French
Embassy denies Schengen visa to Lankan lecturer due to present paper
at international robotics conference in Spain
Rude shock for MURALI scientist
By Frances Bulathsinghala
A year ago, a group of undergraduate students of the Moratuwa University,
under the guidance of Dr. Thrishantha Nanayakkara, a lecturer in
the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, began what could be called
an ambitious project both for the university and the country. The
development of a robot, which would be able to detect landmines.
It was the first time that Sri Lanka was attempting such a feat.
The
project was based on almost two years of research by Dr. Nanayakkara,
with his academic experience in Japan and the U.S.A. Dr. Nanayakkara,
who did his undergraduate studies at Moratuwa University has a master's
degree and a Ph.D in robotics and system control from the Saga University,
Japan and is a post-doctoral research fellow of the Johns Hopkins
University, Washington, USA.
There
were many problems to overcome, mainly the procuring of spare parts
for making the device but by the end of last year despite difficult
scientific labour pains, the Moratuwa University Robot for Anti-Landmine
Intelligence (MURALI) was "born".
However
there was more to be done with regard to getting international recognition
for MURALI. The path seemed smooth when Dr. Nanayakkara received
the invitation to present a paper at the International Conference
of Robotics and Automation (ICRA) in Barcelona, Spain from April
18th - 22nd.
"It
was the dream of my research group who developed the mobile robot
MURALI to present the work in the world's largest robotics conference,
known as the IEEE," said Dr. Nanayakkara who had received full
funding from the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka to cover
his expenses of travel to Barcelona for the conference.
But
on the brink of his dream being realised, having purchased his ticket,
with all documents in place he was to find all their hopes shattered."I
went through the French embassy for my visa because the French embassy
issues the Schengen visa for France, Spain, and Portugal, whereas,
my passport would have to be sent to India if the process was to
be done through the Spanish Mission based in Sri Lanka as it does
not issue visas," Dr. Nanayakkara explained.
After
his first visit failed to get him a place in the queue (with the
French embassy accepting only 15 applications per day) he had telephoned
the embassy, giving a brief introduction of himself as an academic,
to obtain some help about an easier process of obtaining a visa.
He was told by the telephone operator that he had to come in the
queue 'just like anyone else'.
Dr.
Nanayakkara unravels a story of horror as he detailed how he was
later laughed at and ridiculed at the interview."The visa office
was very different from the ones I had seen before. Somebody interviewed
me while chatting with about four people who seemed to have paid
casual visits to the room. They were just chatting, laughing and
walking around. I was wondering how a visa officer could concentrate
in such an environment. One of them took my passport, browsed through
the pages and said something in French to the others that made all
of them laugh. Then, one official asked me whether I had really
visited US and Japan. It was not a question to be asked because
my student visa was on the passport," he says.
"It
was much later in the interview which had turned out to be a big
joke that I was asked the purpose of attending the conference. I
answered that it is the International Conference of Robotics and
Automation. Then she asked me what I was going to present. I said
it was a paper about a mobile robot that can walk in a field of
landmines to detect them. People in the room treated me with a sarcastic
look, as if they did not believe that Sri Lankans could do such
research especially while working in Sri Lanka," he adds.
"Despite
the utter humiliation I was subject to, I patiently explained the
relevance of my work to this conference to the interviewing officer.
I was asked to submit a few missing documents such as detailed bank
statements for the last three months by 12.30 on the following Monday
( April 11). In the guidelines for visa applicants, it mentions
documents to prove assets in Sri Lanka. It is only at the interview
that I was told that I was required to submit detailed bank statements
for three months. My documents of land deeds were not what the French
Embassy meant by assets," Dr. Nanayakkara points out. Having
submitted the documents before the deadline, he was finally asked
to come to collect his passport on April 13, two days before his
scheduled flight to Barcelona.
He
collected his passport only to find to his shock and dismay that
his visa had been rejected. "Amidst all the international recognition
of the work we had done, amidst all official documents from the
University and the National Science Foundation, amidst all invitation
letters that quoted web-sites where my name was displayed among
the list of invitees, a visa officer could block the massive opportunity
for my country and my career," says an utterly disgusted Dr.
Nanayakkara.
His
desperate queries of why he was not granted the visa had not been
answered by the Embassy officials. Dr. Nanayakkara then called the
Dean of the Faculty of Engineering, University of Moratuwa, Professor
Ananda Jayawardena who called the Consulate General to find out
what was wrong with the visa application.
Professor
Jayawardena when contacted by The Sunday Times said that his calls
were answered by a Consulate General who refused give any explanations."I
told the Consulate General that this conference was of utmost importance
to the scientific research programme in the University in particular
and the country in general. Dr. Nanayakkara is one of the most committed
academics of the university and I was very sad that his hard work
and total commitment was going to be destroyed by something as simple
as getting a visa. I explained this to the Consulate General who
was not interested in listening to me. Neither did he make any sense.
He told me that he was 'not saying that he cannot issue the visa,
only that he was not in a position to grant the visa", Professor
Jayawardena says.
Meanwhile
one of the highest-ranking officials in the French Embassy who spoke
to The Sunday Times on the basis of anonymity said his officers
are 'definitely not' capable of racist behaviour as alleged by Dr.
Nanayakkara. Asked if the Embassy had initiated an inquiry, he responded
with a quick 'of course'.
The
official spent twenty minutes explaining that Dr. Nanayakkara did
not call the Embassy before applying for his visa. When asked why
an academic, who was in possession of all the necessary documents
(including a much-stamped passport), state sponsorship and details
of the international conference he was attending should call before,
the official merely stated that a call 'helps'.
He
went onto explain that the embassy maintains a 'working relationship'
with professionals and that it is 'understood' that they call beforehand.
Claiming ignorance of phone calls made by the Dean of the Faculty
of Engineering, Professor Ananda Jayawardena to seek the embassy's
help following the refusal of the visa, he added that he may have
called the 'visa section'. 'No, no it is not the visa section that
he should call it is the Cultural section,'said the official.
About
Sri Lanka's lost chance in the sphere of scientific invention, he
chose not to comment.
Not
free from mistakes: French Embassy replies
"Even if this Embassy receives 3,200 visa applications a year
and visas are issued to all kinds of applicants without discrimination
according to Schengen rules, we do not have the pretension to be
free from mistakes," the Embassy of France said in a press
release.
Their
decision-making process involves at least two officers (three for
complicated cases) who take a common decision, the release added.
The Embassy has also introduced new visa procedures with the company
V.F.S being entrusted with the opening of a visa application centre
as a focal point for all information regarding short-stay visas
to France, Spain and Portugal. "From the 16th of May 2005,
V.F.S, No. 367, R.A.de Mel Mawatha (Duplication Road), Colombo 3
will carry out the distribution and receipt of short stay visa application
forms, scheduling of appointments and the returning of passports
which would in turn prevent applicants from facing the inconvenience
of standing in a queue for a lengthy periods of time.."
The
release also stated that there exists a system where those in the
academic and artistic fields could first obtain an appointment from
the Cultural Section and those in business from the Trade Commission
of the Embassy. "During this interview all relevant documents
are checked if needed, prior to being sent to the visa section.
Even if V.F.S will be handling the short stay visa applications
in future, a previous appointment with the relevant department of
the Embassy is always possible before a professional trip to France."
The
Embassy said it hoped these clarifications would prevent visa applications
from having to face similar experiences. |