Ranil’s
message not getting through
Esmond Wickremesinghe, press magnate and the power behind the throne
in many a United National Party (UNP) regime, once told his second
son Ranil, then a young minister, over dinner: “I have done
many political campaigns all my life, but one thing I have still
not worked out is, what goes on in the mind of the Sri Lankan voter
before he votes”.
The
older Wickremesinghe was a fashionable Marxist in his youth, and
later became the Managing Director of Lake House, which was so powerful
when the UNP ruled, it used to be said “what Lake House says
today, the Government does tomorrow”- not what the Government
does today, Lake House says tomorrow as a newspaper is meant to
do.
He
was privy to, and very much part of the UNP leaders of his time,
their backstage battles and their election campaigns. Hence his
comments must have been borne out of the fickleness of the Sri Lankan
voter who in those days changed governments every five years, no
matter what, so much so it became known as the ‘thattu maaru’
system. After more than thirty years in active politics, being twice
the Prime Minister and twice a presidential candidate, Ranil Wickremesinghe
must surely be pondering the answer to his late father’s remark
many years ago. But, if the campaign of the UNP is the yardstick,
the party hasn’t figured it out either.
It
was convenient for UNPers to say, after the 1999 presidential election
defeat of Ranil Wickremesinghe to Chandrika Kumaratunga that the
LTTE bomb attack on the President ensured her victory, especially
after Kumaratunga’s brilliant post-explosion performance on
national television, one eye-swathed in bandages and tears streaming
down her cheeks. Here was a lady who had given an eye and all she
was asking for was your vote!
What
they were implying was that had the bomb attack not occurred, Ranil
Wickremesinghe would have won the election. That simply is not true.
President Kumaratunga’s majority was more than 700,000 votes,
or more than eight per cent of the valid votes. To say this percentage
of voters was swayed by sympathy to Kumaratunga is to assume they
are extra-ordinarily naive.
What
the bomb attack did do however was to push President Kumaratunga
over the ‘fifty per cent plus one vote’ hurdle, where
she received just over 94,000 votes above the required number. That
could well have been the difference from the sympathy vote, thus
not having to resort to a second round of counting.
More
recent post-election analyses on the poor performance of the UNP
has been focused on why the party lost the 2004 general election
after receiving a mandate from the people in 2001. That is indeed
relevant because the UNP’s main rival, the Sri Lanka Freedom
Party (SLFP) contested that poll in alliance with the Janatha Vimukthi
Peramuna (JVP), the kind of combine that the UNP is up against in
this election — plus whatever vote base there is left of the
Jathika Hela Urumaya (JHU) of course.
The
general consensus then was that the government was unpopular because
the cost of living was sky-rocketing with no relief measures in
sight while there were also reports of widespread corruption about
which Wickremesinghe, although being ‘Mr. Clean’ himself,
was doing nothing about. Add to this the poor platform performances
of the UNP speakers in general and Wickremesinghe in particular,
pitted against the considerable charisma of Chandrika Kumaratunga
and you have a recipe for disaster.
This
time around, the equation is significantly different. The rising
cost of living is a huge plus factor for the UNP and the charges
of corruption are directed at Prime Minister Mahinda Rajapakse whose
charisma is fire-fly like in comparison to Kumaratunga’s.
And yet, reports suggest that the Premier is doing alright, especially
in the ‘south’ at this point of the race. What then
is not clicking in the UNP campaign?
Parakramabahu
era
Wickremesinghe’s advisors have correctly identified that the
previous campaign did not appeal to the village based, mostly Sinhalese
Buddhist voter. So, they thought they would roll back the years,
drop the make-Sri Lanka-a-Singapore call, and revert to the Parakramabahu
era, offer to build the largest Buddhist ‘dagoba’ in
the world, teach Buddhist monks Pali and send them overseas to propagate
Buddhism. Throw in Bandula Gunawardena’s coconut pluckers
using mobile phones to find out how many coconuts they need to pluck
and Rajitha Senaratne wanting to dress up farmers in denims jeans
and Nike T-shirts, and Wickremesinghe’s campaign is the laughing
stock, especially when at the mercy of the oratory of the vitriolic
Wimal Weerawansa.
