Mystery men, Tiger
cargo and the BIA boss
Overtly
eager State officials, who ignore acknowledged channels to please
Tiger guerrillas are causing as much embarrassment to the United
National Front (UNF) Government as those who oppose the yearlong
peace process.
Examples of
such action, where scant regard has been paid to procedures, the
laws of the land, national security interests and the UNF's openly
professed commitment to transparency may be as high as the number
of daily complaints the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission (SLMM) receives
on ceasefire violations. But most do not come into public focus.
This
is the facsmile of the Certicate of Clearance issued by
the Protocol Division of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs
to the Royal Norwegian Embassy in Colombo for the import
of communications equipment and parts.
These
were in effect the radio broadcasting equipment that were
handed over to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE)
without payment of duty.
The
entry in the Remarks cage confirms that this
Clearance Certificate was issued after letter from
Prime Ministers office is received. See detailed
story on this page.
|
However,
some glaring instances already known deliver a strong signal to
the UNF on the need for urgent measures to protect the peace process
from being derailed by over enthusiastic State officials, all political
appointees. That is in view of the increasing threats the actions
of the Governments own men pose.
An example that
received much public exposure is the import of radio broadcasting
equipment for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). If a
Government licence permitted them to beam within a radius of 20
kilometres from Kilinochchi, the radio station that became operational
from January 16, this year can be heard beyond that in Jaffna (70
kilometres away), Mannar (160 kilometres away), Mullaitivu (75 kilometres
away) and deep south of Vavuniya (over 160 kilometres away). Although
these distances are by road, it is still far beyond the radius allowed.
The Sunday Times
can now reveal more details of how the broadcasting equipment was
delivered to the LTTE. A senior official in the Prime Minister's
office asked the Protocol Division of Ministry of Foreign Affairs
to issue a Clearance Certificate to the Royal Norwegian Embassy
in Colombo. This came soon after he made a personal appeal to this
Embassy to act as consignee for the equipment - a request which
they readily obliged since that was tantamount to a formal Government
request.
The Foreign
Ministry issued this Clearance Certificate on October 31,
last year. Diplomatic missions in Colombo to clear cargo, both official
and personal, require this document. That is for goods consigned
to their office or personnel without payment of duty.
The Clearance
Certificate in this instance (see facsimile on this page) was
issued by the Foreign Ministry in the name of Oddvar Halgrund, Minister
Counsellor of the Royal Norwegian Embassy in Colombo. According
to a column in this certificate, the "Detailed Description
of articles imported/purchased ex bond" is stated as "communications
equipment and parts." The answer to a question in another column
which asks "Whether for official or personal use?"
states "official." An entry in "Remarks"
column says, "letter from PM's office is received."
After ensuring
that Foreign Ministry clearance was issued, the high official in
the PM's office, The Sunday Times learnt, asked Defence Secretary
Austin Fernando to arrange for the inspection of the equipment by
a technical team. Here again, intriguing enough, Mr. Fernando appointed
a team to examine "communications equipment consigned to the
Royal Norwegian Embassy." The Committee members, it is learnt,
had been told only verbally that the equipment was bound to the
Wanni for the LTTE.
The team comprised
R.D. Somasiri, a former Telecommunications Department official now
Advisor to the Ministry of Mass Communications, Brigadier Y.S.A.
de Silva, Director, Signals, Sri Lanka Army, Group Captain A. Gunawardena,
Director Electronics and Telecommunications, Sri Lanka Air Force
and Upali Arambewela, an engineer now Additional Director General
of Sri Lanka Rupavahini Corporation.
In their report
to Secretary, Ministry of Defence, dated November 26, last year,
the four members said in the very first paragraph "As instructed
by the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, the following committee was
appointed to inspect the consignment of communication equipment
received by the Royal Norwegian Embassy
." There was
no mention that the broadcasting equipment was for the LTTE.
Customs Appraiser
H.G.C.K. Wijesekera took an inventory of the broadcast equipment
on November 26, last year, in the presence of Brigadier Silva, Mr.
