Do
you know that more than 50 imported food items sold in Sri Lanka
are GM positive?
The forbidde food
A random survey carried out by an environmentalist group in some
of the supermarkets in Colombo has revealed that more than 50 products
ranging from chocolates to soy products contain Genetically Modified
Organisms.
The
Centre for Environmental Justice (CEJ) using the guide from the
Green Peace, which is considered the authority on international
environmental matters, notes a three-fold rise in genetically-modified
food items in the local market over the past three years since the
government introduced regulations to restrict the import of GM food
items.
The
CEJ was among those groups that lobbied for regulations. In April
2001, the Food Advisory Committee of the Ministry of Health issued
a gazette notification for restrictions on the import of 21 GM food
items such as soy products, corn products, fresh and processed tomato
products, cheese, bakers yeast, beet sugar and microbiological cultures.
But apparently under pressure from the United States, the main GM-food
producing country, the World Trade Organisation and food importers,
the then government first granted a 60-day grace period for the
food items to be removed from the shelves and eventually suspended
the regulations a day before the regulations were to come into effect.
But,
CEJ Executive Director Hemantha Withanage, an environmental scientist,
said that in addition to the gazetted food items, more products
such as cereal, chocolates, soft drinks, vegetable oil and peanut
butter, were available in the market.
Three
years have passed since the regulations were suspended and the authorities
still dare not touch the matter, due to pressure from powerful countries.
As a result - also in the absence of legislation - the consumer
is unaware that some food items he buys are genetically modified.
The
term GMOs is commonly used in reference to crop plants, which are
developed using the latest molecular biology techniques, for human
and animal consumption.
These
plants have been modified in the laboratory to enhance desired traits
such as increased resistance to herbicides or improved nutritional
content. GM technology can develop plants with the exact desired
trait very rapidly and with great accuracy, unlike the traditionally
tried and tested methods of conventional plant breeding.
Because
they are living organisms, GM crops can multiply, spread and reproduce
indefinitely and at will. Once released, genetically engineered
organisms can never be recalled, so their effects are irreversible.
GM pollen and seeds can contaminate farms and wilderness, creating
uncontrollable "super weeds" and threatening the veritable
purity of crops, say environmentalists.
Science
and Technology Minister Prof. Tissa Vitharana who was sidelined
from the Food Advisory Committee after he called for a ban on GM
food, warned in an interview with The Sunday Times that the danger
of altering the genetic structure of organisms was immense.
"Genes
typically follow a vertical structure, spreading down through generations
of the same species. Genetically modified genes have the ability
to spread horizontally, and even cross species boundaries - and
this is where the danger lies," said Prof. Vitharana, who once
headed the Medical Research Institute.
"For
example, prawn genes are now being introduced into varieties of
strawberries to help increase their shelf life. If a person with
an allergy for prawns ate these strawberries it is quite possible
that he would react badly, and end up with severe side effects,
which could even result in death," warned Prof. Vitharana,
a microbiologist by profession.
His
view was supported by S. Nagiah, Assistant Director, Food Control
Administration Unit, who claimed that if a gene from a Brazilian
nut was inserted into soybeans, it could cause reactions which could
be fatal for someone who was allergic to nuts.
It
was in this context that labelling with details of the GM ingredients
was necessary, said Prof. Vitharana who earlier served in the Food
Regulatory Authority of the Health Ministry.
"During
my tenure with the FRA in 2001/2002, it was proposed a ban on GM
food imports until the safety of the items is established. Although
the Minister of Health reportedly initially accepted this proposal,
it was later turned down under extreme pressure from foreign countries.
"We
were asked to reconsider the matter, and as a compromise, we proposed
that labelling be made mandatory for all GM goods. But this proposal,
however, was never acted upon. We learned from reliable sources
that the Minister had submitted the proposal to the Prime Minister's
office where it appeared to have been delayed and subsequently shelved,"
Prof. Vitharana claimed.
"Following
my strong stance on this issue, I was not invited for meetings of
the Food Advisory Committee," said the Minister. Dr. C. K.
Shanmugarajah, Director of the Environmental, Occupational Health
& Food Control Administration, explained that a Health Ministry
expert panel appointed in 2001 to conduct a comprehensive probe
on the import of GM foods, came up with three basic recommendations.
One
of them was to label all products to make the consumers aware that
what he or she buys was genetically modified or contained genetically-modified
ingredients. The second recommendation was to make approval by local
authorities compulsory for all GM food entering the country, subjected
to a risk assessment analysis.
The
third recommendation was aimed at strengthening and improving local
laboratory, analytical capacity, including training for personnel,
enabling testing to be carried out here, Dr. Shanmugarajah said.
To
implement these recommendations, Dr. Shanmugarajah said funds were
necessary. "We have to set up the necessary infrastructure
and carry out awareness campaigns." However, he also called
for a balanced approach taking into consideration the consumers'
health and the industry's survival.
The
rise of diseases that are resistant to treatment with common antibiotics
is already a serious medical concern. Doctors warn that the use
of antibiotic resistance genes in GM crops may add to this risk.
The UPFA government believes that it could move on the matter, but
so far no action has been taken at cabinet level, though there has
been discussion at official level on the subject.
Environment
and Natural Resources Minister A.H.M Fowzie said his Ministry was
trying to bring in legislation to control GM foods. "We are
working to formulate a national policy on GM Foods and hope to present
it to the cabinet in the next couple of months," he said.
Ministry
sources said there had been no political pressure to shelve moves
to bring in legislation while Minister Vitharana said Responding
to queries about handling international pressure on the subject,
Prof. Vitharana said all measures necessary to safeguard the consumer
would be taken whether there was international pressure or not.
"There
really is no excuse for importing untested GM foods, especially
when all of them have safe non-GM alternatives," Prof. Vitharana
said. Pointing out strong opposition to GM food in some European
countries, CEJ's Hemantha Withanage said it was vital to safeguard
local crops from being genetically modified.
"Because
there is a decrease in the demand for GM foods in Western Europe,
GM food producers are targeting markets of the developing countries,
Mr. Withanage noted.
According
to various tests and experiments conducted abroad, many brands of
chocolate and fizzy drinks contained syrup made of genetically modified
corn, he said.
"In
addition, some imported brands of soy and wheat products currently
available in our local markets too have been tested GM positive
abroad. We are forced to rely on second hand information from the
West, as we lack resources and expertise to conduct our own studies
locally," Mr. Withanage added.
He
said if a ban on GM products was not feasible, at least some regulations
should be brought in, making labelling necessary so that the consumer
would know whether the item was GM or not. - Reports by Marisa de
Silva, Mahangu Weerasinghe, Asif Fuard and Ishani Ranasinghe |