Key
players piece together the peace process
Negotiating Peace In Sri Lanka, Efforts,
failures and lessons. Volume I & II.Editor: Dr. Kumar Rupesinghe.
Published by The Foundation for Co-Existence. Reviewed by Shimali
Senanayake
The
most valuable lessons of peace making are learnt from failures of
peace building and in that sense, these two books are a repository
of knowledge of past peace making processes not from the point of
view of external commentators and academics but from those who had
hands-on involvement.
Both volumes trace four failed Sri Lankan peace efforts and the
latest bid to negotiate with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam
or LTTE, toward a negotiated settlement to the ethnic conflict.
The
launch of the books, particularly Volume II, was significant and
timely as it coincided with the resumption of peace talks between
the government and the LTTE in February, after a lapse of three
years. But more so, ahead of round II set for April 19-21.
Much
has been said and written about Sri Lanka's peace efforts, more
by "peace pundits," than those who have been involved
in the process. Irrespective of their literary quality, these accounts
in the form of papers, memoirs and diaries are crucial to understand
and document history on one hand, and comprehend the complexities
of an intractable conflict as ours is, on the other.
Volume
I originally published in 1998, offers an insightful examination
of past attempts to bring peace to Sri Lanka from 1985 to 2000.
The first volume was republished with additions of several new chapters,
concentrating specifically on President Chandrika Kumaratunga's
regime. The original volume is re-arranged into three sections,
each encompassing a different phase of the peace process initiated
by Presidents J.R. Jayewardene, R. Premadasa and Chandrika Kumaratunga.
Ring-side
view
What stands out in the second volume -and I will be paying particular
attention to Volume II - is that the chapters and interviews are
compiled by key players who managed and designed the 2002-2003 peace
process.
Among the 16 authors, are the government's former chief negotiator
G.L. Peiris, peace negotiator and former head of the Secretariat
for Coordinating the Peace Process Bernard A. B. Goonetilleke, former
Prime Minister's secretary Bradman Weerakoon, former Defence Secretary
Austin Fernando, peace envoy and now Norway's International Development
Minister Erik Solheim and head of the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission
Hagrup Haukland.
The
focus here is on peace efforts initiated by the United National
Party (UNF) government under Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe,
the co-habitation arrangement with President Chandrika Kumaratunga
from December 2001 until the new United National Front government
was elected to office in April 2004.
What is noticeably missing however, is the LTTE's perspective. Although
articles by the late Dharmaratnam Sivaram, an astute political analyst
and freelance journalist, have attempted to present Tamil perspective,
a protagonist view, would have been undoubtedly useful.
Similarly,
the volume also failed to rope in the so called "peace detractors,"
particularly the Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna and the Jathika Hela
Urumaya, the strongest critics of the Norwegian-backed process.
Theirs is a necessary view, without which, experience has shown
it would be difficult to proceed on any path toward a negotiated
settlement. It would have been sufficient if at least a chapter
could have been added by a contributor who articulates the views
similar to that of the JVP or JHU.
However,
it's this second volume that veers more to the present and can be
a tool for the latest peace initiative under President Mahinda Rajapaksa,
currently aimed at strengthening or revamping a ceasefire agreement
signed under the former UNF government.
The
book espouses the tenets of conflict resolution drawing parallels
from conflict nations like Northern Ireland to Guatemala. This may
have been unthinkable in its application six months ago, but recent
moves indicate greater attention being paid by the present regime
to learn from these processes.
Insider
moments
The reader is given an "insider," perspective to the Wickremesinghe-led
process that at the time was criticized for being shrouded in secrecy
and lacking transparency.
There
are some interesting accounts of what happened behind the scenes,
some revealed for the first time. Weerakoon, who as the premier's
secretary and spearheading work connected to relief, rehabilitation
and reconstruction in the north and east, spells out his side of
the story about the controversy over communication equipment imported
into the country by the LTTE and the subsequent storm it raised.
Peace
envoy Solheim, who has been intrinsically involved in the process
since 1999 and most fiercely criticized, in an interview vehemently
denies that Norway has any stake or intentions in Sri Lanka and
goes on to elucidate how he came about to do what he does here and
weathered the storm.
Goonetilleke and Fernando provide insights to how the cease-fire
was sighed, much in haste, and a tacit account of the difficult
manoeuvres under a hostile president.
Points
to ponder
What makes this book particularly timely and useful is that it has
the ingredients to aid the present negotiating effort under President
Rajapaksa by exploiting the foundation laid by the previous regime
while also learning from the drawbacks and failures of that process.
The
book comes out as championing the UNF's peace bid but at the same
time the authors also highlight where the parties were deterred
and what potholes to avoid in future. The critique provided on these
issues though is unmistakably sympathetic and will remain an important
missing link in the volume.
With
all its shortcomings _ and undoubtedly there are shortcomings -the
CFA is largely considered the bed-rock of the peace process and
a watershed from which efforts are made to transform it into a sustainable
peace process leading to a negotiated settlement.
Efforts
to this end have failed so far, which makes the book all the more
important. The book can also be viewed as a database or glossary
of the UNF peace bid with a comprehensive chronology at the conclusion.
So much has been written on Sri Lanka's peace efforts, here and
overseas, but it wouldn't be an overstatement to say there is much
to learn and reflect from this book.
