Playing
politics with tsunami
By Our Political Editor
The tsunami had more victims than one could imagine.
Not just the dead, the injured, the orphaned, the displaced and
the traumatised, but many others - the victims of despair. The highest
in the land were not immune to fall victim. Ever since the December
26 news that came with the tidal waves indicating that the north-east
district of Mullaitivu was smashed to smithereens, came the stories
suggesting that the rebels of the LTTE, its leaders and its cadres
were washed away in its aftermath.
It
was a fact that the LTTE suffered losses. Even if it was not officially
acknowledged, numbers have exceeded 1200 fighting cadres. Worst
hit are the Sea Tigers, their naval arm. They lost Chelian, their
second in command. The Sea Tiger capability has been badly dented.
Then,
as the waters receded the speculation rose that LTTE leader Velupillai
Prabhakaran, its Sea Tiger leader Soosai, its intelligence chief
Pottu Amman, its political chief S.P. Thamilselvan were swept away
with the tide.
Last
week, these rumours came to boiling point. State-run Sri Lanka Broadcasting
Corporation claimed Chief of Defence Staff and Navy Commander Vice
Admiral Daya Sandagiri had told it that the whereabouts of Prabhakaran
were unknown. This led the radio to announce that Prabhakaran was
missing, possibly dead, quoting Sandagiri as the source. The next
day, one newspaper ran a story that two expensive coffins had been
sent to the LTTE-controlled Wanni by road. It (not the coffins,
but the story) took everyone for a ride. Read together with the
previous day's state radio account, Prabhakaran was pronounced dead.
The world was told how the Sri Lankan media (both state and private)
had joined to report the demise of the 'Sun-God', who apparently
has no magical powers over water. Prabhakaran, like all elusive
guerrillas, has been pronounced dead many times over. But, like
it or not, he carries on.
The
first rumour, soon after the Boxing Day tsunami, was that he died
inside a church by the coast when its roof collapsed. The second,
he was drowned in a bunker. The two stories did prompt a response
from the Wanni jungles of the LTTE. That was how it came to pass
that the LTTE leader placed his signature in Tamil on a statement
where he sympathised with tsunami victims in the South.
Like
the tsunami waves, the story of the death of Prabhakaran gathered
speed as the week began. The retraction by state radio soon after
they found they could not substantiate the story was missed by most,
and the newspaper that reported the coffins being sent to the Wanni
had no follow up other than to follow up on some other stories reported
by the world and local press of an old man who was found in the
post-tsunami rubble, saying the story was untrue and had taken everyone
for a ride. There was a deafening silence on their own story that
had caused a 'sensation'.
At
President's House, none other than President Chandrika Kumaratunga
was a victim of this new tsunami-story wave hitting all parts of
Sri Lanka, India, and the world. She called for her Chief of Defence
Staff and Naval chief Daya Sandagiri and she yelled to him, "what
are you doing - haven't they found the body of Prabhakaran?"
Navy Commander Sandagiri must have initially thought his Commander-in-Chief
was being sarcastic, for he was the man associated with the first
report by SLBC suggesting that the rebel supremo had probably died.
Then, he realised that she was serious - dead serious.
Commander
Sandagiri began a search for the body of Velupillai Prabhakaran,
as the tsunami-like story was causing havoc all over. Glasses were
being raised at Colombo's clubs by members refusing to disbelieve
the story. New versions were turning up. The common question being
asked, however, was, "why is he not showing up then?"
Prabhakaran's
erstwhile deputy Karuna was one of them to ask this question. At
the Defence Ministry, the hierarchy was equally convinced that the
man most Sri Lankans love to hate, the man responsible for two decades
of misery for the Sinhalese, Tamils and the Muslims alike in this
country, was now in the dustbin of history. The only silver lining
of the tsunami devastation, they said, was this.
Newly
appointed Defence Secretary Asoka Jayawardene was also convinced.
He told the DII (Directorate of Internal Intelligence), the boys
who monitor the work of the LTTE, that they should devote more attention
to reports on Prabhakaran's death. It seemed that even if they could
not defeat him militarily, they should get to know about his demise
through a national calamity, soonest.
One
thing these Government Intelligence top brass could have easily
done was to check with an expatriate Tamil Fund Manager who is reported
to have actually met Prabhakaran after the tsunami hit Mullaitivu.
This was reported in this column last week. His identity is easy
to establish - it is not a top secret as such. He has already given
interviews to the local press as well about post-tsunami relief
projects. Whether this Fund Manager who has invested in a lot of
Sri Lankan business ventures, gave US $ 5 million to Prabhakaran
is probably not the issue now, it is to ascertain whether Prabhakaran
survived the tsunami.
In
Colombo's diplomatic community, however, there was less excitement.
They had made inquiries after the first rumour, and had been assured
the man is alive and kicking. The news will become public soon.
That is when Norway's Foreign Minister Jan Petersen, who arrives
with a significant entourage, visits the Wanni. They will arrive
in Colombo on Wednesday. Also in the delegation are Norway's International
Development Minister Hilde F. Johnson, Deputy Foreign Minister Vidar
Helgessen and Special Envoy Erik Solheim. Petersen and party who
are coming with aid are due to have a meeting with Prabhakaran.
