled a twist to the tale,
having met the convicted man nearly 20 years later at a pola (market),
the man having been released from prison for good behaviour. "He
later visited me at home asking me for a job."
Military
stint
In 1964, Mr. Perera was given two years leave from the
Department to join the Army to 'raise' their legal division. As
a Lieutenant Colonel he was instrumental in setting up court martials,
imposing summary punishments and even convicting a fellow lieutenant
colonel who had dipped into the kitty. In 1971 over the language
issue, Mr. Perera having refused to make submissions in Sinhala
left the Department to practise as a defence counsel in the private
Bar where he has remained to date.
Apart
from his excellent advocacy skills Mr. Perera is known for his court
craft. With a mischievous twinkle in his eye, he recounts a gruesome
murder where the woman had been stunned, strangled and thereafter
torched. As the prosecutor in the case, in his possession was a
book of photos of the mutilated body. Handing it over to the jury
he had expressly stated not to look at the pictures, knowing very
well that curiosity would get the better of them. "As anticipated
they immediately began to discreetly look at the pictures. I saw
the blood drain from their faces. I knew a verdict of guilt was
sealed."
One
of the boys
Renowned for his sharp wit Mr. Perera recalled his days
as Ambassador for Sri Lanka to the United Nations. On his first
day he met the Ambassador for Grenada who soon learned that Mr.
Perera was not a career diplomat but a lawyer. Happy to meet a non-career
diplomat, the ambassador had introduced himself as a dentist adding,
"We both make money through the mouth." Pat came the reply,
"You earn money though other peoples' mouths while I have to
earn money through mine!" From that day on he had been embraced
as 'one of the boys' at the UN.
Mr.
Perera's most proud achievement was winning the International Court
of Justice (ICJ) election for Judge C.G. Weeramantry without any
assistance from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "I personally
spoke to 149 Ambassadors of the 151 countries with the exception
of South Africa and Israel."
Decline
of professionalism
Commenting on the gradual decline in the standards of
the legal profession over the fifty years, he states, “Today's
lawyers are entering a profession that stinks. Standards are almost
non-existent. The decline is tragic. I don't have tears to weep
for it.”
Mr.
Perera blames the fusion (from proctors and advocates to attorneys-at-law)
in the profession for most of today's ills. "The profession
was brought to its knees by a perverse politician and has still
not recovered. Judges were stripped of their robes and sat on the
bench in black coat and black tie. They were made to travel in car
pools, and the state stopped conferring silk in recognition of senior
lawyers. The dignity and tradition on which the legal profession
was based was all destroyed." Stating it was the darkest period
in the history of the legal profession, explains that the system
of government was such that no one dared to protest. As a result
the profession has now become unmanageable.
Competent
counsel and judges are the bedrock of a good judicial system. "Although
by and large judges are excellent, there are a few who are crude
and don't have the finesse even to be nasty in an elegant way."
Mr. Perera is of the opinion that Magistrates ought to be given
a training at the Attorney General's Department. He opposes the
current system of lone High Court judges sitting in judgment over
the life and death of a man as opposed to the previous system of
a Supreme Court judge hearing the trial with a jury. "Some
of today's judges have not even seen a jury trial," he laments.
Looking
back over the 50 years, he says there are no shortcuts. To be a
criminal lawyer "one has to be very analytical, with an extremely
vigilant disposition and capable of instant reaction". But
to be a successful criminal lawyer one has to be "absolutely
hard working and have unquestionable integrity". That is how
one becomes a Daya Perera. Members of the Bar will felicitate Mr.
Perera on Friday, March 19 at 7.30 p.m. at the Colombo Plaza. |