Caught
in the middle
Domestic violence is one of the gravest social problems that society
faces. It ruins families, destroys individuals and above all damages
children’s lives. N. Dilshath Banu takes a closer look at
a burning issue of our times
Sam*(14)
is the eldest in a family of four. His dad is a strong Anglican
and mum, a devoted Catholic. But both his parents got married without
any problems from their families. Sam says he’s very happy
to have an understanding family, where any kind of problem can be
discussed without hesitation.
However,
the difference in religious philosophy in his family makes Sam and
his brother pretty uncomfortable. Both his parents go to separate
churches, even during Christmas, and usually, matters related to
religion are not spoken about at home.
Sam
recalls that once he questioned his mother on a matter of doctrine,
when his father was at home. His mother’s answer clashed with
his father’s and an argument ignited.
“I
was very confused. If my parents are from completely different backgrounds,
I can understand what they are going through. But being in the same
religion in different sects, I don’t understand why such simple
differences become a problem,” says Sam and he adds that since
then, he has never spoken about matters concerning religion at home,
but at the same time he knows that these arguments won’t affect
his parents’ marriage.
Sumitha*(18)
says that she has a happy family, although her parents got married
without the approval of their parents. But when her grandparents,
from both sides visit, she rarely comes to the living room.
“My
mother complains that I never speak to her family members and my
father says it’s the other way around. It’s not that
I don’t want to talk to my grandparents, but very simple things
are enough for my parents to start a fight when my grandparents
are in. I used to get very scared, but now I don’t take those
arguments too seriously.”
It
happens at some point in our family. We have to witness an uneasy
situation, which has nothing to do with us, but which involves us.
It’s true that, when our parents argue, we feel very lonely
and confused.
“Arguments
and fights that happen once in a blue moon don’t have an impact
on children, unless the concerned child is very sensitive. It also
depends on the age of the child, because a little child could get
scared when they see an argument and hear the tone adults use during
an argument. During these times, children must understand that parents
are humans too. They have their own similarities and differences,
like all of us,” says Anne Abayasekara, a well-known counsellor.
However,
there are families that live under the gloomy cloud of much bigger
suffocation, loneliness and violence than ordinary arguments. Guilt,
shame and stigma silence this fact. Most often, many who are victims
endure repetitive victimisation in a situation of domestic violence.
Domestic
violence can be a physical assault and battering, or it can be psychological
as with constant criticism, refusal to acknowledge or support or
the deliberate use of silence, perhaps weeks at a time. It is behaviour
that controls the abused partner and most of the time, their children,
for the purpose of establishing and maintaining authority. It can
range from constant put downs, dismissals or ridicule, to controlling
behaviour, shoving, beating and threatening. Yet many parents live
in situations of domestic violence, as a result of us – their
children.
Prema*
(22) says that, she has witnessed constant arguments at home between
her parents. “I feel helpless. I feel very bad that I cannot
do anything about it.” Prema has had bad experiences when
she tried to stop these fights.
She
adds, “The problem with my parents is that they don’t
consult each other when problems arise. Each one takes different
decisions on the same problem. I don’t know whether it’s
the lack of time or the lack of money.” Currently, Prema is
living with her older sister and now she’s so glad that she’s
free from verbal violence.
For
the past eighteen years, Melani* lived a double life. Outside, she
looked happy and academically successful. But behind the well-decorated
curtains of her house, she was under constant fear – fear
of the unknown, of loneliness and many fears that she cannot even
recognize herself. “I wish I was never born,” she says.
She
has witnessed her father beating her mother and witnessed her mother’s
disfigured face, depressed outlook and anxiety. She doesn’t
understand why her father gets mad and she says that he starts a
fight with her for no reason. Yet her mother still opted to live
with her father. In many instances, she wanted her mother to complain
to the police, but her mother doesn’t want to take that step.
Once Melani thought of lodging a complaint, but her mother stopped
her.
“I
don’t know why she wants to live with him, even after all
the beatings and verbal torture. My friends say that once I finish
my A/levels I am free. Then I’ll find a job and move out of
the house. I feel sorry for my mother, but I am going to decide
what is best for my life,” says Melani.