Already diplomatic contacts are under way.
The
search for Prabhakaran's corpus apart, the search for political
unity in the 'south' of Sri Lanka has been as daunting a task. Not
for years since Sirima Bandaranaike contacted Dudley Senanayake
before she signed the Sirima-Shastri Pact in New Delhi, or J.R.
Jayewardene offered co-operation to Ms. Bandaranaike in the aftermath
of the 1971 JVP insurgency, has there been any glimmer of bi-partisanship
in the politics of Sri Lanka.
The
tsunami tragedy saw some cosmetic appearance by the party leaders
at a National Day of Mourning on December 31, and then it was back
to basics. The opposition UNP blaming the UPFA government for hogging
the relief work despite the national nature of the calamity.
If
it had to be a then second string British MP Liam Fox who had to
bring together UNP's Opposition Leader Ranil Wickremesinghe and
President Kumaratunga some years back - despite half a century of
Independence from the British - to have a common approach to the
LTTE question, the meeting this week between Wickremesinghe and
Kumaratunga, was also prodded, to a great extent, by the international
community.
Wickremesinghe
had been complaining to the visiting foreign dignitaries and the
foreign ambassadors based in Sri Lanka about the UPFA government's
handling of the relief work. The gravamen of his arguement has been
that the President's Secretariat has tried to centralise the complex
issue of national re-construction, sidelining civil society, NGOs,
and even the opposition in a bid to make political capital out of
the national disaster.
At
the meeting, Wickremesinghe repeated most of this to the President.
He pointed out that even her coalition ally, the JVP, was complaining
that she was not handling the disaster relief work properly. The
JVP had been under a different accusation of trying to score political
points by hi-jacking the tsunami relief work in the southern coastal
areas, but it too was indeed complaining of the President's questionable
committees that were running the 'show'. President Kumaratunga responded
by saying that her government had incorporated many of the issues
raised by the UNP in the task of national re-building.
Wickremesinghe
read from the UNP's point-by-point proposals on what the government
should do. He then emphasised the need to re-build the lives of
the people before putting into place any grand long-term designs
for the future. He said that the small hotels needed support to
re-build, and that the houses of the affected people should sprout
pronto, arguing that when there is life among the affected, the
nation will automatically spring to life itself.
He
emphasised the need to ensure that aid went direct to the affected
people rather than get blocked in government pipelines, and promoted
the intervention of NGOs and civil societies in the exercise. He
pointed out, as he had told the visiting dignitaries and ambassadors
that it were the village system - the viharas, the churches, the
local community leaders, who were first at the scene during the
tragedy, not the government, and that it was these functionaries
that needed to be involved in the national recovery from the tsunami.
President
Kumaratunga explained what her government was doing. She said that
her trusted point-man Mano Tittawella would come up with the grand
proposals for re-construction by next month, while her trusted point-woman
Tara de Mel was carrying out the relief chores.
Foreign
Minister Lakshman Kadirgamar then asked Wickremesinghe if he or
any UNPer had told foreign ambassadors that they should link foreign
aid to the peace process (an issue also referred to in this column
last week). President Kumaratunga followed it up saying "yes,
yes, I was also wondering about it", to which Wickremesinghe
said that he did not link emergency aid to the peace process.
In
the meantime, questions persisted about the Presidential Committees
appointed to handle the country's biggest natural disaster, and
the calibre of those appointed to run it. The UN gave a slap in
the face when it said that it has appointed PricewaterCooper, the
well-known international accounting firm, to do the accounting of
"every cent" that is being given as tsunami aid, a terrible
indictment on the powers-that-be who have allowed bribery and corruption
to be a way of governance in Sri Lanka.
Within
the committees, the squabbling has already started. Cat-fights have
begun. The JVP, an ally of the UPFA government has called for the
widening of the scope of these committees saying on-going efforts
were "not enough".
It
has listed the areas which need to be given priority attention -
collection of data; planning committees; relief committees; human
resources (local and foreign); to co-ordinate local and foreign
aid; building national opinion - and the setting up of a separate
auditing and accounts section.
The
President's Office has remained silent for too long now on how it
plans to audit and account for all this money coming in. The JVP
has also called for members of the Armed Services and Police, professionals
and even businessmen (presumably not just the ones who have been
appointed so far) to be in these seven committees it proposes.
Clearly,
the President has to expand and embrace others. This is a national
disaster, not a PA disaster. She is already accused of vacillating
on the passing of the Sri Lanka Disaster Counter-Measures Bill of
2002, and have done nothing except to hog the Ministry in charge
of National Disaster during the cohabitation period with the UNF
government of Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe.
That
draft bill for the "establishment of the National Council for
Disaster Management, the National Disaster Management Centre; the
preparation of Disaster Management Plans; the declaration of a state
of disaster " etc., was locked in parochial Sri Lankan politics.
That
bill had under section 25 (f) of that proposed law the word "tsunami"
in it, described as "seismic wave" as one of the meanings
of what a "disaster" is. The country's engineers proposed
this law, and the Legal Draftsman's Department had the law ready.
But the bickering politicians were not ready for the tsunami that
eventually hit us. |