Improvisation,
innovation, yes, but was there creativity?
"Innovative Music Meeting" by the (unsuspected)
sea featuring Rohan de Saram (cello), Rajesh Mehta (trumpet) &
Piyasara Shilpadhipathi (drums) at the Galle Face Hotel on December
22
The
generous applause notwithstanding, I have no doubt that the majority
of the audience were wondering what quite to make of this concert,
subtitled "An Exceptional Improvisation Concert". The
music emanating from it was such a far cry from what local audiences
have hitherto associated with the name of Rohan de Saram.
The
concert's title and subtitle did, of course, provide a clue as to
what might be expected. It was to be music of an "innovative"
type, and "exceptional" in the sense of its largely "improvisatory"
nature.
To
say the least, the music was most innovative. It explored wholly
unexpected and unsuspected sonic effects of the cello and the trumpet.
To this end, the instruments themselves were played innovatively.
The cello strings were sometimes strummed as well as plucked, the
bow alternately droned out wavering quasi-pedal notes, executed
the wildest of glissandos and engaged in high-frequency harmonics,
sometimes straying well beyond the bridge and having even its rod
pressed into service. As for the trumpet, apart from being of modified
design, its playing was augmented by a succession of gadgetry, notably
a length of tubing that was twirled about at regular intervals rather
like a lasso in slow motion. There were times when one could not
tell whether a certain sound came from the cello or the trumpet!
The drums, in fact, were the only link with the conventional, providing
a recognizably percussive rhythmic accompaniment.
It
was essentially, as Arun Dias Bandaranaike cautioned in his introduction,
music that had more to do with textures, timbre and ambience than
with scales and harmonies. This became clearest in the item, "The
elements". Here, the cello and the trumpet seemed to be attempting
to capture the effects of the elements fire, water, earth and air,
in strictly elemental rather than in musical terms, virtually mimicking
their audible aspects, real or imaginary, through sound effects
without employing actual musical sounds. Form, evidently, consisted
in the overall ambience produced by these effects.
It
was all quite captivating. Then, as the players went on to other
compositions cum improvisations one felt that, for all the permutations
and variations of sound and rhythm, it was all much of a muchness.
And one began to realize that while the music was highly innovative,
it was not strictly creative. We were privy not to a creative but
to an innovative process, to a session of improvisation that had
more to do with experimentation than with inspiration. The exhilaration
was there but sans the creative impulse. "Consequently we rejoice,
having to construct something upon which to rejoice"!
And
if the creative imagination was not at work, this was surely because
the basic musical principle was missing. The music sought to reproduce
the various sounds and noises of our environment on their own rather
than on musical terms. (It was as if Beethoven had made of such
sound effects as the call of the cuckoo the staple, not the mere
embellishment, of his Pastoral Symphony!). Thus while the superficies
of music were in full evidence, the textures, the timbre, the ambience,
in fact the whole range of sound effects, the reality that all this
is meant to serve was missing, namely musical sound itself. There
was neither tonality nor atonality, surely the sine qua non of music,
because the basic ingredient of musical sound, the interval - the
deliberate exploration of the relationship between the pitch of
notes - whether vertically or horizontally or both, was absent.
The creative imagination, thus, had no basic musical substance to
work on. The interval is the core, the key, to all true music of
whatever tradition, whether western or eastern, classical, jazz
or folk, composed or improvised. Although this music purported to
be derived from some of these traditions, this was so only in an
impressionistic and imitative sense, as in the fleeting echoes of
the Carnatic nadeswaram or the jazz trumpet or the dance-hall double-bass.
There was no recreation of these elements to make new musicals sense.
And
yet, I would not have missed this concert for the world. The experience
of this music was stimulating if only to be able to place it as
not being part of the great musical tradition, both western and
eastern, that we are heir to. But more importantly for the three
minutes of a Bach prelude and the five or more minutes of a Kodaly
sonata that de Saram gave us, playing solo, in the first and second
halves of the concert respectively. He did this, he told us, to
remind us that it was, in fact, a cello that he was playing. But
I do not believe that any player, local or foreign, has in this
country put bow to string to such marvellous effect. Here were texture
and timbre etc. in their proper place, servants of great musical
sound, put to work by a great performer.
The
Bach passage was played with such power and feeling that the austere
beauty of the Bach line seemed to catch fire and be ablaze throughout.
It was playing worthy of the great Casals, one of de Saram's teachers
who, incidentally, is said to have been unable to do without some
Bach every day. As for the almost impossibly difficult Kodaly, which
employed double stopping most of the way, the 'cello in de Saram's
loving hands assumed such heights of urgent, even strident, poignancy
as one would have thought only the human voice to be capable of.
Here was real creativity of performance, the genius of the performer
combining with the genius of the composer to bring out the full
potential of the music.
