Doctors
say assault was real
Medical report shows JHU monk
suffered multiple injuries in June 8 parliament brawl
JHU official complains of shoddy treatment at government-run hospital
By Santhush Fernando
As medical evidence quashed claims by UPFA politicians that JHU
National Organizer and parliamentarian Ven. Kolonawe Siri Sumangala
Thera was not injured in the scuffle in the June 8 Parliament brawl,
new allegations that the monk did not receive proper treatment at
the government-run Sri Jayawardenepura General Hospital (SJGH) have
surfaced.
Confirming
JHU allegations, a medical report prepared by top physician Dr.
Vajira Tennakoon of the Nawaloka Hospital affirms that the monk
suffered rotator cuff injury to the right shoulder, contusion (blood
clot) in the right transverse abdominal muscle and overlying subcutaneous
tissue, which caused urinary retention.
The
report said that Ven. Sumangala Thera complained of a physical assault
on June 8 … in Parliament. He said he had received blows to
the lower abdomen and right shoulder. His upper limb had been subjected
to violent twisting and pulling. He complained of severe pain in
the right shoulder and lower abdomen. At the time of admission to
the Sri Jayawardenepura General Hospital (SJGH), he was unable to
pass urine because of the pain in the lower abdomen. A urinary catheter
had been inserted.
The
report says the monk was examined at Nawaloka by Dr. Lalith Wijeratne,
Consultant Rheumatologist who observed (and recorded) limitation
of internal rotation of the right shoulder joint due to intense
pain and contusion on the lower anterior abdominal wall in the region
of the right iliac fossa. Dr. Narendra Pinto, Consultant Orthopaedic
Surgeon has noted limitation of extension, internal and external
rotation of the right shoulder joint due to the pain. He was transferred
to the Medical Intensive Care Unit for further observation.
Dr.
Tennakoon says he "confirmed the limitation of movement of
the right shoulder joint and the presence of a tender contusion
on the anterior abdominal wall".
He
says he advised a trial period without the catheter but the monk
experienced, the next morning, difficulty in passing urine once
again. The ultrasound scan of the abdomen done on June 10 evening
at Nawaloka Hospital by Dr. Sanjeewa Munasinghe Consultant Radiologist
has confirmed the presence of a contusion of the right transverse
abdominis muscle and the overlying subcutaneous tissue, the report
says.
Meanwhile,
Nalaka Wijesinghe, Coordinating Secretary of Ven. Sumangala Thera,
alleged that the monk did not receive proper treatment or attention
at the SJGH. He said he believed it was because the hospital staff
was pressurized by interested parties.
Mr.
Wijesinghe said the hospital staff told him that the injuries were
not serious the monk had only suffered what they called a "small
bruise". He said the family members of the monk then decided
to take him to a private hospital because they feared for the safety
of the monk in a government-run hospital.
At
this stage, SJGH doctors objected to it and insisted that the monk
at least undergo an ECG test. Mr. Wijesinghe said the manner in
which the management of the hospital treated the case gave rise
to doubts that they were trying to hide the true condition of the
monk - a suspicion, which, he said, gained more credence when the
hospital authorities denied media personnel any access to the monk.
The
coordinating secretary said he used his camera phone, took some
pictures of the monk, and gave them to the media. He said the monk
told him that he complained of a severe abdominal pain around midnight,
but no doctor attended to him for one hour. A lady doctor who arrived
around 1 a.m. instructed the staff to insert a catheter.
Mr.
Wijesinghe said that he also learnt that the monk was made to walk
a considerable distance to the toilet and his pleas for alternate
arrangements fell on deaf ears. The coordinating secretary said
that when he took up the matter with the management, he was told
that even if the Mahanayake Thera was admitted, he would be treated
in the similar manner.
Mr.
Wijesinghe also alleged that even when he was being discharged,
a male nurse refused to remove the saline needle from the monk's
hand. Denying these charges, SJGH Director Dr. D. L de Lanerolle
said the monk was given the room in a ward where even prelates had
been treated and the staff there was familiar with rules and respects
accorded to a monk.
The
director said the staff was concerned about the monk and had even
complained about the lack of privacy for the monk in the ward where
some 15 people were receiving treatment.
Meanwhile
JHU Advisor Tilak Karunaratne, referring to the June 8 incident
in parliament said the party was awaiting the setting up of the
Parliamentary Privileges Committee to take up the matter with the
Speaker.
He
said those responsible for the attack should be suspended after
the inquiry by the committee or the committee's report should be
sent to the Supreme Court for the determination of a penalty.
However,
the two JHU monks - Ven. Sumangala Thera and Ven. Akmeemana Dayarathana
Thera - had said they would not name the people as such an exercise
was against the Dhamma.
JHU
leader Ven. Ellawala Medhananda Thera in a letter to President Chandrika
Kumaratunga said the JHU would not engage in any action, which would
penalise the offenders. However, he called on the President to guarantee
the functioning of the Parliament and accept the wrong doing of
the UPFA.
Meanwhile,
Minister Jeevan Kumaratunga, who is in the center of the allegations,
denied that he assaulted or manhandled the monk. He said what happened
on June 8 was just a protest by Government MPs against the decision
of the Speaker to swear in a JHU MP and added he had not been questioned
by police so far.
Deputy
Minister Sripathy Sooriyaarachchi warned of a 500-million-rupee
law suit if police tried to question him without a formal complaint. |