Arambewela, Group Captain Gunawardena and Lasantha Prabath of Arrow
Freight, the local agents for the freight-forwarding firm. It was
only thereafter that the container with the cargo was sealed. It
was again on the basis that the equipment was consigned to the Royal
Norwegian Embassy. There was no mention whatsoever in any official
documents of the cargo being cleared for or by the LTTE.
Little wonder
when The Sunday Times front page lead story of December 8 last year
headlined "New Voice of Tigers with govt. approval"
drew a prompt and angry denial from Defence Secretary Fernando.
The report said he had issued a letter to a Police Inspector who
accompanied the container load of equipment up to the Army Checkpoint
at Omanthai from where it was moved to Wanni.
"
I
wish to state categorically and with full responsibility that I,
as the Defence Secretary, have not issued any such letter to anyone
and accordingly the news item is entirely false as regards the said
letter." He was right. There is no documentation involving
the LTTE. Even the instructions to the Police to escort the cargo
to Omanthai, ostensibly to prevent any outsider introducing any
other material, was done verbally.
The equipment
came as a consignment to the Royal Norwegian Embassy. A technical
team was called upon to examine this consignment. It reported the
verification to the Ministry of Defence. The Customs gave clearance
to the cargo for collection by the Norwegian Embassy who was the
consignee. And at the end of it all, when the story broke out, official
accounts had to concede that the consignment was for the LTTE. That
was with the assertion that the LTTE had written two letters on
October 1, last year, requesting permission to import the broadcasting
equipment. It was said that one was directed to the Secretary to
the Prime Minister and another to the Minister of Mass Communications.
The fact that
the entire exercise was surreptitiously carried out caused acute
embarrassment not only to the UNF leadership but also to the Norwegian
Government and their Embassy in Colombo. Norwegian officials insist
to date they are unaware who paid the money or who procured the
radio equipment. They say they "willingly agreed" to act
as consignee for the cargo, heeding the request of the high official,
as a "measure of goodwill" and to "assist the Government
of Sri Lanka." The position is clearly underscored by the role
of the high official in the PM's office. It is he who asked the
Foreign Ministry to issue a Clearance Certificate in the name of
the Royal Norwegian Embassy. If the equipment was imported by the
Embassy in question, the request should have originated from them.
Whether playing
good Samaritan was wise is another matter. But having done so, the
Royal Norwegian Embassy learnt it the hard way. A prolonged silence
on the part of the Government did cause further damage to Norway's
credibility as a facilitator. The first statement by the Government
spokesman on December 26 last year - a cool three months after an
LTTE request was reportedly received - did very little to clear
the imbroglio. It raised more questions than it answered.
It therefore
took Prime Minister, Ranil Wickremasinghe, in a letter to President
Chandrika Bandaranaike Kumaratunga on January 3 to defend Norway.
In doing so he stressed that their Ambassador in Sri Lanka Jon Westborg
"has an unrivalled experience of the ground realities in Sri
Lanka."
The position
that the Norwegian Government and their Embassy in Colombo was put
into could have been very easily avoided had the proper regulations
and protocol been complied with. This is an instance where the high
official concerned had ignored fundamental governmental procedures
and also the Secretariat for Co-ordinating the Peace Process (SCOPP).
The latter could have been called upon to go through with the formalities.
Why was this not done?
After all the
events, the fact that the LTTE is now operating a radio station,
with a range far in excess of the radius approved, is common knowledge.
It is also common knowledge that the Government cannot enforce any
punitive action for violating a stipulation in the licence issued
to them. That is despite public claims that such action would be
taken if there were any violations. Why then did the high official
in question resort to improper means and thus embarrass both Sri
Lankan and Norwegian governments? If that was lesson number one
from a glaring instance, there was more.
Another is
the "self inflicted" crisis over the High Security Zones
(HSZ) in the Jaffna peninsula. A "De-escalation Plan,"
a secret document, formulated by Security Forces Commander, Jaffna,
Major General Sarath Fonseka for study by the Government was sent
directly to the LTTE by Defence Secretary, Austin Fernando. A demand
in that plan for guerrilla cadres to disarm and decommission long-range
weapons angered the LTTE. Later Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe
himself conceded that the document should not have gone to the LTTE
in that format.
