Curtains for Army - LTTE contacts

It became abundantly clear last Tuesday that the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) has succeeded in dismantling the Sub Committee on De-escalation and Normalisation (SDN) for good.

A high security barrier at the entrance to an LTTE High Security Zone in the Mullaitivu district

Defence Secretary Austin Fernando declared at a news conference on January 1 that the SDN would meet last Tuesday (January 14). He said the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM) had officially confirmed a meeting between the Security Forces Commander (Jaffna), Major General Sarath Fonseka and "Colonel" Theepan, LTTE's "Northern Commander," on that day to discuss the former's report on High Security Zones (HSZ) in the Jaffna peninsula.

The event never took place. The reasons were known even five days before Mr. Fernando made the announcement. Responding to the Army's proposal that they decommission long-range weapons for re-settling displaced persons in the HSZ, the LTTE declared in a statement on December 26…"the Sub-Committee on De-escalation and Normalisation is rendered irrelevant by the SLA's new conditions for de-escalation. The SDN was formed specifically to work out the details of returning civilian homes and properties presently occupied by the military to their rightful owners. As such, and as long as the SLA insists on its unacceptable demands that the LTTE must disarm and decommission its heavy weapons, there is no purpose to be served by further meetings of the SDN…" After the third day of the fourth round of peace talks in Thailand last month, an accomplished foreign correspondent and now Editor of the State's own Daily News Arjuna Ranawana quoted Chief Negotiator, Anton Balasingham, saying that the LTTE would not attend the scheduled meeting of the SDN on January 14. In the same report, however, he quoted the Chief Negotiator of the Government of Sri Lanka (GOSL); Cabinet Minister Professor G.L. Peiris saying the SDN "is not dismantled or suspended." Added Prof. Peiris "it is natural for differences to come up during such a process. If there weren't any such differences there would be no need for negotiations…"

When the latest round of peace talks ended, the Royal Norwegian Government said in an official statement "………The parties did not reach agreement on the continuation of the work of the Sub-Committee on De-Escalation and Normalisation (SDN)…." If that sentence left any doubts on the future of the SDN, the fact that the LTTE and the GOSL did not meet on January 14 makes matters more clear. Hence, one need hardly provide answers to questions on the credibility of the assertions made on behalf of the LTTE or the GOSL by their respective Chief Negotiators. The events speak for themselves.

That means an important mechanism evolved during peace talks to scale down the atmosphere of war through direct consultations between Tiger guerrillas and the military is now gone. One need hardly elaborate how one bureaucrat's blunder has contributed to all this. The facts are known. With accountability, either during war or peace, becoming a matter of least concern to successive governments, the matter will now go into the limbo of forgotten things. But the manifold problems it has spawned will continue to impact on matters of not only national security but also on the peace process itself.

The Sub Committee on De-escalation and Normalisation being rendered defunct means that the LTTE will no longer deal directly with the Security Forces on military or any other matters during the ongoing peace process. No longer will there be meetings in an aluminium tent in a stretch of no-man's land in Muhamalai (in the Jaffna peninsula) that lay between the checkpoints of the Army and Tiger guerrillas. It will be back to the negotiating table in Thailand.

And to pave the way for such talks on High Security Zones, both the LTTE and the Government have agreed to seek the help of a neutral international advisor. That is in the form of retired Indian Lieutenant General Satish Nambiar, until August 1994 the second in command of the Indian Army. See his profile in the box story on this page. The UNF Government says his help is being sought in his private capacity and his assignment does not in any way involve the Government of India.

Minister Milinda Moragoda, who flew direct from Thailand after the last round of peace talks to brief Indian leaders, also took the opportunity to invite Lt. Gen. Nambiar to take a "fresh look" at the working of the High Security Zones. In view of other commitments, he is due in Sri Lanka early next month. He is now due to formulate a comprehensive report on the matter.

Lt. Gen. Nambiar has made two previous visits to Sri Lanka, once in September and the other in December last year, at the invitation of Prime Minister, Ranil Wickremaesinghe. During these visits, The Sunday Times learnt he had been tasked to study and report on possible incorporation of Tiger guerrilla cadres into the armed services and Police when a final peace settlement is arrived at.

He was also asked to make a study of the working of the High Security Zones in the Jaffna peninsula. In this regard, he flew to Jaffna and held extensive talks with the Security Forces Commander there, Maj. Gen. Sarath Fonseka. He flew with Maj. Gen. Fonseka in a Sri Lanka Air Force helicopter over most of the High Security Zones in the peninsula. Though Lt. Gen. Nambiar is learnt to have submitted a full report to the Government on the subjects assigned to him, no details of his observations or recommendations are known. Needless to say his upcoming study will encompass or elaborate on matters he has already examined and reported on.