As Dr. Rupesinghe himself says, "No process design is perfect
and it will always be a question of trial and error. But we cannot
rely on trial and error approach and elevate pragmatism to such
an extent where so much is at stake. Learning by doing is a risky
enterprise when the country's very future is at stake."
Compact
book on literary works and literary giants
Literary Essays, by. W.A.Abeysinghe.
Published by Sarasavi Publishers, Nugegoda. Price: Rs. 125. Reviewed
by W.T.A. Leslie Fernando
Reputed
poet, lyricist, translator, prose writer and literary critic W.A.
Abeysinghe's latest work is "Literary Essays", a collection
of presentations he had made at colloquiums, articles written to
journals and extracts from other publications. This is his 144th
book.
In
the essay "The Sinhala Novel as a medium of Cultural Expression"
W.A. Abeysinghe submits that literary creation is a social activity
because it is guided both consciously and unconsciously by the system
of ethics and culture in which it is rooted. As such the novel is
a vehicle of society's cultural expression. Novels like "Yali
Upannaemi", "Hevanella" and "Aprasanna Kathavak"
were not realistic because they went contrary to our cultural ethos,
whereas later novels like K. Jayatilleke's "Charitha Thunak",
Leel Gunasekera's "Pethsama" and "Athsana",
Eva Ranweera's "Sedona", A.V. Suraweera's "Heiyyammaruwa"
and Jayasena Jayakody's "Aswenna" were a portrayal of
our social life, reflecting aspects of our indigenous culture.
In
the chapter dealing with realism in literature, Abeysinghe emphasises
that presenting a work naturally and authentically is not realism.
The artist unveils realistic life in a complex pattern and in the
process he may even resort to circumlocution and exaggerations such
as Leo Tolstoy's "How much land does a man need". In Akutagawa's
"Rashoman" even the dead man's soul speaks out.
He
adds that one who dismisses Jathaka stories as nonsense sees only
the exaggerations in the stories and is blind to the subtleties
of human behaviour portrayed. In the essay "The Sinhala Poem
- Some random Thoughts" the author refers to the clash between
the Colombo poets and those of the Peradeniya School. He observes
that both groups squabbled over the mere superficial elements of
poetry rather than over the substance.
Abeysinghe
is happy that the controversy has submerged and young poets today
have succeeded in communicating their feelings and ideas not only
through traditional rhymed verse, free verse and lyrical verse but
also through many other vehicles.
In
two essays on Anton Chekhov, W.A. Abeysinghe discusses how his short
stories and short novels have considerably fashioned the theme,
mood and fashion of our short story.
Coming
to our own Martin Wickremasinghe, Abeysinghe places him as an intellectual
giant in the 20th century. Martin Wickremasinghe has produced nearly
2000 pieces of writings both in Sinhala and in English, including
nearly 90 books.
W.A.
Abeysinghe categorises Martin Wickremasinghe's writing into three
groups namely journalistic, creative and academic. As a journalist
he was an erudite personality who wrote on a variety of subjects
ranging from Sinhala culture to Indian Vedanta philosophy and Western
rationalism.
As
a fiction writer he was responsible for the emergence of the realistic
novel and shaping novels and short stories into a serious form of
art. Through his critical works and academic essays he proved himself
an intellectual par excellence.
Abeysinghe
hails W.D. Amaradeva for being able to create the correct idiom
in musical expression. Although in the quest for a form of true
Sinhala music he drew inspiration from his pioneers, Ananda Samarakone
and Sunil Santha, it was W.D. Amaradeva who fused the Indian Raghadhari
form into the traditional Sinhala folk music.
In
his review of "Seegiri Gee Siri" by W.J.M. Lokubandara,
Abeysinghe finds that the author has selected 127 verses of Siigiri
graffiti and has classified them into carefully planned 14 topics.
Lokubandara then discusses various aspects of Sigiriya poetic tradition
that Abeysinghe finds are deep, rich and incisive interpretation
of Sigiri verses. This book contains material on literature and
literary giants that one would have to gather by reading many books.
Abeysinghe has presented most of his works in Sinhala, though he
has an equally good command of the English language.
Little
book that shows what to say and how to say it
Sri Lanka Words and Phrases, 7th edition.
Published by Arjuna Hulugalle Dictionaries. Price: Rs. 250
The title of this small book is Sri Lanka Words and Phrases. Its
front cover in white, orange and yellow marked 106 has a simple
outline of a map of Sri Lanka.
It
has been used by thousands of tourists and expatriates since 1998.
The new edition contains 197 pages.
It
is invaluable because it gives the English word with the pronunciation
in the Sinhala script and the Sinhala translation with the pronunciation
in the Roman (English) script.
Themes
include 'shopping', 'describing people', 'vegetables', 'hospital',
'hotel', 'on the road', 'numbers and quantities'. The reader can
effortlessly find a phrase he needs and pronounce the Sinhala words
and expressions often surprising the listener!
Language
companions are popular because they make conversation and understanding
of cultures and customs easy. Not everyone is a linguist and can
speak the language of others. A knowledge of the language of the
other shows a respect for him or her and opens doors to hearts and
minds.
It
gets one out of many a crisis and adds humour to verbal exchanges.
The Sri Lankan student learning English will find this particular
small book an important companion. |