Explaining imperialism: The ‘feel
good effect’alone won’t do
By Charles Sarvan
About a good third of One Country
deals with what the book erroneously refers to as “colonialism”
in Sri Lanka: etymologically, the word comes from the
Latin colonia, meaning “farm” or “settlement”.
In what is now the United States, Europeans dispossessed
the native inhabitants of their land, killing off most
of them in the process. Time confers normalcy; normalcy
confers legitimacy, and founding facts are forgotten.
(See also, Canada, Australia and New Zealand). However,
Europeans did not settle in large numbers in Sri Lanka;
they did not make it their home and drive Sri Lankans
from the land. What “Ceylon” experienced
was not “colonialism” but “imperialism”.
Precisely because we are writing for little children
who think adults know better, we must be more, not less,
careful. To cite just one other example from the much
that is unclear or inaccurate, the Portuguese did not
rule Sri Lanka from 1505 to 1656: the first contact
was in 1505. (About twelve years later, a fortified
trading settlement was built but soon abandoned.)
|
The Rails and a Dutch Church:
Some aspects of our imperial legacy |
The book celebrates imperial legacy,
among them the baila we dance, certain kinds of food
we enjoy, the legal system, the English language and
parliamentary majoritarianism, but it fails to make
clear that these were by-products, and not the primary
motive or intention of imperial Europe. Imperialism
is the forcible occupation of foreign countries (with
or without a pretext or excuse), the subjugation of
the people, and the exploitation of resources entirely
for the benefit of the imperial country. It is difficult
to accept the full and equal humanity of members of
another group, and still suppress and exploit them.
It is therefore psychologically and emotionally necessary
not only to see the “Other” as different
but also as inferior: difference and inferiority become
the justification for maltreatment.
The British, particularly, were guilty
of “racial” and cultural contempt. Most
damagingly, in Africa and Asia, the natives, consciously
or not, came to accept and believe in their inherent
inferiority. This, in turn, facilitated the maintenance
and continuance of imperial rule: those who have been
“brainwashed” into thinking they are inferior
are unlikely to protest and fight. (Not so long ago,
a high compliment was to say of someone that he was
like a Sudha, that is, “White” man.)
The English language was introduced
not to the benefit of Sri Lankans but for the convenience
of imperial administrators and their political masters
back in Westminster. It was claimed that English was
a “link language” and would bring the different
ethnic groups together. But this was an illusion, if
not a fraud: English connected only the middle and upper
classes. Workers, and the rural folk who composed the
vast majority, were excluded. The Westernised “Ceylonese”
elite, moving within their circle, believed that everyone
who mattered in the island spoke English. However, a
1969 government publication, “Education in Sri
Lanka,” records that in 1946, two years before
independence, only 6.3% of the population was literate
in English. (My thanks to K.G. Kulasena, formerly of
the Education Research Institute for this information.)
A man or woman in a remote village, going to a local
office was confronted with a form printed in English.
In short, the majority of “Ceylonese”, though
living in their own country, were made to feel inferior
because they didn’t know a foreign language! And
it was not only language, but Sri Lankan culture that
was either neglected or looked down upon. Rural folk
were disregarded because they were traditional, were
godayas, rustics: see plays of bourgeois comedy such
as “Well, Mudaliyar”, “The Return
of Ralahamy” and “He comes from Jaffna”.
One Country exhorts us to be tolerant
but offers no help in understanding how and why we are
where we are at present, why there is so much mistrust
and resentment, anger and violence. To say that we must
be kind and inclusive may produce a cosy, warm, feeling,
but given the ground realities in Sri Lanka, surely
we are past the stage of vague and lofty exhortation?
What is desperately needed, both at the level of children
and of adults, is a clearer, in-depth understanding.
For almost five hundred years, the island was ruled
by Western, Christian, conquerors. During these long
years, the people were subordinated and marginalized,
the country’s resources exploited, Buddhism and
Hinduism neglected, the national languages officially
excluded. Resentment and anger built up, seething but
inarticulate because of imperial power and policing.
Independence opened the gates of the dam, and the waters
of historical grievance have poured out, impatient and
violent.
My attempt is not to explain Sri Lanka’s
present woes but to urge that children’s books,
however interesting and simple, should start them on
the path to serious thought and an in-depth historical
understanding. One Country creates a superficial “feel
good” effect, but to leave colonialism (sic) as
having forever gifted us kokis, pancake and lamprais
simply won’t do: past imperialism is one among
the major factors underlying the present ethnic conflict.
Of course, to understand is not to excuse, much less
condone, but it is the sine qua non for real rectification.
Men, women who brought the message of
divinity closer to home
The recent launch of Sivanandini Duraiswamy’s
book “The Footfalls on Time,” marked the
seventh death anniversary of Yogendra Duraiswamy –
an outstanding diplomat who did his country proud. Attorney
General K. C. Kamalasabeyson, PC was the Special Guest
on that occasion and addressed the gathering.