He explained
it should have been "sanitized" or in other words a fresh
document formulated in acceptable jargon to be forwarded for LTTE
consideration. As a result, the LTTE made use of this fiasco to
render defunct the Sub Committee on De-escalation and Normalisation
(SDN) thus shutting off direct contacts or consultations with the
Army. Lesson number two from another glaring instance one would
say. But that is not the end of it.
A third glaring
instance has raised more questions on national security and whether
Tiger guerrillas enjoy "duty free" cum "security
free" status when they use the Bandaranaike International Airport
(BIA). This time again, it is the result of the role played by a
BIA director appointed by the UNF to a key position at the airport.
He is said to use his close Ministerial connections to by-pass all
border control channels.
On January 11
(Saturday), the six member Tiger guerrilla delegation taking part
at the fourth round of peace talks in Nakorn Pathom (Thailand) arrived
in Colombo by Srilankan Airlines flight UL 423 at 11.40 p.m. They
were S.P. Tamilselvan, Vinayagamoorthy Muralitharan (Karuna), S.
Prabakharan (Pulithevan), M. Sharvananda Krishnan, M. Sivapalan
and P. Sivaparan. The Royal Norwegian Embassy in Colombo had made
arrangements for their overnight accommodation at the Airport Gardens
hotel in Seeduwa.
Twelve crack
commandos of the Sri Lanka Army led by an officer escorted the LTTE
team to the hotel and stood guard there. For these commandos, it
was a strange twist of fate. It was only on July 24 2001; these
men together with their colleagues had braved the fierce Tiger guerrilla
attack on the Sri Lanka Air Force Base at Katunayake and the adjoining
Bandaranaike International Airport - an incident that had a devastating
effect on the country's economy. In a reversed role, it has become
their task now to protect the guerrilla leaders every time they
passed through BIA.
It is the responsibility
of the SCOPP to arrange Air Force flights in consultation with the
Royal Norwegian Embassy to bring to Colombo the LTTE delegation
for the outward flight from Sri Lanka and later to return them to
their own locations. Usually, a Sri Lanka Air Force helicopter would
drop the main group in Kilinochchi, return to Colombo and fly to
Batticaloa to drop Mr Muralitharan alias Karuna.
However, the
BIA director had by passed the SCOPP and used his political clout
to ensure there were two SLAF helicopters to take back the LTTE
delegation. It was on the grounds that Political Wing leader, S.P.
Tamilselvan, had a morning conference in Kilinochchi. He could still
have been dropped for this conference and Mr. Muralitharan taken
on the second trip. There were two SLAF Bell 212 helicopters on
the BIA tarmac when the LTTE delegation, escorted by the Army commandos,
arrived from their hotel on the morning of January 12 (Sunday).
A white coloured
lorry from the Airport and Aviation Services (Sri Lanka) Ltd. drove
in with the luggage of the LTTE delegation. It turned out that the
passenger baggage of the four-member team flying to Kilinochchi
was too big a load to carry. There were too many packages and boxes,
all of them sealed and secured. The SLAF pilot had to ask they be
left behind as that could impede take off. It was re-loaded to the
lorry.
Just then, driving
to the apron (where the choppers were parked) was the official vehicle
of the BIA director followed by a Mitsubishi Montero. The time was
6.50 a.m. An occupant alighted from the Montero and handed over
a packed box, (about a foot long and eight inches wide) to Mr. Prabakharan
alias Pulithevan. What was in the box? While the Montero has been
registered in the name of a private distillery's office in Colombo,
security authorities are unaware what the box contained and who
came in the Montero.
They had entered
a very high security zone escorted by the BIA director's vehicle
with an unchecked parcel. The checkpoints had been cleared without
any hindrance because the director's vehicle was ahead. Senior airport
officials suspect the box may have contained foreign currency but
this could not be verified. In any case, they point out that the
parcel could have been easily handed over outside the airport high
security area if there was a requirement.
