Environmentalists trample National Policy on Elephants
By Marisa de Silva
Provisions of the newly-drafted ‘National
Policy for the Conservation and Management of Wild Elephants in
Sri Lanka’, has come under fire from environmentalists.
The committee was appointed by the Environment
Ministry and the Wildlife Conservation Department and according
to Mammals Instructor Pubudu Weeraratna, among the matters raised
was the new concept of Managed Elephant Reserves (MERs) which has
been included in the proposed amendment to the Fauna and Flora Protection
Ordinance (FFPO).
|
A young tusker suffers from a swollen hind
leg and a large wound on his neck. |
“How can you base a section of a Policy
on an Ordinance that hasn’t even been submitted for approval
as yet,” Mr. Weeraratna asked.
According to the national policy, MERs are considered
to be the conservation areas other than those areas protected under
the Department of Wildlife conservation and forests managed by the
Forest Department.
Therefore, MER’s will essentially comprise
privately owned lands which won’t be essentially too conducive
for conservation, he added. The relocation of “problem animals”
is the next cause for concern faced by environmentalists as there
is no specific place demarcated to hold these animals in the event
the capacity of a specific Elephant Conservation Area (ECA) is exceeded.
Environmentalists point out that although the transferring of such
problem animals to Temporary Animal Holdings (TAH) is mentioned
there is little information given regarding the exact location or
the feasibility of constructing such areas.
Mr. Weeraratne said that when considering the
extent of tranquilising and the logistics involved in the translocation
process, it’s very strange that not even a single veterinarian
has been included in the 17-member committee set up to formulate
the new National Policy. He said the provision of thunder-flashes
to authorized village committees can have severe repercussions,
as gun powder used to set up these flashes may be used by poachers
for their trap guns or in hunting other animals. The new Policy
mentions that insufficient research has been done on the subject
of elephant management, with no obvious relevance to management
issues.
“Another provision we’re strongly
against is the use of trained elephants for safaris and patrolling
inside national parks,” environmentalist and aquatic instructor
Shantha Jayaweera said.
He said apart from the discomfort to the elephant,
if a trained elephant is to move about within the park carrying
tourists their safety is not guaranteed, as other elephants could
either attack the visiting elephant.
“Another related issue of great concern
that needs to be addressed, is the use of trained elephants for
safaris, especially in the Sigiriya and Habarana areas. We think
this should be banned as both the condition under which these elephants
work and the nature of their meals lead to the weakening of their
immune system resulting in premature death” Mr. Jayaweera
said.
He said the draft National Policy states that
the elephants should be made use for labour rather than the use
of machinery because unlike heavy machinery, elephants do not rust,
corrode or pollute the environment. They don’t need expensive
spare parts and elephants can work throughout the year, even during
the rainy season and on muddy surfaces that immobilize machines.
“This is particularly ridiculous, as anyone
who knows anything about elephants know that a male elephant cannot
work throughout the year as he needs to be tied up when he’s
in musk. Whereas, female elephants won’t be able to carry
heavy loads,” Mr. Jayaweera said.
The Policy goes on to state that wild elephants
are being killed at the rate of three animals per week and what’s
more tragic is that these animals are being slaughtered simply because
they destroy plantations and threaten the livelihood and lives of
people.
Former Zoological Gardens Director, H.A.N.T. Perera
who is one of the committee members said he was in fact able to
attend only one committee meeting and his input as far as the content
of the Policy goes was zero.
The Managing Trustee of the Biodiversity and Elephant
Conservation Trust (BECT) and an elephant enthusiast Jayantha Jayawardena
elaborated on some of the provisions of the Policy. He said the
elephant was compared to a machine primarily to show an elephant
was much cheaper and a lot less of an environmental hazard.
“Particularly since the government has decided
to capture “trouble elephants”, they need to be utilized
for some useful purpose. However, as far as auctioning these elephants
to private owners, my organisation (BECT), has submitted a list
of specifications to follow when short listing suitable applicants.
As an elephant requires about Rs. 40,000 a month on food, and about
Rs. 6,000 on drugs and its upkeep is very expensive. Therefore,
only those who had the necessary financial resources should be even
considered as eligible to own an elephant or elephants,” Dr.
Jaywardena said.
“We are also opposed to the Habarana and
Sigiriya elephant safaris as elephants are made to carry tourists
on their back under the burning mid afternoon sun over hot tarred
surfaces. Whereas, the Policy, states that the elephant should travel
in the shade, on soft ground, within the jungles that are more familiar
and comfortable to it,” he said and added that India had perfected
suitable seats, ensuring an elephant’s spine was not injured.
Over the past 50 years, there has been little
or no conservation or management policy compiled, Wildlife Conservation
Director General Dayananda Kariyawasam said.
Pinnawela
too short of ‘babies’ |
The Ministry of Promotion
of Botanical and Zoological Gardens (PBZG) has made an urgent
appeal to the Environmental Ministry for five baby elephants
for the Pinnawela Elephant Orphanage, with a warning of a
drop in their revenue by Rs. 100 million annually, if the
demand is not met. Ministry Secretary, S. Liyanagama, has
made a request to the Minister of Environment, Maithripala
Sirisena for the transfer from the Udawalawe Elephant Transit
Home, to Pinnawela.
“The Orphanage could also stand to lose a substantial
Rs. 90-100 million rupee annual revenue as a result of not
having baby elephants on display,” said PBZG Minster
Bandula Basnayake. However, there has been no response from
the Environment Ministry thus far, he said.
“Pinnawela also gets a huge milk quota donated from
overseas to feed the elephants, so if we don’t have
baby elephants, the milk will just go to waste,” he
said. In relation to the very real concern that the elephants
at the transit home are kept in semi-wild conditions so as
to be later released to the wild, Minister Basnayake said,
“Since the Transit Home doesn’t monitor the elephants
after release, they might as well give these elephants to
Pinnawela.”
However, Environment Minister, Maithripala Sirisena said,
“I have no knowledge of such a request for five baby
elephants and have no connection with the matter.”
Bringing more elephants to Pinnawela, especially from the
Transit Home, is doing a great disservice to the animals,
since once it becomes accustomed to humans. It will never
be able to return to the wild, said Environmental Lawyer -
Jagath Gunawardena from the Society for Environmental Education. |
Many
eager to buy ‘troubled jumbos’ |
Over 100 applicants have
expressed interest in buying “trouble elephants”
in an auction to be conducted by the Wildlife Department.
The “problem elephants” that needed to be auctioned
to private owners comprise some of the lingering male elephants
that refuse to be driven to other sanctuaries together with
the herd and those that break down the electric fences and
cause havoc in villages.
Wildlife Conservation Department Director General, Dayananda
Kariyawasam says that so far, they’ve identified approximately
30 “trouble elephants,” that would be auctioned
in batches.
“They will not be caught together. We will initially
conduct a pilot project and monitor its feasibility prior
to continuing with the programme,” he said.
These animals were identified as a result of two main drives
that were conducted in consultation with NGO’s, the
affected communities, AG’s Divisions, Wildlife officials
and other experts, he said. The male elephants that couldn’t
be driven could be dangerous if left alone, he said.
These lone male elephants tracked from the Anuradhapura,
Kurunegala, Puttalam, Hambantota, Moneragala, Polonnaruwa
and Ampara districts, would be captured and translocated until
they’re auctioned, explained Mr. Kariyawasam.
|
|