Is
ban on Sunday tuition classes necessary or practical?
By Sachitra Mahendra and Harinda Vithange
A JVP proposal to ban private tuition classes on Sundays has come
in for strong criticism from principals, students and tuition and
school masters claiming that it would have an adverse effect on
students who depend on tuition.
A
group of tuition teachers are planning a protest rally against the
proposed ban on holding tuition classes for students below Advanced
Level on Sunday mornings between 8 and 12. Thus this decision would
affect students preparing for the Ordinary Level examination.
Cultural
Affairs Minister, Vijitha Herath is behind the move for the ban
claiming it would help children attend religious classes held on
Sundays in temples and other places of worship.
But
this proposal, which had already been approved by the cabinet, has
come under fire from parties who would be affected by the move.
"Even though the A/L classes are exempted, we are against this
move", Tilak Mahanama, a leading tuition master of Economics
told The Sunday Times.
"We
have enough holidays. Employees earn much on Sundays due to tuition
classes. The decision to ban tuition takes away the right of the
people to work on Sundays. It's the people's right to decide whether
or not they should work on a Sunday. Government has no right to
enforce a ban on the workers' freedom", he said.
"Tuition
does have an impact in obtaining better results. If tuition was
abolished, what about the students, who live in areas where they
have no other recourse", Polonnaruwa Royal College Principal
H. K. Jayasekara told The Sunday Times.
Principals
of a number of leading schools are of the opinion that banning tuition
classes on Sundays was not practical. Kingswood College Principal
R. Chandrasekara told The Sunday Times that there was no law to
implement the ban and many of the Ordinary Level tuition classes
are held on Sundays.
"With
the Ordinary Level examinations due at the end of the year just
a few months away it would be unsettling to ban Sunday tuition classes",
A.R. Ranasinghe, a student of Peradeniya Madya Maha Vidyalaya said.
Students
believe that a loss of at least three to four hours of class studies
on Sunday mornings would be a setback to their year end performance.
Most students depend on Ordinary Level exam results to apply to
better schools for their Advanced Level studies and the proposal
if effected could affect them, a teacher of a school in Dehiwala
who did not want to be named said.
However
it was not only the O/L students but also students studying in year
six grades upward as well who would be affected by this impractical
move. UNP parliamentarian Bandula Gunawardena himself a former tuition
teacher commenting on the move told The Sunday Times the ban was
highly impractical.
"The
British Council conducted the largest English tuition classes in
Sri Lanka. So do the French and Russian institutes where languages
are taught. Many of the artistes too conduct classes on Sunday.
I am doubtful if they will stop their activities even if the government
implements the ban", Mr. Gunawardena said.
"Students
have sports practices on weekends. Those who could afford to can
bring individual teachers to their homes. You can't expect that
children would attend Sunday school even though the government bans
tuition classes", Mr. Gunawardena explained.
He
said that, in a highly competitive environment it was unfair by
the pupils to have the tuition classes banned. "Pupils attend
classes because they need the extra knowledge and may be also because
they do not get sufficient help at school. This is a problem that
should be addressed seriously", he said.
Cultural
Affairs Minister Vijitha Herath said that the necessary groundwork
for the Bill to ban tuition classes on Sundays was in progress and
would be put into effect as soon as possible. "This proposal
will certainly be implemented since Cabinet approval has already
been obtained. We hope to get the opinion of others as well before
finalising it", Minister Herath told The Sunday Times.
When
asked about individual or private classes, he said such activity
automatically becomes illegal. "Those who complain can rearrange
the class times for after 12 noon", the Minister said. |