Later, the
four-member team took off to Kilinochchi accompanied by the BIA
director and another holding a managerial position at the airport.
At the same time, the second Bell 212 took off for Batticaloa (Palugamam)
with Mr. Muralitharan (Karuna), Mr Sivapalan and an official from
the SCOPP. This helicopter carried three pieces of personal luggage.
The Sunday
Times learnt that the packages left behind were much heavier than
the personal luggage of 375 kilos that five members of the LTTE
delegation brought along to Colombo when they returned from Oslo,
Norway, after the third round of peace talks. According to authoritative
sources, the packages had not been subjected to Customs examination
although it is not clear whether a description of them were given
if they did make declarations. One source said that one of the larger
packages contained a mini refrigerator. However, this could not
be confirmed. Nor were details of what the other packages or boxes
held are known. How did these packages later arrive in Wanni?
The Sunday
Times learnt that the BIA director had already made arrangements.
Instead of sending them by road, he was to airlift them though the
SCOPP, which was responsible for such arrangements, was unaware
of the move. Two SLAF Bell 412 helicopters were to land at the Thurstan
College football grounds in Colombo at 7 a.m. on January 15 (Thai
Pongal Day) to take the Government delegation and Norwegian officials
for the meeting of the Sub Committee on Immediate Humanitarian and
Rehabilitation Needs (SIHRN) in Kilinochchi.
Ahead of the
scheduled time, (around 6.45 am) an SLAF Mi-17 troop transport helicopter
had arrived there. The packages left behind were all loaded into
this. One SLAF source said BIA director had objected to security
checks on the packages by Air Force personnel - a routine security
procedure when SLAF aircraft carried cargo or baggage. If the packages
were allowed duty free and without Customs examination, here was
a case of the security checks also being done away with.
This is in
marked contrast to accepted procedures. All soldiers boarding Air
Force flights from Ratmalana for their bases in the North or returning
are subject to security checks. Air Force personnel use explosive
detectors for checks on baggage. The baggage is not loaded to aircraft
or helicopters until this is completed. But for baggage that was
going to the LTTE in the Wanni, the BIA director had sought an exception.
One Air Force source said he used names of senior UNF leaders to
caution those who attempted to carry out checks. Eight passengers
flew together later with the packages in the Mi-17. Eight others
took the Bell 412.
That was the
course of events that occurred when the LTTE delegation returned
from Bangkok. Their visit to Colombo from Wanni en- route to Thailand
was also marked by some disturbing events.
The six-member
LTTE delegation arrived in Colombo on January 3 and was accommodated
at the Airport Garden Hotel (Seeduwa) protected by the Army commando
team. The next day (January 4), they were driven to the airport
to board Srilankan airlines flight UL 422 for Bangkok that was scheduled
to leave at 7.55 am.
It transpired
that two other persons, described as close associates of a member
of the LTTE delegation had joined them at the airport. They are
learnt to have stayed at the official residence of the BIA director,
located in the high security area though they were not members of
the delegation and thus had no official status. The director is
learnt to have obtained confirmation of seats in the same flight
for the two outsiders. They later flew in the same flight. So did
the BIA director. He was on hand in the Rose Garden Resort in Nakorn
Pathom where the LTTE delegation and the Government team were holding
peace talks.
The member
of the LTTE delegation, who was close to the two outsiders, The
Sunday Times learnt, had (before arriving in Colombo) contacted
an official in the SCOPP and inquired whether the delegation also
could stay at the BIA director's official residence. That was together
with the duo. Since Royal Norwegian Embassy officials had already
made arrangements for accommodation, the SCOPP official had regretted
his inability to help.
One of the
two outsiders who boarded the flight, intelligence sources at the
airport told The Sunday Times had powerful connections and lived
in Kelaniya. According to these sources, he received regular visitors
from the City including airport officials to his residence and was
known for his lavish spending.
According to
these sources, the delegation member in question had once visited
the Kelaniya residence when he was in Colombo to travel abroad.