Some years ago, Sivanandani Duraiswamy,
had this to say about her husband. "Since Yoga's
passing away, I have felt closer to him, living in spirit
through all those beautiful years once again".
Today's publication clearly demonstrates to all of us
that this attachment is no longer something personal
to the writer but has taken a different form to enrich
the spiritual knowledge of many who would be fortunate
to read this book.
Our country has produced outstanding
public servants.
The Tamil community has produced public
servants of the calibre of Sir Ponnambalam Ramanathan,
Sir Ponnambalam Arunachalam and C. Balasingham. Yogendra
Duraiswamy is yet another product of the community to
be added to this illustrious list.
He was in every sense of the word
a true Sri Lankan who ably represented his country as
a diplomat in several parts of the world. To him, his
career was a work of art, encased in commitment, dedication
and integrity. Above all, the religious faith and belief
deeply embedded in him was a force that guided him throughout
his career in the Foreign Service.
On his retirement from the Foreign
Service, rather prematurely, he went back to his birth
place, Jaffna, where we saw him play a different role.
He was fearless and forthright and
was never hesitant to stand up to injustice. He advocated
a fair and equitable social order so that the members
of the Tamil community could live with dignity and respect.
Amidst the political turmoil of the
time he was appointed the District Secretary and Government
Agent of Jaffna in April, 1969. He served the people
of Jaffna without fear or favour and stood up to the
politicians from both the government side and the opposition
- by no means an easy or enviable task at that point
of time, but he was able to achieve results through
perseverance and stubbornness.
Recently an elderly gentleman from
Jaffna wrote an article in the "Daily Mirror"
on one of the most unfortunate and horrible events of
the last century, both nationally and internationally
viz. the destruction of the Jaffna Library.
It is relevant to note that in his
article he specifically refers to the absence of the
political leaders and ministers on the spot of the incident
at the time of burning but to the presence and the efforts
of the then Government Agent and his wife who were the
only persons of standing present on the spot.
A man is tested only at a time of
crisis. It is only then that his true qualities become
known to the world. On that fateful day we saw a clear
demonstration of strength, discipline and courage in
late Mr. Yogendra.
Writing a book is by no means an easy
task, particularly, if it is on the various aspects
of Hinduism and about the saints and sages who have
enriched the Hindu religion and culture, both in the
ancient and modern world.
"The Footfalls on Time"
not only contains the stories of the Hindu saints but
also the underlying Hindu philosophy that has served
to preserve the spiritual values for over five thousand
years.
No religion can survive by itself
or its philosophy and teachings sustained. It could
be achieved only through realization which cannot exist
in thin air.
From time to time, great men and women
with saintly qualities are born to nurture and spread
the true message. "The Footfalls on Time"
contains the stories of these divine men and women who
have at different stages brought to the ordinary people
the true meaning of God and shown to them the path to
truth and enlightenment.
Lessons on life through death
By Salma Yusuf
Quite different to her biography of
a national hero who was in the vanguard of the struggle
for his country’s independence - ‘E.W.Perera:
Portrait of a True Patriot of Sri Lanka’ is Rita
Perera’s latest book ‘Coalescing With Omega’.
‘Coalescing With Omega’
is about the writer’s perception of what may happen
after death. While in this world, race, nationality,
culture, religion, gender, age etc. play a vital role
in our lives. But when we die, the author feels, in
all probability, we will all experience the same process.
The writer has attempted to develop
this theme through five fictional characters, who all
die simultaneously though under different circumstances,
different causes and for varying reasons. Luke, a baptised
Christian from the U.S.A, dies when his private plane
crashes; Mohan Das, an Indian Hindu who migrated to
England dies of a sudden heart attack; Abdul Karim,
a young Muslim boy of Egyptian nationality who was a
paraplegic all his life dies in Egypt; Padma, an elderly
Sri Lankan Buddhist is killed in a motor accident and
Nicky, an Aborigine from Australia, in his late twenties
meets his death during a drunken brawl.
She draws on these five individuals
from diverse backgrounds in an attempt to represent
a microcosm of the world. Their deaths as well as the
expectations they held regarding what happens after
death, differ vastly, but they experience the same process.
The rites and rituals at their funerals
and interaction between families, as well as the appraisal
they make of their lives in the light of their new awareness
are a social commentary where the author has tried to
fuse fact with fiction.
The writer says that various religious
beliefs and myths colour what most people believe is
likely to happen after they die but there is little
scientific evidence to support such views.
Modern resuscitation methods as well
as the documentation of countless near-death experiences,
she highlights, reveal an increasingly common pattern.
