Bill
soon in Parliament to curb unethical conversions
By Santhush Fernando
Buddhist and Hindu organisations and the Catholic Bishops’
Conference hold similar views regarding the move to present a Bill
in parliament to curb unethical conversions. With the government
deciding to look at this issue in depth the Buddha Sasana Minister
W.J.M. Lokubandara had written to the Maha Sangha assuring them
the Government would within the next 60 days introduce these laws.
The
Minister gave this undertaking on December 30 following the fast-unto-death
campaign led by Ven. Dr. Omalpe Sobitha Thera and Ven. Rajawatte
Vappe Thera outside the Buddha Sasana Ministry. The Buddhist monks
suspended the fast when the government represented by Ministers
Lokubandara and Karu Jayasuriya held lengthy discussions with National
Sangha Conference president Ven. Dr. Ellawala Medhanada Thera.
The
Ministers had undertaken to gazette within fourteen days from December
30 the names of the twenty-member advisory council comprising monks
from all three Nikayas with at least five monks representing the
National Sangha Conference. They said the Bill would be presented
as an 'Urgent Bill'.
Meanwhile
the Prime Minister's office had announced that it had appointed
a ministerial sub committee consisting of Ministers W.J.M. Lokubandara,
John Amaratunga, T. Maheswaran, Karunasena Kodituwakku and Rauff
Hakeem, to look into unethical conversions and legal and other steps
necessary to curb this type of conversions. They are expected to
consult dignitaries of all religious groups with a view to obtaining
their views and the sub committee hopes to present its recommendations
as soon as possible. It has also been decided to establish 'Religious
Amity Committees’ at district and provincial levels in a bid
to defuse the current religious tension and to prevent any type
of religious conflicts rearing its ugly head in this already battered
Island of ours.
In
August last year the Supreme Court ruled that although it was permissible
under our Constitution for a person to manifest his or her religion,
propagating another's religion would not be permissible, as the
Constitution does not guarantee the fundamental right to do so.
The
bench comprising Justices Shirani Bandaranayake, H.S.Yapa and Nihal
Jayasinghe ruled, that where there is no fundamental right to propagate,
if efforts are taken to convert another person to one's own religion,
such conduct could hinder the very existence of the Buddha Sasana
which is to be given prominence by the State, under article 9 of
the Constitution. What is guaranteed under Article 14(1)(e) of the
Constitution is the manifestation, observance and practice of one's
own religion while the propagation and spreading of Christianity
as postulated in terms of clause three of the Bill in question,
would not be permissible, as it would impair the very existence
of Buddhism or the Buddha Sasana.
National
Sangha Conference president Ven. Dr. Ellawala Medhanada Thera told
The Sunday Times that although the Constitution says the Buddha
Sasana be granted foremost place by the state, whole villages have
been converted to Christianity using aid sent by western countries.
The
Thera said that as Buddhists, they value religious tolerance and
recognised one’s freedom to believe in any religion but converting
to another religions by means financial inducements or social welfare
should be prohibited by law as in many other countries.
The
Thera said that although they were against fundamentalist Christian
groups, they are not against traditional Christian churches. Ven.
Medananda Thera said he had invited the Catholic Church to send
a representative to the fast, if the statement issued by the Catholic
Church denouncing fundamentalists was sincere.
Ven.
Dr. Ellawala Medhanada Thera had unveiled a programme to inform
the public about the work of the National Sangha Conference held
at Buddha Sasana Ministry.
He
said that there were 176 odd organisations registered under Company
Act, and 159 prayer centres have been set up throughout the country,
and are attempting to destroy the Buddha Sasana. The Auxiliary Bishop
of Colombo, Rt. Rev. Dr. Marius Peiris, told The Sunday Times that
the Catholic Church was totally against unethical conversions, as
it was a hindrance to a person’s fundamental rights. He said
the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Sri Lanka would meet when the
Bill was ready and make its stand known on the Bill, after closely
studying its clauses.
Batticaloa
Bishop Rt. Rev. Dr. Kingsley Swampillai , said that the Roman Catholic
Church along with other traditional churches have had longstanding
amicable relations with other religious groups and said that unethical
conversions was a danger to the Catholic Church as well.
In
a statement issued on December 18, the Archbishop of Colombo Rt.
Rev. Dr. Oswald Gomis, said "the Catholic Church is not bent
on getting people of other religions converted by wrongful and illegitimate
means"
Rev.
Noel Fernando, President of the Methodist Church, which is a constituent
member of the National Christian Council (NCC) of Sri Lanka, told
The Sunday Times that the introduction of such a Bill, is not healthy
as relegious freedom of an individual could be harmed as the Bill
may be variously interpreted.
Anglican
Bishop of Kurunegala the Rt. Rev. Kumar Illangasinghe who is also
President of the NCC, the umbrella organisation of the other traditional
churches - (Anglican, Methodist, Baptist, Salvation Army, Dutch
Reformed, Presbyterian Churches and Church of South India - other
than the Roman Catholic Church) was not available for comment.
Christian
Affairs Minister John Amaratunga told The Sunday Times that extremist
political groups were allegedly responsible for the religious strife
in the country and also for the recent attacks on Churches.
He
said that although the churches attacked were allegedly involved
in unethical conversions, asked why the Roman Catholic and Anglican
Churches were attacked as well. Mr. Amaratunga said the Police were
lethargic in inquiring into complaints made by Churches that have
been attacked.
Hindu
Affairs Minister, T. Maheswaran, who had been in the forefront of
the struggle to bring a Bill against unethical conversions, told
The Sunday Times that Hindus are in solidarity with their Buddhist
brothers regarding the Bill. He said to express that solidarity,
he had organized a demonstration of about 200 Hindu priests from
Jaffna, on January 9.
Buddha
Sasana Minister W.J.M. Lokubandara told The Sunday Times that his
Ministry would do everything possible to bring necessary legislation
in due course.
Report
of the Presidential Buddha Sasana Commission
The Buddha Sasana Presidential Commission Report made public in
the final quarter of 2003, mentions under its aims and objectives
that it was appointed to "to propose appropriate steps to prevent
the registration, under various laws and acts, of individuals and/or
groups having beliefs that are different to that of traditional
religious institutions and as a result strategically bend the people
to their beliefs."
It
recommends "that appropriate steps be taken to prevent religious
conflicts in future, as converting Buddhists to other religions
by various means, have been violent at several instances",
that "an act be brought to prohibit conversion and proselytising,
by nonconformist provocative means and make it a penal offence under
Penal Code", "the approval of the Interfaith Advisory
Council - which constitutes of representatives of each religion,
proportional to their population- be obtained for the registration
of a new missionary or fundamentalist group"
"
Sasanarakshaka councils be vested with authority to investigate
into complaints of Buddhists being converted to other religions"
" the termination of the licenses of organisations involved
in proselytising Buddhists under the guise of social service".
The
Buddha Sasana Presidential Commission Report lists 110 Christian
Associations registered in the Department of Registrar of Companies.
It specifically points out "World Vision Christian Organisation",
"Assemblies of God (AOG)", "Jehovah's Witnesses",
"Pentecostal Church" as being involved in conversions.
|