This visit had taken place in a vehicle belonging to the Norwegian
Embassy in Colombo. However, this could not be independently verified
though the same intelligence sources said DPL vehicles often arrived
at this Kelaniya residence.
The Sunday
Times learns that the Royal Norwegian Embassy officials had expressed
concern to local counterparts over some of the alleged violation
of procedures and protocol at the airport. Their concerns had been
heightened because of their keenness to avoid any criticism against
them like in the case of the issue involving the import of broadcasting
equipment.
All these glaring
incidents manifest the supine accommodation of the LTTE by the Government.
Making matters worse is the fact that there is hardly any reciprocity
from the Tiger guerrillas.
It was only
last Thursday that an LTTE "Court" in Kilinochchi took
the case once again of Army soldier Nihal Kumara, arrested by their
"Police" for straying into guerrilla dominated areas in
the Weli Oya sector. LTTE "prosecutors" argued that the
soldier was a spy who had infiltrated into guerrilla areas to collect
information. A "counsel" assigned to the soldier by the
LTTE argued that he had ventured out on a game hunt with his service
weapon, a Chinese built T-56 assault rifle.
How the two
different versions arose is indeed comical.
According to
the soldier's own testimony to guerrilla "Police," he
had gone looking for wood apple before beginning his morning ablutions.
He fell into guerrilla hands. The LTTE "Judge" has now
put off the case for February 13 and the soldier continues to languish
in an LTTE jail. The Army is unable to obtain help since procuring
counsel to appear in an LTTE "court" would amount to accepting
their "jurisdiction." The Government has remained helpless
since the soldier was arrested on December 24.
The LTTE arrest
is also a warning to all other members of the Security Forces not
to stray into guerrilla dominated areas. Unlike what prevailed before
the Ceasefire Agreement of February 22 2002, they will face arrest
by the LTTE "Police" and face prosecution in their "Court
of law." If found "guilty" they will be "jailed."
So the Alpha Nine highway from Vavuniya to Jaffna is not for them
to travel. They will still have to fly out of Jaffna and return
there by air.
Is this not
in marked contrast to the treatment Tiger guerrillas have received
at the hands of the Government? Kandasamy Ramasamy (of Tellipalai,
Jaffna) and Madhavan Vasanthan (of Sampur, Trincomalee), both hard
core guerrillas were arrested with weapons whilst felling trees
in a forest reserve in the jungles of Kantalai in the Trincomalee
District late last year. They were charged under the Offensive Weapons
Act.
An application
for their release came up before the Court of Appeal on October
8, last year. Bail was granted on that day with Rs 25,000 each as
surety.
The duo were
released and ordered to report to the Kantalai Police on the second
Saturday of each month. The Police have not set eyes on the duo
from the day of their release. The case comes up for hearing in
the new Magistrate's Court in Kantalai on February 28. This court
was set up only on January 1 this year.
The LTTE has
refused to accept the jurisdiction of the Courts of Sri Lanka. Its
men have disobeyed a Court order. That is not all. The LTTE now
wants the Government and the Army to accept the "jurisdiction"
of its own "law courts." Who acknowledged that these LTTE
"courts" have been in existence for long years when in
reality they were not? Now, will those who did so, accept they would
also heed to the "jurisdiction" of such courts? Their
silence is deafening.
It is in this
backdrop that one has to view the violation of regulations and protocol
that applies to the normal citizens of Sri Lanka in order to appease
the LTTE. That leaves open several doubts and raises several more
questions, the foremost of which is whether in that process the
nation's security and integrity has been compromised? The peace
process is one aspect and undoubtedly a highly desirable national
objective but it should not be at the jeopardy of the country's
security and political dignity. It remains the UNF Government's
priority to secure the sovereignty of Sri Lanka and all its citizens
since a ceasefire is not a total peace and a final end to war. At
the end of it all, it is the public that has to endorse a political
solution through a peace dialogue.
The actions
of the Government should give the public, those of all communities,
the confidence that their political integrity and security are being
safeguarded. Without this assurance it is doubtful whether everlasting
peace can be achieved. This means the Government should act. There
should be accountability.
|