data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7ede1/7ede116c41cddd24d5904bfa28c28ae80c5ed9bf" alt=""
Muscles vs. Flexibility – Choice for employees
and employers
“Workers’ new flexibility spurs upturn
in Europe” writes Marcus Walker from Dorfen, Germany in the
Wall Street Journal of July 24, 2006, setting the scene for “keeping
jobs at home”.
“After a long slump, strong exports and
new flexibility in companies labour relations are laying the groundwork
that could sustain economic recovery in Germany and some other parts
of Europe. The reason is on display amid the stepped gables of this
medieval town, where a pump and valve company has just done something
rare for Germany in the past five years; It opened a new Factory,”
writes Walker who goes on to state, “Only last year, HAWE
Hydraulics was a part of the trend that was taking jobs from high-cost
Germany and moving them to countries with lower labour costs. The
midsize, family –owned company opened a factory in 2005 in
Bangalore, India, saying the cost savings were too big to spurn.
‘We can’t afford to be romantic about locations,’
said Chief Executive Karl Haesgen, grandson of a company founder”.
He goes on to say, “But now HAWE has decided
to invest at home again. To avoid losing more jobs, HAWE’s
workers hammered out new labour arrangements with Mr. Haeusgen that
includes Saturday shifts, flexible work hours, and profit-sharing
in place of fixed bonuses. The changes made it possible for Mr.
Haeusgen to justify building his factory in Germany” and “Longer,
less regular hours for no extra pay didn’t come easily to
a workforce used to a 35 hour, five day week.
The backlash led chief negotiator Joself Olasz
to step down as chairman of the council that represents workers
at the company. Critics accused him of getting too cozy with company
management. ‘We saved jobs,’ Mr. Olasz responds”.
“The Euro region is poised to post its strongest
economic growth since the technology boom of 2000. The 2.2% expansion
projected for this year would be the largest improvement in the
growth rate among the world’s big, developed economies. Amid
signs that U.S, growth is losing steam, it is a timely revival that
could help prevent a global slowdown. Rising employment in Germany
is expected to drive stronger domestic demand, adding momentum to
an export-driven recovery that was draining, not adding, jobs. Germany
is Europe’s largest economy and in recent years has been one
of its most stagnant. But the nation has led in developing a robust
export industry and in the corporate restructuring that has finally
begun to create jobs.”
He sums up with the following quotes worthy of
attention of Sri Lankan business leaders: “Europe’s
economic slump has given companies new muscle in their negotiations
with workers.
The governments in Europe have been slow to overhaul
worker friendly labour laws for fear of incurring voters’
wrath” and “German industry has gone furthest in overhauling
work practices within strict labour laws and union accords common
across Europe.
Companies now are pressing their employees to
work longer, more flexible hours and to forgo pay increases, using
the threat of moving jobs abroad as bargaining leverage. While pinching
employees, the changes have made operating in Germany more attractive,
stimulating local investment and helping the country hold on to
more jobs.”
In Sri Lanka our ‘Rathu Sahodarayas’
are warning that the trade unions in the four essential services
–the Port, the Railway, Petroleum and Electricity will form
an alliance to strengthen their bargaining power using their combined
clout to defeat the strong arm tactics of the rulers, and also that
workers should resort to the alternatives used by their counterparts
in countries considered as model democracies.
How much time, effort, resources and focused attention
to communications, worker education and labour relations bridge
building have the leaders of government, business, chambers and
employer organizations committed to in the recent years? How much
effort at sector level (rather than company level) has gone in to
Corporate Restructuring and overhauling work practices within strict
labour laws and union accords? How much of focus has been given
to profit sharing and ESOP’s and variable productivity and
profitability driven pay and bonus schemes for critical sectors
of the economy?
Too little is the obvious answer, leaving aside
some noteworthy individual company achievements and “nothing”
as far as taking the debate on issues, best practices and what is
happening in the global village public is concerned and the longer
term impact of continuing with present practices on the nation and
its people, especially awareness building involving family members,
and civil society as partners in the education and altitudinal change
management processes.
It is now time for change management initiatives
led by the private sector- without waiting for labour reforms other
wise “it will be like waiting for Godot” dreaming for
political masters to lead the way with reforms. Take a cue from
Germany and Europe and build this into the way forward strategy.
|