Pause-in-conflict
economy
Quarterly review of the economy by Muttukrishna Sarvananthan,
International Centre for Ethnic Studies
The second quarter (April-June) of 2003 experienced political developments
that have made a serious dent in the feel good factor that prevailed
in the country ever since the Government of Sri Lanka (GoSL) and
the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) signed a Memorandum
of Understanding in February 2002. Firstly, the LTTE "temporarily"
suspended its participation in the peace negotiations with the GoSL
on April 21. Secondly, the President attempted to take over the
National Lotteries Board under her authority from the Ministry of
Economic Reforms in the last week of April. Thirdly, devastating
floods hit the southern and south-western parts of the country during
May. Fourthly, the Tokyo donor conference, which took place on June
9 and 10, was the only positive development in the politico-economic
front during the quarter under review.
The 1st quarter
GDP growth was a massive improvement compared to the 0.1% growth
during the corresponding quarter last year. The 2nd quarter GDP
growth could be less than the 1st quarter because of the floods
and its economic fallout. Nevertheless the forecast is that Sri
Lanka would achieve 5.5% growth rate for the year 2003. This target
is feasible provided that there is no resumption of full-scale war.
Agricultural
production
In the agricultural sector, tea and coconut output increased but
rubber output declined during the quarter under review in comparison
to the previous quarter. Tea production increased by 12%, coconut
production by 10% and rubber production declined by 18%. Quarterly
coconut production has increased for the first time since the last
quarter of 2001. Coconut production has increased month after month
since the beginning of the year, which is a positive development
after a disappointing 2002.
Industrial
exports, in terms of value, which dropped by 28% to $ 232 million
in April, increased by 58% to $ 366 million in May and dropped by
13% in June compared to the preceding month respectively. The total
quarterly industrial exports to the value of $ 915 million during
the 2nd quarter was slightly lower than $ 918 million in the 1st
quarter. Hence the quarterly industrial export values have been
declining since the beginning of this year.
The interest
rates continued to decline during the quarter under review. The
prime-lending rate during the last week of April averaged 11.49%
(declining from 11.77% during the last week of March), declined
to 10.54% during the last week of May and then to 10.44% during
the last week of June. Likewise, the Treasury Bill rate (12 months)
dropped to 8.62% during the last week of April (from 9.18% during
the last week of March) and further declined to 8.55% and 8.46%
during the last weeks of May and June respectively.
However, the
declining Central Bank interest rates have not been correspondingly
reflected in the lending rates of commercial banks to businesses
and personal customers. Both the annual average rate of inflation
and the point-to-point rate of inflation have been consistently
declining since mid-2002 and late-2002 respectively. Continuously
declining interest and inflation rates are indications of the stabilization
of the macro economy after the disastrous economic performance in
2001.
The gross official
foreign currency reserves of the country improved considerably by
15% during the quarter under review. The gross official reserves
increased to almost $ 2 billion at the end of the quarter under
review from $ 1.7 billion at the end of the 1st quarter. Over 80%
of the rise in gross official reserves was in April. The rise in
gross official reserves in April (in spite of the huge trade deficit
and drops in net private remittances and tourism receipts during
the same month) was due to the disbursement of the first installment
of the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) by the International
Monetary Fund (IMF). The gross official reserves dropped by $ 40
million in May but increased by $ 85 million in June.
Remittances
from abroad have become a major source of foreign exchange earnings
to Sri Lanka. The bulk of the private remittances are from Sri Lankan
workers in the Middle Eastern countries. Almost a million Sri Lankans
work abroad in the Middle East, Cyprus, Singapore, Malaysia and
Italy.
The monthly
net private remittances continued to drop since March 2003. However,
the total net private remittances during the quarter under review
were marginally higher than the 1st quarter. Besides the quarterly
net private remittances during the first-two quarters of this year
have been considerably greater than the first-three quarters of
last year but falling behind the last-quarter of 2002. This is real
growth as it is in terms of US dollars.
On average
almost $ 100 million net private remittances (i.e. remittances received
minus remittances sent out) have been received during the first-six
months of the year. If this trend continues the annual remittances
of the current year may exceed last year's total of $ 1,100 million.