Melani
may be able to move out of her house (hopefully she will find a
peaceful life), but her fears will not move away from her heart
so easily. “I don’t think I’ll ever get married.
I am very scared to even witness marriage ceremonies, I don’t
know why,” says Melani, leaving many such questions in her
tone.
Some
cultures and societies permit intimidation of women and the use
of force to preserve the status of the male. Twenty-eight-year-old
Gihan*, who’s now happily married and working in a leading
company, reflects on his story. “I was a failure in relationships
in the past, especially when I was in my early twenties. I didn’t
know why women didn’t understand me. I had few girl friends,
before I found my wife, but all these girls couldn’t stay
with me for even one month. And I didn’t have many friends
to seek guidance from.”
Gihan
recalls that once he tried to commit suicide as a result of a broken
relationship, but was somehow saved by one of his friends. And through
this friend, he attended private counselling. After a few years,
his entire self changed. “I understood what was wrong with
me. Since my childhood, I always saw my father doing everything
by intimidation and violence. I saw how my mother was very scared
and even my sister couldn’t do anything. I learnt that when
you control everyone, especially women you can win. As a result,
I was very possessive. I detested anyone who had a different opinion
and always wanted my friends to agree with me. I also thought women
were always weak and men should keep women under them. This is why
I failed in my past relationships with not only women, but potential
friends,” he says.
“If
fights and arguments are continuous and turns into domestic violence,
it undermines the child’s security and confidence in their
parents, that they will always be there for them. It’s a state
of uncertainty, which drives children away from their bond with
parents. When children tend to see violence during their upbringing,
they tend to integrate violent behaviour into their lifestyle as
well,” says Mrs. Abayasekara.
According
to Mrs. Abayasekara, the main reason for domestic violence is that
one of the concerned parties is unable to control anger and when
anger turns into rage, it leads to verbal and physical attack.
“The
situation gets worse when parties keep on arguing. I also found
that some of these people, even after apologising tend to use violence
again and again. These people cannot control themselves and need
some kind of psychological back-up. In such situations, it’s
very, very difficult for children, as they are in a situation where
their home rotates in the cycle of tension – abuse, relief;
abuse, relief; abuse, relief. Yet many mothers tend to stay with
their abusive families, thinking it will ruin the lives of their
children if they break up with their husbands. Some-times, these
women try to pacify the situation by blaming themselves as responsible
for provoking their husbands’ anger.”
Says
Mrs. Abaya-sekara, “It’s very sad that many parents
enrich their children with all the best material things the world
has to offer, like tuition, swimming lessons, elocution classes,
drama classes, thinking that these things will keep the children
happy when their home life is unpleasant. This situation will affect
the entire life of the children. Only a few are able to overcome
the traumatic experience with courage and come up in life, but the
rest will bear the scars created by this situation.
As
a result of domestic violence, some children, especially girls,
fall for the first man who’s nice to them. Or else, some girls
hate their fathers, and it will apply to all men. This is the result
of witnessing their fathers’ behaviour towards their mothers’.
Sometimes, they may not consider marrying, thinking that their husbands’
might treat them in the same way as their fathers’ did their
mothers.”
Having
identified domestic violence as a crime against humanity, society
is now open to stop this violence. Even the immediate victims of
domestic violence can lodge a complaint to the police and take matters
to courts, but Mrs. Abayasekara admits that children have very little
choice in this matter. “How many children are in a position
to move away from home? Even if they did, the parents may not want
their children to be living with their aunts and uncles. This situation
makes the children really helpless. They’re stuck.”
She
says that there is no definite solution for children caught up in
domestic violence, until they are able to move out of their house.
But Mrs. Abayasekara adds that children can talk about the matter
with a trusted elder person, who can influence the parents. “It
can be your aunt, uncle or even your teacher. Domestic violence
is not a silent topic now. If you don’t find any support in
your family circle, you can choose to seek help from professional
organisations.”
“Women
In Need (WIN) is an NGO that helps out specifically in situations
of domestic violence. WIN gives advice for both parties concerning
domestic violence.”
WIN
can be contacted on 2575765. (*Names have been changed) |