Many
court battles confront anti-conversion bill
By Frances Bulathsinghala
Religious groups and political parties are gearing
themselves for legal battles over the proposed anti-conversion bills
by the Jathika Hela Urumaya and the government.
The
JHU said it would be organising twenty seminars during the first
two weeks of August to create an awareness among the general public
as a means of counteracting the island-wide signature campaigns
against the bill.
The
Sihala Urumaya Administrative Secretary, Udaya Gammanpila told The
Sunday Times that there 'might be technical flaws' with the JHU
bill and said the party would take steps to initiate a dialogue
with the mainline Christian churches.
He
said the JHU would not resort to signature campaigns to garner support
from Buddhists as the JHU had received a mandate for the introduction
of a bill to protect Buddhism. The Catholic Church and the Christian
Council has presented some 22 petitions in court challenging the
bill.
Referring
to the proposed government's anti-conversion bill proposed by the
Buddha Sasana Ministry, the JHU administrative secretary accused
the government of ‘delaying tactics’.
"No
deadline has been set for the government draft. We were not consulted
about it. Neither have we seen it", Mr. Gammanpila said while
alleging the government was bowing down to pressure from western
powers.
The
Buddhasasana Ministry said there was also the possibility of amalgamating
the government draft with that of the JHU. Buddha Sasana Ministry
Secretary D.W. Abeywickrema said the government would present the
draft Bill titled the Religious Freedom Act and the Supreme Sangha
Council Bill on a priority basis.
"We
cannot give a definite time frame for the bill to be presented in
Parliament. We are awaiting the draft from the Legal Draftsman’s
Department after due scrutiny. We will look into the possibility
of amalgamating both drafts", Mr. Abeywickrema said.
The
government bill on conversions has been drafted on recommendations
made by the ten-member Presidential Buddha Sasana Commission report
of June 28, 2002. Mr. Abeywickrema said a 21-member Supreme Sangha
Council would be appointed to advise the government on all matters
pertaining to Buddhism in Sri Lanka.
A spokesperson
for the Malwatte Chapter when contacted said they have not taken
any formal stand on the issue of the anti-conversion bill. UNF Deputy
Secretary, Tissa Attanayake told The Sunday Times that the party
has not taken any decision on the JHU bill.
Minister
Susil Premajayantha meanwhile said there were 'ample differences'
between the proposed government bill and the private members bill
presented by the JHU.
"The
Government bill is based on the Buddhist Commission report of 2001
but is applicable to forced and unethical conversions affecting
any religion", Minister Premajayantha said adding that the
government would not introduce any draft in an 'ad hoc manner'.
"Yes,
we are taking time. We are not in a hurry. We have sent the bill
to the Legal Draftsman and once we get it back we will submit it
once again for Cabinet approval", Minister Premajayantha said,
responding to allegations by the JHU that the government was avoiding
presenting the bill in Parliament.
He
did not comment on the JHU bill that was read in Parliament and
said the government would await the ruling by the Supreme Court.
Colombo's Archbishop Dr. Oswald Gomis, who is the Head of the Catholic
church in Sri Lanka -- comprising some 6.9 percent of the country's
population -- said the Catholic Church would be lobbying for an
inter-religious committee to tackle the issue of unethical conversions
as opposed to any legislation.
He
dismissed the JHU bill as being too broad and alleged the bill could
lead to false and malicious charges being made on the grounds of
personal animosity. "We have informed the JHU that we believe
the issue of conversions should be resolved through equal representation
of all religious denominations in an inter-religious committee.
It should be the committee who should determine if religious action
should be initiated against any complaint of unethical conversion",
Colombo's Archbishop said.
Meanwhile
a petition was filed by the All Ceylon Hindu Congress President,
Kandiah Neelakandan, protesting against the preamble to the JHU
bill which Mr. Neelakandan alleges is seeking to portray Buddhism
as the country's foremost religion but the petition does not oppose
the main objective of the bill.
The
Muslim Theological Council, the All Ceylon Jamiathul Ulema said
that although the Muslims were not directly affected by the bill
they were perturbed by the likelihood of legal action being constituted
against people who convert and not so much against the fundamental
missionaries.
Moulana
Rilwan Rahim of the Muslim Theological Council said the Council
was concerned about illegal conversions but added that if the anti-conversions
bill becomes law it could have serious implications on human rights.
National
Christian Evangelical Association's President Geoffrey Theagaraja
said the Association which represents five denominations -- the
Dutch Reformed Church, the Assembly of God, the Salvation Army,
the Calvary Church, the Church of the Four Square Gospels -- with
a total of seventy four churches was fully opposed to the bill.
|