The pause-in-conflict
economy in the North and East (N&E) Province of Sri Lanka is
hereby defined as the transitory economy from a conflict economy
to a post-conflict economy. The Tokyo donor conference provided
a stimulus to the revival of the North and East Provincial economy.
Out of the total aid of $ 4.5 billion pledged to Sri Lanka over
a period of four years about one-third is expected to be for the
rehabilitation and reconstruction needs of the North and East Province.
North-east
agriculture
Paddy, chilli and onion are the major agricultural crops in the
North and East Province. Paddy is the single largest food crop in
the N and E. These are seasonal crops and there are two agricultural
seasons in Sri Lanka, viz. Maha and Yala (former being the major
season). The Provincial Department of Agriculture estimates that
the land extent under paddy cultivation in the North dropped by
50% during the 20 years of conflict, but there has been a 35% rise
in the land extent under paddy cultivation in the North during the
2002/2003 Maha season.
For example,
in the Kilinochchi district out of the total paddy cultivatable
extent of 25,000 hectares only 10,000 - 12,000 hectares were cultivated
during conflict-time, which increased to 18,000 hectares during
the 2002/2003 Maha season. Likewise, in the Mullaitivu district
out of the total paddy cultivatable extent of 17,000 hectares only
8,000 - 10,000 hectares were cultivated during conflict, which increased
to 14,000 hectares during the 2002/2003 Maha season (Ceylon Daily
News, 15-07-2003: 7). Large extents of agricultural land are still
uncultivated because of landmines and high security zones.
According to
the North-East Provincial Department of Agriculture the paddy production
during the 2002/2003 Maha season in the five districts of the North
(Jaffna, Kilinochchi, Mannar, Mullaitivu and Vavuniya) was 400,000
metric tonnes (ibid). In contrast, according to the Department of
Census and Statistics, only 84,000 metric tonnes of paddy were produced
in the North during 2000 (both Maha and Yala). However, the author
could not verify the production figures of the North-East Provincial
Department of Agriculture. Statistical data on other crops are yet
to be made available.
Civil
war and poverty
Twenty years of civil war has left the Sri Lankan economy in general
and the economy of the North and East Province in particular in
tatters. The civil war had its impact on poverty as well, inter
alia. However, the impact of the civil war on poverty differed in
different regions of the country. Whilst the N&E Province and
the adjacent areas experienced increased and acute poverty as a
direct result of the war the rest of the country did not experience
war-induced poverty.
According to
available evidence the proportion of the poor in the total population
of Sri Lanka actually declined between the early-1980s and the late-1990s.
In 1980/1 half the total population was poor but in 1996/7 only
31% of the population was poor using a higher poverty line. That
is, the income or consumption poverty seems to have dropped. However,
we have to remember that post-1983 poverty data does not incorporate
the N&E Province and therefore the decline in poverty in 1996/7
may have been overstated. Yet it would be reasonable to infer that
the incidence of poverty declined between the early-1980s and the
late-1990s though we cannot be sure by how much.
Though in the
rest of the country the incidence of poverty seems to have declined
during two decades of civil war it was the contrary in the N&E.
In the author's judgement around 50% of the N&E population could
be under the higher poverty line. This is because of massive displacement
of rural farming communities, fishing communities, destruction of
farming and fishing equipment and private properties resulting in
loss of livelihoods to hundreds of thousands of people throughout
the N&E and adjacent areas.
The Northern
Province is the poorest province in terms of per capita income and
the Eastern Province is the next poorest. According to the Department
of Census and Statistics, in the early-1980s the Sabaragamuwa Province
was the poorest in terms of per capita income and the Uva Province
second poorest, which is now being occupied by the Northern and
Eastern Provinces respectively. The per capita income of the Northern
Province was LKR 37,206 in 2000 while the national per capita income
was nearly LKR 63,000.
According to
a survey undertaken by the Council of NGOs in the Jaffna District
in September 2002 the unemployment rate in the Jaffna district was
28% while at the national level (baring the N&E Province) it
was only 8%. The unemployment rate among women was 32% whereas among
men it was 23% in Jaffna. The underemployment rate of 37% in Jaffna
was split into 60% among women and 8% among men. Although no data
exists it is understandable that the unemployment and underemployment
rates in the Vanni (encompassing Kilinochchi, Mannar, Mullaitivu
and Vavuniya districts) would be considerably higher than that of
Jaffna. The huge unemployment and underemployment problems as a
result of the civil war are a major cause of poverty in the N&E.