It
was in 1999 that Wickremesinghe promised gold chains and chewing
gum to the farmers at Polonnaruwa and came a cropper. But it appears
that Wickremesinghe’s strategists have not learnt a lesson
from the past. They don’t seem to understand that somehow,
Parakramabahu in denim jeans is not an image most Sri Lankans, be
they rural or urban, would be comfortable with.
The tragedy is that the message that Wickremesinghe is trying to
convey — that he is a politician who has a vision for the
country built on peace and economic prosperity for all segments
of society — is lost in the mad milieu of mass communications
while ‘Mahinda aiya’ (or ‘Mahinda maama’,
if it is children who are interviewing him) gallops ahead by default.
The
brief that Wickremesinghe is arguing before the jury of the Sri
Lankan voter is not a bad one: he says he will strive to provide
his countrymen with a decent standard of living, a modern economy
that can stand up to the rigours of the world market, an economy
that will not just be providing housemaids to the Arabs but be a
robust economy away from the clutches and clichés of our
glorious agricultural past because farmers today are not kings,
but paupers committing suicide because they cannot service their
bank loans.
Wickremesinghe
contends that our economy is so dependent on foreign aid that, however
much one may shout at the World Bank and the IMF, ultimately even
the great Marxist Finance Minister Dr. N.M. Perera had to pay pooja
at the altar of these Washington-based Siamese-twins and even the
Nationalist JVP couldn’t quite ‘pull the plug’
from the World Bank though they promised to do so.
Where
the UNP ers is when it portrays the brave new world for the rural
farmer as being one of Nike shirts and denims jeans. There is a
point in the UNP message – that they want to uplift the ‘status’
of the farmer, but there is a mis-match in conveying it across.
Our rural farmer will be quite happy to re-pay his loans, buy a
new tractor, and perhaps some good clothes under Wickremesinghe’s
economic reforms. The transformation from ‘amudey’ (span-cloth)
to the denim will perhaps eventually come, but that is not how the
UNP message came across.
Wickremesinghe
is also probably wasting his money when his campaign is run predominantly
electronically -- through expensive advertisements mostly in private
television networks which have a lesser area of coverage than the
state media which are being blatantly misused for ‘Mahinda
maama’-style interviews. Indeed, the UNP would do well to
realise that this election is not being decided in urban areas where
private television networks have their audience -- or by mobile
phone owners with SMS capability!
Talking
to Tigers
Then, Wickremesinghe says he will talk to the Tiger rebels, but
not surrender the sovereignty of this island-state and see it divided;
he says that he will negotiate with the rebels, but put the final
solution to the people to accept or reject at a Referendum; that
he will bring peace as he did with the Ceasefire Agreement (CFA)
with all its flaws, and in the long-run ensure neutralisation of
the LTTE as a guerrilla organisation and have them return to the
democratic field, just as the JVP did; that Federalism with all
its faults is as far as he will go, and that it is worth offering
this in return for permanent peace with the separatists. Valid arguments,
but is the message getting through?
In
reply, Mahinda Rajapakse says that Ranil Wickremasinghe is dividing
the country and that strikes a chord, more so with the Sinhala Buddhist
voter. What the UNP has not highlighted enough is that it was Ranil
Wickremesinghe who brought about the Ceasefire Agreement (CFA) which
in turn brought about relative peace and forced the Tigers to walk
a tightrope constantly looking down at the ‘international
safety net’. When the Tigers step out of line, they fall into
the net and are placed back on the tight rope, most recently so
vis-à-vis the European Union travel ban.
Of
course, the CFA is not ideal and the Tigers do blatantly transgress
its terms but isn’t it better than bombs at the Central Bank,
the Pettah bus stand, the Dehiwela railway station and yes, the
bombs at the Dalada Maligawa and the massacres at the Sri Maha Bodhi
and Arantalawa? And the over-running of military camps? Isn’t
it better than not knowing whether your father or son will return
home from work or school in the evening even if they are living
in Maharagama, Matara or Medawachchiya?
It
doesn’t take rocket science or an advertising genius to realise
that a campaign which takes voters back to those uncertain days
before the CFA through images, video clips, posters and campaign
speeches will have an impact -- much more so than hair-splitting
arguments about the merits and demerits of federalism versus the
unitary state. But surprise, surprise, the UNP has chosen not to
go down that route, probably scared away by the JVP-led campaign
that the UNP is trying to win by frightening the voter.
