Corporate
Affairs
Corruption, losses and public accountability
By Sunil Karunanayake
With newspapers and the public domain filled with scams in the Tax
Department and other agencies of the government, our columnist today
looks at the key issue of governance, transparency and whether the
government is effectively tackling these key issues.
Governance
is a reflection of the extent to which public officials can be held
accountable to citizens and the transparency with which they carry
out their functions. Increasing corruption and swindling of public
funds has now become a feature of Third World countries struggling
to overcome poverty and internal conflicts.
Not
that the developed countries are devoid of corrupt officials but
the strong institutional structures in these countries are able
to act fast and apprehend the wrong doers and prosecute them with
speed which itself acts as a deterrent.
Recent
examples of corporate scandals in the West and the manner in which
the law enforcement agencies acted are examples of good governance.
Today corporate governance has brought a certain amount of boardroom
discipline.
In
Sri Lanka we are at the moment witnessing the unfolding of the great
VAT robbery that has taken even the man in the street by surprise
and now rated as one of the biggest scams in South East Asia, while
media reports have also surfaced on visa scams.
These
corrupt activities at “high places” have exposed the
large-scale irregularities in an unbelievable manner Corruption
has been defined by the World Bank as “using public office
for private gains” while Transparency International, a non-governmental
organisation based in Berlin dedicated to increasing government
accountability and a watchdog of both local and international corruption,
interprets corruption as “misuse of entrusted power for private
gains”.
A well-known
Indian economist has identified five major players in the corruption
scene who strengthen the vicious cycle, They are the corrupt politician,
corrupt bureaucrat, corrupt businessman, corrupt NGO and the criminal
underworld. In this case we also witnessed perfect communal harmony
among the players said to be in a country in ethnic conflict.
Much
has been said about the corrupt manner how funds amounting to not
less than Rs 3.5 billion (approximately 5% of the VAT revenue) in
public funds has been siphoned out using the simplest methods. Investigators
have stated the actual amount is expected to be much higher.
What
is even more disturbing is the failure of the authorities to detect
these frauds that obviously have been going on for a longer period
of time. In the eighties several finance companies put up shutters
leaving the poor depositors high and dry; then in very recent times
the Central Bank took action against Pramuka, a financial institution
for financial irregularities.
Commencing
2005 Central Bank initiated an annual “Financial Stability
Review” to convey to the public the status of the finance
sector. It was just a few days ago that the Central Bank released
its latest Financial Stability Review assuring the public that the
finance sector is healthy and that there is no cause of alarm.
Unfortunately
the Treasury and the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) does not come
under this review though the funds held by these institutions are
significant. Today the public is losing confidence in the tax collecting
mechanism; this is not healthy for a nation seeking higher revenue
to rebuild infrastructure of a war-damaged country.
The
IRD once manned by the cream of the well-trained public service
with good university education was quietly slipping in quality during
the last few decades.
Pressurised
by fiscal deficits aggravated by high military expenditure and political
instability the revenue authorities are constantly under pressure
to maximise government revenue. The change over from TT to GST and
to VAT was too rapid and one wonders whether the IRD was prepared
to meet such challenges.
Despite
the growth and complexity of the tax system the IRD hardly changed
and the required specialisation in ICT, HR financial management
and audit control was behind the times. Such lapses obviously open
the doors for leakages. What has happened at the IRD is an eye opener
for the whole public sector. Developing low and middle income countries
appear to be the most affected by corruption thus increasing poverty
and conflicts leading to civil wars.
This
vicious circle keeps these poor countries in turmoil depriving many
innocents of food, clothing, health care and education. Siphoning
away of the government revenue to the benefit of few individuals
will increase the burden for many.
The
developed donor countries who are the providers of credit to these
countries must apply effective pressure to curb corruption particularly
at high places as such amounts involved are beyond the fiscal capacities
of such countries. Sri Lanka which has now emerged as a middle-income
country and boasts of a sound transparent judicial system must come
out of its slumber and fight this national enemy of corruption that
is as deadlier as an armed terrorist. We are yet to hear of any
significant prosecutions by the Permanent Commission for Bribery
and Corruption, nor was the euphoria of setting up an anti corruption
commission converted to reality. The annual asset declarations by
the public officials too have lost its meaning.
Corruption
is a symptom of weak governance. The political leadership must realise
that benefiting from globalisation is vital for eradication of poverty
and a sustainable growth momentum could only be achieved through
honest leadership and good governance.
Good
governance is a prerequisite to attract foreign investment. Sri
Lanka’s poor showing in the Commonwealth Games and the alarming
decline in the standard of cricket with adverse effects to the economy
too reflects the governance weaknesses as the sports is now considered
a global industry.
(Comments can be sent to the writer at suvink@eureka.lk)
|