Pre-war
surplus
Agriculture (food and cash crops, livestock and fishery) has been
the primary economic activity in the N&E Province, historically.
It remained so even during the civil war in the past two decades.
However, the nature of the agriculture sector has undergone a change
during the past 20 years. In pre-war times the N&E was a significant
surplus producer of food (e.g. paddy) and cash crops (e.g. onion,
chilli and tobacco) and fish products, which used to be transported
to other parts of the country for marketing.
However, due
to massive displacement of populations, laying of landmines in agricultural
lands, absorption of highly fertile agricultural lands cum coastal
areas into high security zones, economic embargo on the N&E
covering fuel, fertilisers and pesticides, restrictions on the transport
of local produce to the rest of the country, lack of electricity
and severe time and distance restrictions on fishing, a surplus
agrarian economy has been transformed into a subsistence/survival
economy.
For example,
in 1980 the N&E Province produced almost one-third of the total
production of paddy in the country, which dropped to a quarter in
2000. In 1980, nearly 40% of the onions produced in the country
were in the N&E, which dropped to nearly 30% in 2000. Little
more than a quarter of the total chilli production in the country
in 1980 was in the N&E, which had dropped to just 8% in 2000.
The Northern Province accounted for 13% of the total potato output
in the country in 1980, which dropped to less than 1% in 2000. In
1980 the N&E accounted for 56% of the total fish catches of
the country, which dropped to just 16% in 2000.
The backwardness
and relative deprivation of the N&E economy is not only in terms
of per capita income (i.e. in terms of income or consumption poverty)
but also in terms of social indicators (i.e. in terms of human poverty).
For example, the percentage of households with access to safe water
in the country (as a whole) is 45% whereas in the N&E it is
only 20% (less than half the national average).
Nationally 73%
of the total households do have sanitary facility whereas only 48%
of the households in the N&E do. While nationally 17% of babies
are born underweight in the N&E 26% of the babies are born in
like manner. Similarly, while 30% of the children under-5 years
are underweight nationally it is 46% in the N&E. Almost 50%
of the pregnant women in the N&E are malnourished. Almost 20%
of the births take place at home in the N&E whereas nationally
only 4% do so (five times higher than the national average). As
a corollary the maternal mortality ratio (i.e. death of mothers
during every 1,000 live births) in the N&E is 81 while it is
only 23 in the country as a whole (three and a half times the national
average).
It is important
to remember that despite the untold hardships unleashed by the gruesome
civil war the N&E population did not experience starvation or
hunger as in some other internal war-torn regions such as Southern
Sudan. The inflow of foreign remittances from kith and kin that
fled abroad as refugees and assistance from international relief
agencies and the Government of Sri Lanka mitigated the impact of
the war on the people of N&E.
IDPs
return
Since the indefinite ceasefire, in effect from the beginning of
2002, the general economic, social and psychological conditions
of the people of the N&E are improving slowly but surely. The
evidence for this change is emerging gradually. For instance, according
to the UNHCR, nearly half the internally displaced people (IDP)
have voluntarily returned to their places of origin in the past
18 months.
This is taking
place spontaneously against the advice of the UNHCR. The UNHCR would
not encourage resettlement of IDPs unless and until the landmines
are completely cleared in suspected lands. Yet, the fact that the
IDPs are spontaneously returning to their places of origin (vast
majority to Jaffna) even before the clearance of landmines is complete
is a testimony to the sense of confidence and security felt by the
ordinary public.
Moreover, according
to anecdotal evidence, the extent of crop agriculture cultivation
in the N&E has increased significantly in the past 18 months.
Since agricultural crops are seasonal the output data are still
not available. However, fish catches in the N&E have tremendously
improved during 2002. While the total fish catches in the N&E
were 44,000 metric tonnes in 2000 it almost doubled to 85,000 metric
tonnes in 2002.
The foregoing
evidence indicates the enormous potential out there for economic
revival and poverty alleviation in the N&E Province. However,
uncleared landmines, high security zones, remaining restrictions
on fishing, arbitrary taxation and the general political and economic
uncertainty appear to be some of the non-market institutional impediments
for the full realisation of the peace dividend in the N&E. |