Until that task is carried out, talks on re-settlement of displaced persons within the HSZ in the peninsula will remain on hold. And the Army's demand of the guerrillas decommissioning long-range weapons in addition to disarming their cadres will thus be no longer an issue.

A related matter that appears to have not surfaced is the High Security Zones of the LTTE itself, particularly around its own expanding military installations and other locations in the Mullaitivu district.

These areas have also encompassed civilian homes. This, however, will not be an issue since the UNF Government has recognised that the task of re-settling displaced persons in those areas was the responsibility of the LTTE.

Hence, priority attention of the Security Forces Headquarters in Jaffna is now being focussed on vacating some 700 Army-occupied homes outside the HSZ. This is besides the vacation of two hotels and nearly 70 homes in the Jaffna town area. Whilst alternative areas to accommodate the Army personnel is now being sought, the Government has decided to utilise a currently valid Indian line of credit to obtain pre-fabricated units to build housing and office accommodation. It has been agreed that Indian companies would be allowed to come to the peninsula to put up these facilities utilising local labour for which they will be required to pay.

The demise of the Sub Committee on De-escalation and Normalisation, unfortunately, comes at a bad time for the Security Forces. For the Army, if it came in for praise by the LTTE for its co-operation soon after the Ceasefire Agreement of February 22, relations appear to be already soured. If it was the culmination of a number of events, the issue over the HSZ appears to have capped it all.

A few examples from the Army's own official website - Army News Centre - (http://www.army.lk/news/) underscores the situation. Just to cite a few with the headlines:

LTTE member threatens troops

A person introducing himself as a member of the LTTE had threatened the troops to refrain from collecting details of houses and buildings in the general area VANNARAPANNAI, about 2.5 km, north of JAFFNA town on 07 January 2003 around 11 a.m.

A team of soldiers have been collecting details of buildings, houses and the occupants of them in VANNARAPANNAI where a LTTE member in civil attire had introduced himself as PAVALAN had showed his LTTE identity card and threatened the troops to refrain from doing so.

Further he had told the troops, if they continued to collect details they would be arrested.

However, to avoid any dispute with the LTTE the troops have stopped their mission and reported to their base.

Later this unruly action of the LTTE was reported to the Police station VANNARAPANNAI and Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM) in JAFFNA.

Soldiers show restraint despite provocative action

Five LTTE cadres on two motor bicycles proceeding from PUMPUGAR village in the general area of KALMADU, about 15 km. northwest of VAVUNIYA on 21 December around 4.30 p.m. had knocked down a soldier who was riding a bicycle.

The victim had gone towards KALMADU tank along with two other soldiers for a bath at the time of the incident.

In the meantime, the leader of the said LTTE group, named KAPILAN had abused the soldiers, ignored and proceeded further without stopping.

Troops who were around the area had however shown restraint to avoid any confrontation.

Soldiers had also seen one of the LTTE cadres carrying an Icom radio communication set.

This incident was reported to the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM) and KALMADU Police for further investigation.

Men tried to dismantle bunker arrested

KOPAI Police were able to arrest a group of ten men, suspected to be LTTE cadres who attempted to dismantle a bunker beside the KAITHADI bridge which had been in place to protect the historic and architectural value of this bridge with an arch.

The bunker used by troops to provide security to this arch-bridge in view of its historical significance after Engineer troops renovated this British built bridge to its original position after LTTE cadres blasted it when they were flushed out of the peninsula in 2000.

Troops not allowed into area

Troops on routine patrol in the general area of MARUTANKULAM, about 25 km northwest of VAVUNIYA town had been stopped from moving into MARUTANKULAM area by armed LTTE cadres who had arrived there on a Double Cab on 08 December 2002 around 11.30 a.m.

LTTE cadres have demanded identity cards of the troops and threatened the Security Forces personnel not to move into the said area.

However, troops showed restraint and returned to the camp.

The Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM) in VAVUNIYA has been kept informed of this stoppage of movement.

Besides these occurrences, though no longer listed in the daily news releases once issued by the Operational Headquarters of the Ministry of Defence, the reports appear daily in the Army website accessible world-wide. Such incidents do get reported to the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission.

However, besides them, incidents of a more serious nature with political and security implications have also become a cause for concern.

One such case is the arrest and detention of soldier Nihal Kumara of the Ranabapura Army detachment, 9 kilometres north of Weli Oya since December 24. He had walked some 75 metres away from the defence lines with his personal weapon when he fell into Tiger guerrilla hands. The soldier has now been produced before LTTE "law courts" by their "Police" and remanded till later this month. On the last date of the case, relatives of the soldier said the LTTE expected lawyers for the Army to come and appeal for his "bail" or "release." Responding to that move would mean the acceptance of the "jurisdiction of the LTTE Courts." Hence, no one has moved in.