Then
there is this issue of Wickremesinghe’s ‘image’:
his smile appears contrived, his wave has an awkwardness about it
and his voice does not resonate as much as the deep baritones of
Mahinda Rajapakse, they say. In general, he is not the ‘pat-you-on
the back’ politician. And he is surrounded by Colombo-centric
men with a private sector mentality.
The
answer to this from the UNP campaign appears to be to compel Wickremesinghe
to do what he is uncomfortable at doing. And the result is plenty
of video footage for Rupavahini to use -- and repeat ad nauseum,
such as when Wickremesinghe plays the rabaana -- for a picture is
worth a thousand words.
Maybe
the UNP could view again the interview Wickremesinghe had with the
Maha Sangha. He was calm, collected and composed, handled the questions
with ease and gave the impression of being a confident and competent
leader. As he was speaking to a small audience and that too to members
of the Maha Sangha, there was no arm waving histrionics or belligerent
slogan shouting. The net effect was far more impressive than his
platform oratory.
One
recalls that J. R. Jayewardene had a similar handicap -- and also
had a limited command of the Sinhala language -- but in his latter
political career this was hardly noticed as JR took to delivering
matter of fact speeches sans the gesticulations and gyrations. What
he lacked in flamboyance, he made up for in brevity and wit. This
should be food for thought to Ranil Wickremesinghe -- he is better
off emulating his mentor and uncle on the campaign platform rather
than try to do a Wimal Weerawansa impression.
And
he could get help from those who can do what he cannot -- the Lokubandaras,
Premadasas, Bakeer Markars, Hemakumara Nanayakkaras- -- to articulate
his vision in Sinhala, so that it is understood by the masses and
not misrepresented by the hostile state media. And, to dispel the
notion that he is in the clutches of his secretive inner coterie,
he would do well to enlist the support of those party faithfuls
who do still have a following: the Sirisena Coorays, Ranjith Atapattus,
Harold Heraths et al, who will also serve if they merely stand and
wait on the political platform. And it will help take away the hostility
directed towards the jhonny-come-latelys of the UNPs, the Moragodas
and the Peirises and their ‘padanamas’( Foundations
).
Not
much has been made of the fact the fact that Ranil Wickremesinghe
does hail from a family with long traditional connections with the
historic Kelaniya Raja Maha Vihara; that his personal knowledge
of the Buddha's Doctrine, and of Buddhism, the religion of the great
majority of the people, is far greater than those who carry trays
of flowers and worship at temples for the cameras. Wickremesinghe’s
interview with the Maha Sangha was a step in the right direction,
but it needs to be followed up.
So,
if the people of Sri Lanka see Ranil Wickremesinghe as an urbane
politician who is cut away from the realities of the common man
and his difficulties and his aspirations, as one who is going to
sell the country to the LTTE rebels and hand-over one-third of the
nation to them on a silver tray, and whose economic theorems and
theories are good for America, and not for Sri Lanka, then it is
largely the fault of his campaign machine.
Need
to go forth
Indeed, if the Bandaranaikes are accusing Mahinda Rajapaksa of giving
them the ‘karapincha’ treatment, then to use a similar
turn of phrase, Ranil Wickremesinghe is your ‘karawila’
candidate: bitter to swallow but good for you.
But
with only 32 precious days to go for the poll, Ranil Wickremesinghe
and his campaign minders will need every minute of it to trek to
the backwaters of Sri Lanka, instead of remaining in the cold comfort
of their air-conditioned offices in Colombo to spread the message
of their Leader. Relying on a few television advertisements and
posters to do the job, is just not going to be enough. Karawila,
we know, packaged and labelled in a bottle, doesn’t sell as
well unless properly marketed.
Wickremesinghe
is seasoned enough to know that in a Presidential election, he must
have the votes of rural Sri Lanka, and those of the minorities.
He’s got the latter in the bag. What about the former? Surely,
he must go after those crucial votes unless he ends up as the only
UNP leader never to have become the leader of the country.
(Next
week; The Rajapakse campaign for the presidency) |