Court
action spins off CD traders boycott
By Marisa de Silva
With court cases being filed against compact disc
traders in Colombo, the Compact Disc Traders Association (CDTA)
has decided not to sell anything distributed under the M-Entertainments
label, including the sale of original albums released by popular
local artistes.
CDTA
president Sheron Samaranayake claimed that as a result of the action
taken by M-Entertainments, all members of the association had unanimously
agreed not to be involved in the sale of any products falling under
the M-Entertainments label.
Another
concern raised by Mr. Samaranayake was the inability of the general
public to afford buying original software for everyday personal
or official use. An average original software system could cost
anything between Rs. 10,000 and 300,000. So this is not just a problem
for the traders and their families but it affects the growth of
the country as a whole, he said.
For
example, he referred to 'Gamata Thakshana' a Government initiative
to give those in rural areas a basic knowledge in computers. He
said it would be impossible for them to afford original software
from now on.
He
said an average person cannot afford an original CD priced at Rs.
800 or more on his income. It is impractical to adhere to copyright
laws in our country as the economic situation is such that the majority
cannot afford to pay such high prices. Most international recording
companies aren't even aware of our existence due to the inconsequential
impact we have on their market, he said. He also said shop owners
were quite ignorant of the law and its workings and had not been
previously informed that any local distributor held the rights to
particular labels.
Mr.
Samaranayake said the CDTA strongly opposed pornography and the
copying of work of local artistes. He said of the 14 cases, 12 were
members of the association while the other two offenders had been
copying the work of local artistes as well.
Before
the raids took place, the CDTA had big plans to penetrate the local
music and film industry, obtain the copyright to various tele-dramas,
movies and songs, and produce them for a lower cost, without compromising
on quality, he said.
If
all the members invest even Rs. 100,000 each, we should have adequate
funds to start this project, said Mr. Samaranayake. They would be
able to sell these originals for much less than they cost now, as
their main aim wouldn't be to make profits but to make enough to
cover costs.
However,
he said that soon after the raid, most shops had made a huge loss
as some had closed for about a week, not knowing what was happening.
Shop owners confirmed Mr. Samaranayake's grievance of never having
received any sort of official notification from either the Government
or a corporate establishment stipulating exclusive right to certain
products.
"I
run a legitimate business and trade in the open. I've been paying
taxes to the Government ever since I started my business, nine years
ago. It's not like I am running a drug business or a brothel,"
a shop owner said.
Another
shop owner complained he lost a lot in terms of reputation and clientele.
"What was worse was that I had to lay off some of my staff
as I couldn't afford to keep them" he said.
One
shop owner said he had incurred about a Rs. 100,000 loss and lost
235 CDs as a result of the raid. "Some CDs that weren't even
on the list were seized. They just came out of the blue, without
any prior warning, strode into my shop and took whatever they wanted"
he said. There are around 500,000 dependents of the industry, in
the form of traders, staff and their families.
Pirated
CD sellers fined
Colombo Additional Magistrate S.L. Nissanka convicted
on March 10 three organisations for intellectual property rights
violations by selling pirated compact discs (CDs), VCDs and DVDs.
They were prosecuted under the provisions of the Intellectual Property
Act No. 36 of 2003.
The
plaintiff M/s Maharaja Entertainments (Pvt) Ltd., accused the organisations
of violating the copyrights of its principals, Sony Music, Columbia,
Records, Epic Pecords, Universal Music, Polygram, Poldore, Mercury,
Vergin, Capitol, EMI, Sarigam, RPG, Warner Bros and Miramax.
The
court had issued search warrants and the commercial crimes division
of the CID had raided "Ape CD Kade" situated at Borella,
"Digi Media" Colombo and "Pro Media" Colombo
and seized the counterfeit CDs, VCDs and DVDs including the computer
used for the manufacture of the copies.
The
organisations pleaded guilty to the charges and gave a further undertaking
to court that they will not violate the copyrights of the owners
in the future. It was also agreed that in the event they act in
a manner, which violates the rights of the copyrights owners, the
complainant is free to reopen the case and prosecute them for contempt
of court.
Each
of the accused paid a sum of Rs. 2,500,00 as prosecution costs in
addition to the crown costs imposed by the court. Attorneys-at-law
Kalinga Indatissa with Indika Karunajeeva, Asanga Bodaragama, Upamalika
Liyanage instructed by G.G. Arulpragasam appeared for M. Entertainments
while Muditha Abeyratna, attorney-at-law appeared for the accused.
|