‘They
hadn’t forgotten, but they learnt to forgive’
By Feizal Samath
A man is wheeled into the room
of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) and
slowly reveals how he was harassed and tortured by government forces.
Suffering from multiple injuries as a result of his legs being spread
- virtually torn apart - right up to the upper portion of his body,
his evidence grips the commissioners.
As
his story unfolds Archbishop Desmond Tutu, the Nobel-Prize winning
human rights activist and chairman of the commission, is moved to
tears. In another heart-rending account, the TRC is told about a
young female freedom fighter who bravely covers her body - stripped
of its clothes - with a plastic bag before being shot in the head
and buried by her killers. Her body had decomposed before it was
found but the plastic bag remained, testimony to her pathetic plight.
According
to Dr. Biki S.V. Minyuku, former CEO and Chief Accounting Officer
of the TRC, there were worse and even more, gory cases that the
commission heard during three years of work from 1996 to 1998. "There
were families that were totally wiped out. There is no way you can
express the emotions of those families," said Minyuku, currently
Project Director of a state-run Criminal Justice Strengthening Programme.
Perhaps
one of the biggest achievements of the South African peace process
was the ability of victims to forgive and not seek retribution for
the brutal acts committed over a 30-year period mostly by the minority
'white' government.
Minyuku,
in Sri Lanka 10 days ago with a South African business peace mission,
said there was the magnanimous spirit of South Africans who despite
suffering gross human rights violations "dug deep into themselves
to find within their minds and hearts and manifest a spirit of forgiveness”.
"I
am not saying they have forgotten but they were able to rise above
the torture events to be able to forgive what they knew; who did
what to them and why," he said. While the country at large
listened and watched thousands of harrowing stories, the victims
were to be provided with counselling services at the commission.
"Being
in a position of trust and privilege, one has to always be careful
because in the commission we had to open wounds. We also had to
heal ... as best and as close as possible. To be able to do that
we had to provide counsellors who could counsel the victims... before
the hearings, during the hearings and after the hearings,"
he said.
The
victims were not the only ones needing psychological and emotional
support. The TRC staff too had a psychologist who counselled groups
and had individual counselling for staff members.
"For
the commissioners too we provided a service. Remember everyday they
listen to all these stories - it's nothing but death, maiming and
calculated murder. Without a support system it would have been very
difficult," the former TRC chief executive noted.
The
TRC wasn't prepared for the tales that unfolded before the commission
-- which in many ways are lessons for Sri Lanka trying to end a
bloody 21-year-old conflict. "All of us went into the commission
with expectations but we didn't know the extent to which these people
had suffered until we met with the victim. You hear these stories
of how their loved ones have been harassed - could have been the
father, the mother, the brother, the sister. It didn't end with
that. Some families were totally wiped out."
The
commission received 22,000 statements claiming gross human rights
violations of varying degrees of which 99 percent were found to
be true. The TRC probe covered a period of 33 years and took three
years to complete. The commission's work on amnesty was completed
last year and the report handed over to the President of South Africa.
It received about 7,200 amnesty applications from perpetrators including
some ministers. Anyone who fully disclosed his or her actions was
granted an amnesty.
Did
this personally cause Minyuku a lot of pain and grief? "It
was traumatic because we had short time frames and I as CEO had
to drive the process. I had to be dispassionate about all this and
focus on achieving our goal.”
Minyuku
said he hadn't had time to reflect on those three years. "I
told myself that between 1999 and 2003 I am not going to do anything
but focus on myself, debrief myself and get back to normal before
I could do anything. I have not talked about the truth commission
between 1999 and 2003."
There
was little or no revenge sought in the peace process. There wasn't
a single case where a former killer given amnesty was lynched or
killed while walking on the street, Minyuku said.
Minyuku
described the case of former police captain Brian Mitchell who ravaged
an entire community with his force. Many died at his hands. He confessed
before the commission, related everything and said he was sorry.
He didn't stop at that, indicating he wanted to go back to the community
he ruined to try and rebuild their lives. Before that he met with
community leaders and the families who welcomed him on board. Minyuku
said there were many similar cases.
Each
time I recall the TRC experience through Minyuku, I am reminded
of the pain and grief of thousands of families who lost their loved
ones not only in the war for the northeast but also during the JVP
revolt in 1988 and before. Would they ever be able to forgive ...
like the victims in South Africa?
Minyuku
said that during the humane TRC process, a blinded victim proclaimed
that "he could now see" while the family of a boy who
disappeared buried their lost son's ball of fallen hair that they
held on to for so long.
The
underlying message from the South African peace process irrespective
of the differences with what we have here - a minority group fighting
for their rights as against the majority being ruled by a minority
there and no deadly guerrilla group in the form of the LTTE to contend
with unlike in South Africa - is that the entire country was united
towards one objective - seeking peace.
If
the rallying call in South Africa during the peace process was "we
shall overcome", what should it be in Sri Lanka - "When
will we ever learn?" |