And
here was first-hand evidence of the real basis of music, the pattern
of sound formed by intervals, whether consistently tonal in the
Bach or disturbingly dissonant in the equally moving and expressive
Kodaly. These two excerpts were utterly and unquestionably part
of "the still sad music of humanity", to make literal
use of the Wordsworthian phrase, in a way that the rest of that
evening's music could never have been. We in Sri Lanka have been
starved of great music like this as played by great performers like
de Saram. We are in even greater need of it following the tragedy
that submerged our country not more than four days after the concert.
I urge Rohan de Saram, and it is not my appeal alone, to give us
a preponderance of such truly creative music on his future visit
with a modicum, if necessary, of the merely innovative variety.
–
Priya David
Music
and dance for friends in need
Friends in Harmony and Channa Upuli Art Foundation will perform
in a concert organized by the Alumni Association, Colombo University,
to aid tsunami victims.
The
evening's programme will consist of music and dance from two famous
groups, 'Friends-in-Harmony', a group of professionals who have
got together for the love of music, and Channa Upuli, the well-known
dance ensemble who performed at the Sydney Opera House recently.
All
artistes are performing free of charge to raise maximum funds for
this worthy cause. The concert will take place at the New Town Hall,
Green Path on February 20 at 6.30 p.m.
Student
of seduction
Sathsara Ilangasingha, a third year student of the Department of
Art and Sculpture, Institute of Aesthetic Studies, University of
Kelaniya will hold an exhibition of his paintings from January 28
to 31 at the Lionel Wendt Art Gallery.
Commenting
on his work Sathsara says, "My new exhibition, 'Seduction'
presents many important ideas. Human forms are produced with detached
shapes using colourful mixed colours with quick brush work on square
shaped drawing surfaces.
"In
one of my creations the Sigiri Goddess bears a "Kadupul flower"
or the lotus Naga which represents the symbol of "seduction".
Drawing on both the European and Asian drawing styles, the "Kadupul
flower" has been used together with the Sigiri Goddess.
“
We can be seduced by anyone or anything,” he explains. In
a primitive society, primeval productive acts (economical, social,
psychological and artistic) all happened by force or by order or
by assignment.
"But
now in polite society democratic and human rights are regarded on
a high level. So none can interfere. Today, even an advertisement
for cement needs to show a woman's legs. Knowingly or unknowingly
we are all seduced.”
‘An
artist of linear poetry’
An exhibition of Chandana Ranaweera's work will be on at the Alliance
Francaise de Kandy from Jan. 28 to February 3.
Writing
on his work, Prof. Ashley Halpe says Chandana spends hours creating
idiosyncratic figures of gods and men, mendicants and guardians,
on the meticulously laid out backgrounds and inner spaces created
with hundreds of thin penstrokes, squiggles and whorls, with pointilliste
brushwork, with unpredictable and unfashionable splotches of pastel
colours. But the figures he evokes have been drawn with swift, audaciously
elegant lines producing whimsical mouths and noses, suddenly staring
or weirdly hooded eyes, with drapes, accoutrements, tridents and
what you will, sketched, sometimes just suggested, with marvellous
economy and certainty.
"There
are totally unpredictable spaces and inspired collocations in a
quirky world that is surely the unique vision of an instinctively
original mind, despite the deceptively simple identifications in
terms of Buddhist themes and tales.
"Chandana
Ranaweera has been called "an artist of linear poetry".
Chandana's command of technical resources is now rather more developed,
as I have suggested in my impressionistic responses to the present
collection. It is now clear that he affects naivete as a deliberate
creative choice, deploying his images, arabesques and chromatic
adventures with the instinctive sophistication of a constant practitioner.
"Chandana
has defined his artistic vocabulary and is content to let originality
appear in the disposition of his pictorial elements on surfaces
that encourage a miniaturist scale. Our appreciation of his work
involves an admiration for the courage of his choice."
She
will dance for Lanka’s tsunami children
One of India's most inspired and dedicated Bharata Natyam exponents
of her generation, Priyadarsini Govind, graces the Colombo stage
on Monday, January 31, at the Bishop's College Auditorium at 7 p.m.
The
proceeds of the show will go to children affected by the tsunami
disaster. The event is being organized by the International Centre
for Ethnic Studies, Colombo, Law and Society Trust and the Neelan
Tiruchelvam Trust.
Acclaimed
not only for the exquisite perfection of her dance, Priyadarsini
is also hailed as a creative artiste, who brings to every one of
her items depth, intensity and grace. A Commerce graduate with a
course in Mass Communication, Priyadarsini had her training under
the guidance of her gurus, Sri Swamimalai K. Rajarathnam and Smt.
Kalanidhi Narayanan. She has performed in various cities in India
and abroad at the Festival of India, Paris, Yuva Utsavat at Kanpur
and recitals in South Africa, USA, Canada and Europe.
Priyadarsini
is the recipient of many awards, including the "Kalaimamani"
the highest award from the Tamil Nadu Government, the Yuva Kala
Bharathi', Bharat Kalachar award, and the prestigious Krishna Gana
Sabha award "Nrithya Choodamani". The box plan opens at
the ICES on January 21. |