Some UNF leaders who argued that the "LTTE Police and Law Courts" had existed for long years maintained a stoic silence over this whilst the soldier languished in a jail in the Wanni. Their helplessness now is further compounded by the fact that it is the first time since the Ceasefire Agreement of February 22 that a soldier has been remanded by an "LTTE Court." It has never happened before. If there was no SDN now to raise issue, the matter did not even figure at last month's talks in Nakorn Pathom. Nor was there any mention in the official statement issued by the Royal Norwegian Government.

Another incident that raises serious security issues occurred on December 28 when Sea Tiger craft rounded up nine Indian fishing boats off Kalmunai Point, near Pooneryn and arrested 35 Tamil Nadu fishermen. They were held near the Sea Tiger base at Nachchikudah whilst moves were afoot to shift them to Kilinochchi to face charges before "law courts." They were to be later handed over either to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) or the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM). The move drew a furious response in New Delhi. Without any explanation, the fishermen were released by the LTTE on January 2 this year. This is the first time the Sea Tigers arrested a group of South Indian fishermen and detained them.

The only means through which the Sri Lanka Navy learnt of these arrests and the subsequent release, The Sunday Times learnt, was through radio intercepts. Their patrols have been acting with great caution to avoid being accused of trying to disrupt the peace process. The incident undoubtedly signals the birth of a new phenomenon - the emergence of a third Naval force in the Palk Straits and the Indian Ocean besides those of India and Sri Lanka.

If that is at sea, since the Ceasefire Agreement of February 22, on land, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil's Eelam's military strength, capability and their arsenal has grown enormously and is continuing to grow. There will still be those who refuse to believe in this so rapidly changing security dimension that reminds one of the proverb there is none so blind as those who refuse to see. One cannot blame the LTTE for seizing every opportunity to achieve what they could not with a million round of bullets.
What of the Security Forces ? Someone, somewhere is evidently neglecting them. Amidst the diminishing dimensions of their preparedness and capability, they are being perceived as obstacles to peace. So, a handful of media personnel are not alone.

Lt. Gen. Nambiar- a brief who’s who

If he finds right answers to looming questions on the High Security Zones in Jaffna peninsula - the contentious issue between the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) and the Government of Sri Lanka - in the coming weeks, that will indeed be an addition to a number of firsts for 63 year old retired Indian Lieutenant General Satish Nambiar.

He raised the first Mechanised Brigade Group of the Indian Army and later commanded its Mechanised Division. Deputed by the Government of India, he was the first Force Commander of the United Nations Forces in the former Yugoslavia. Also designated as a UN Under Secretary General, it was his task to set up a mission which he later headed for a year from March 1992.

Returning to the Indian Army, he retired as Deputy Chief of Army Staff, the second in command, on August 31, 1994. By then, he had won the Vir Chakra for gallantry (during the Indo-Pakistan War of 1971), the Ati Vishist Medal and the Param Vishist Seva Medal for distinguished service.

Born in Mumbai on August 30, 1936, into a Nair family with its roots in Kerala, Lt. Gen. Nambiar was educated in Pune and Mumbai. He was commissioned from the Indian Military Academy on December 15 1967 into the 20th Battalion of the Maratha Light Infantry.

He saw active service in India's North-Western and North-Eastern theatres, including counter-insurgency operations, the 1965 and 1971 conflicts in the sub continent. He commanded the first battalion and later the 20th battalion of the Maratha Light Infantry.

A graduate of the Australian Staff College, Lt. Gen. (retd.) Nambiar served on the General Staff Branch at Divisional Headquarters and held appointments as Additional Director General and Director General of Military Operations at Army Headquarters.

In the latter position, he led two defence delegations for discussions with Pakistani counterparts in April 1991 in New Delhi and September 1991 in Islamabad.

With a Master's Degree in Defence Studies from the University of Madras, Lt. Gen. Nambiar has been actively engaged since retirement, in the study and analysis of UN peacekeeping operations, national security issues and international relations. Elected to the Council of the United Service Institution of India in late 1995, he assumed office as its Director in July 1996. He is also a life member of the Institute for Defence Studies and Analysis, New Delhi.

He lectures at India's National Defence College, the Defence Services Staff College, the Foreign Service Institute, the Jawaharlal Nehru University and the Army War College.

His son is a commissioned officer in the Indian Army, in the same battalion as his father - the 20th Maratha Light Infantry.

 


Back to Top
 Back to Columns  

Copyright © 2001 Wijeya Newspapers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Webmaster