IMF
report says govt. still abusing captive funds
A new International Monetary Fund report has said Sri Lanka has
made some headway in certain financial reforms but that there has
been little progress in eliminating the government’s reliance
on public corporations for cheap budget financing.The report, called
‘Sri Lanka: Report on the Observance of Standards and Codes
(Rosc)—Fiscal Transparency Module—Update’, also
called for more openness and transparency in government finances.
“There
has been little progress made in eliminating the quasi-fiscal activities
of public corporations,” the report said. It noted that following
the sharp rise in world oil prices, the authorities suspended the
petroleum pricing formula that ensured domestic prices reflected
market prices in 2004.
Prices
are now administered with periodic ad hoc adjustments. The government
pays subsidies to the petroleum companies for the difference between
the underlying formula price and the administered price. Likewise,
Ceylon Electricity Board (CEB) prices continue to be administered
at below-cost levels and with cross-subsidization between industrial
and domestic sectors.
“Despite
the below market pricing of their petroleum inputs, CEB continues
to make substantial losses that are financed through borrowing from
public financial corporations and arrears to government and other
public corporations,” the report said. It said many of the
most important issues highlighted by the original ROSC, published
in October 2002, in particular in the area of reforming relations
between the government and public enterprises, remain to be addressed.
“Particular
priority should be given to developing and publishing a systematic
accounting of implicit and contingent liabilities, moving away from
using public corporations for quasi-fiscal activities and reducing
the reliance of the government on captive sources of cheap budget
and public enterprise financing.”
Producing
consolidated accounts of central and provincial governments should
also be pursued, in particular if the government is planning further
reforms to the system of intergovernmental fiscal relations, the
report said.
The
report was prepared after the IMF staff reviewed developments in
the areas pertaining to Sri Lanka’s observance of fiscal transparency
practices with a view to updating changes in current practices,
or describing the implementation of the ROSC’s recommendations.
The
original ROSC emphasized the importance of subjecting public corporations
to market discipline, developing an overarching privatization strategy,
and reforming domestic financing policies to reduce reliance on
and increase the transparency of borrowing from captive sources
of financing such as the Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF).
The
new report said that the implementation of ROSC recommendations
has been affected by external and political developments such as
the general elections in April 2004 which it said “caused
a hiatus” in policy implementation while a new coalition was
formed.
The
new government had a different approach, which has led to changes
in some of the policies described in the original ROSC. Furthermore,
the December 26, 2004 tsunami has diminished the short-term priority
attached to fiscal management reforms, the report said.
It
said the 2003 Fiscal Management (Responsibility) Act (FMRA) has
improved the transparency of government fiscal policy but that the
focus of public enterprise reform has changed from privatization
to restructuring.
The
14 largest public corporations have been placed under the control
of the Strategic Enterprise Management Agency (SEMA) that has the
objective of improving performance of these agencies through restructuring
while retaining public ownership.
“The
government has recently announced a policy that privatization of
any of these agencies will require a two-thirds majority in parliament,”
the report said. However, it said that some progress has been made
in preparing key public enterprises for the introduction of market
discipline.
Non-price
competition in the petroleum sector has been introduced through
the introduction of a foreign-owned second company and negotiations
are underway to introduce a third player through further divestiture
of the assets of the state-owned petroleum ompany.
A plan
is being developed to improve the efficiency of CEB through the
separation of its generation, transmission and distribution functions
into individual companies. The report said the government continues
to use public financial corporations to subsidize the cost of budgetary
financing.
“Rupee
securities and foreign-currency denominated bonds continue to be
placed with state-owned banks and financial corporations, often
at below market rates. State-owned banks have often been used to
provide financing to loss-making public corporations.”
The
report said that while there was some improvement in the availability
of information the budget documentation does not contain systematic
quantification or analysis of tax expenditures. In 2004, the Budget
Estimates document included detailed information on actual and projected
revenue, grants, and expenditures of provincial councils. These
however were not consolidated with information on central government
activities.
Information
was also provided on transfers to public enterprises, but not on
their overall financial position. “However, the 2005 budget
documentation did not include any of this detail,” the IMF
said. “The budget documentation only contains information
concerning central government debt and does not address overall
public sector debt.”Central government borrowing that is on-lent
to development banks for private sector lending is included in budget
estimates, but excluded from the economic classification of the
budget outturn even though it adds directly to the stock of central
government debt.
“There
has been considerable progress in a number of areas since the original
ROSC,” the report said. “However, the gains remain fragile,
as demonstrated by the reduction in information provided alongside
the budget in 2005.”
Many of the most important issues highlighted by the original ROSC,
in particular in the area of reforming relations between the government
and public enterprises, remain to be addressed. |