She asserts that her own apprehension has been assuaged
to some degree by documented research , especially in
books such as Dr. Raymond Moody’s ‘Life
after Life’, where he recounts many near death
experiences. She makes reference to Dr. Michael Newton,
a hypno-therapist and the case studies he has documented
in ‘Journey of Souls’ and ‘Destiny
of Souls’ that support the view that life is a
continuum.
The motivation for this book comes
in the wake of recent world events, like the 9/11, the
tsunami, as well as recent earthquakes, floods, epidemics,
wars throughout the world which caused instantaneous
deaths and brought home the stark reality of human mortality.
The author highlights how this phenomenon is relevant
to everyone, for in whatever form it presents itself,
death like birth remains inevitable for every human
being.
The combination of feelings of peace,
joy and exhilaration felt in death and the subsequent
‘transportation’ to the ‘other’
world are shown to be common to and provide a unifying
force for all five characters irrespective of cause,
place or background of all five characters.
However, this commonality experienced
initially after death gradually degenerates after which
each of the characters gains renewed awareness of their
individual identities. It is at this point of time that
they begin to look back on their lives and begin to
evaluate every incident in it.
Every nuance and shadow of each of
their lives gains a sharper and brighter meaning. The
author compares this phenomenon to a rewound video film
in slow motion.
Earthly factors like time, which no
longer have the same dimensions, an oscillation between
reliving pre-death experiences and re-viewing them in
the light of different values, and shifts in emphasis
of different events, make this book an absorbing read.
A love beyond earth
Ma...I promise by Sathya Amorik - a
story that explores life beyond the veil. Emerald Publications,
Singapore. Available at the Lake House Bookshop - Rs.630.
Reviewed by
Anne Abayasekara
"The title, "Ma...I promise",
seemed a bit strange and the cover picture depicted
what looked like a typically Indian woman and little
son, so I was surprised to find that the story focused
on an English family and was set entirely in England.
An explanatory note on the back cover gives the key
to the title: it concerns a boy who took to heart his
Mum's constant admonition that, "Promises are not
meant to be broken", and so he would never make
a promise unless he was sure he could and would keep
it.
In a nutshell, this novel is about
a family comprising father, mother and son – Alan
and Christina Carrington and the boy Jim who is 7 years
old when the story begins and 12 when it ends. Jim is
the central character. He adores his Mum, Christina
or Chris as she is generally called. His Dad, Alan,
a trusted executive in a steel manufacturing company,
is a likeable man and Christina and he love each other
deeply and are devoted to their only child.
Their almost idyllic existence is
rudely shattered when Chris dies at the birth of her
second child, at 31. Both mother and baby are lost during
a premature labour. Chris's husband and her parents
are stunned and Jim is utterly devastated.
Refusing to be consoled, he could
only rebel against reality. It was his belief that his
Mum would never ever leave him. “`You can't leave
me like that, mum....you won't.'" This section
of the book is headed, "Ma, Don’t Leave Me,
Please."
Now we come to the part of the book
that rather baffles me. The writer uses Jim's unquenchable
longing for his mother, even two years after her death,
to take off with him into realms unknown. This section
is entitled, "Ma... I Will Seek You." I feel
the author is exploring her own beliefs and trying to
work out the meaning of death and the hereafter. It's
at bedtime that Jim has these travels to other worlds
inhabited by ethereal butterflies and birds and even
snakes. "Altogether, it was an awesome scene. There
was no fear, no anger - only happiness and peace."
Jim accepts the creatures who can enlarge themselves
at will and speak to him and is specially befriended
by a larger – than - life talking budgerigar whom
he calls ‘Budgie’.
When he eventually wakes up later
in his own bed, he knows it hasn't been a dream. "He
knew he had been whisked away from the physical - beyond
a world of dreams to a magical land of wonder and joy."
Immediately after each experience, he sleeps longer
than usual and his head aches mildly.
I found my credulity strained as I
read on. Beautiful angelic beings, I could accept, but
light beams emanating from flowers, winged children
flying about, talking butterflies, birds and snakes,
came across as fantasy.
Jim hugs his secret to himself and
the adults around him don't have a clue to his nightly
adventures. He and his friend Jerry decide to write
a book based on Jim's heavenly travels - Jerry is a
natural writer and Jim supplies all the material for
the book for which, after much thought and discussion,
they hit on the apt title, "Good Heavens!"
While Jim is entranced by the Beings
who inhabit the various worlds he visits at nights,
he never forgets his Mum and longs to be reunited with
her. He hopes that his trips to these other worlds will
conclude with a visit to wherever his mother is.
The boy's deep love and longing for his mother is very
convincingly conveyed without any sentimentalism, and
the author seems, in this book, to work out a way to
make the finality of death understandable to mortals.
The ending took me by surprise and
the implication seemed to be that meeting with his mother's
spirit transforms the boy, so that rebellion is replaced
by acceptance. He understands that while he will always
cherish his mother's memory, life has to go on in the
real world in which his lot is cast.
|