Financial Times

Hedging case takes another turn

Attempt to block overseas arbitration process
By Natasha Gunaratne

A fresh fundamental rights petition was filed on the oil hedging crisis this Thursday seeking an interim order from the Supreme Court to restrain the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation (CPC) and the Treasury Secretary from participating in any arbitration proceedings or litigation with any of the banks involved in the hedging contracts until a final determination is made on the application.

The petitioner, public interest activist Nihal Sri Ameresekere filed a petition in May 2009 on the hedging issue in the Supreme Court but in this week’s petition says that he was only aware of the intentions of the banks, namely Citibank, Deutsche Bank and Standard Chartered Bank, to enter into arbitration or litigation after the May application was filed. He is also asking that the interim order be converted into a permanent order upon the final determination of the application.

The petition states that arbitration cannot be proceeded with because the claims for payments by the banks stem from unlawful and illegal contracts. Mr. Ameresekere states that he now believes that the payments due from the CPC on the hedging agreements it entered into with five different banks is over US$800 million as some agreements go up to July, August and October of 2009. He also stated that contracts which he says are unlawful and illegal jeopardizes the government of Sri Lanka’s foreign borrowing ability and the standing in the international community for attracting foreign investments into the country.

The petition says the claims by the five banks --Standard Chartered Bank, Citibank, Deutsche Bank, Commercial Bank and People’s Bank --, are alarmingly high when compared with the foreign exchange reserves.

The petition further states that the hedging contracts are in effect ‘deals’ in the nature of speculating, gambling, betting or wagering on the movement of petroleum oil prices on notional quantities, through a devious scheme of hedging through derivative instruments. Such ‘deals’ are unlawful and illegal activity in Sri Lanka and internationally and cannot be enforced in law. Mr. Ameresekere states that he believed the transactions were carried out purportedly under the Master Agreement, referred to as the ISDA Master Agreement of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association, Inc., and in terms of the directions of the CB.

The petition states regardless of specific directions given in or about December 2008 by the CB’s Monetary Board, Standard Chartered Bank has remitted in valuable foreign exchange a sum exceeding US$100 million between December 2008 and April 2009, and was endeavouring to remit a further sum exceeding US$20 million on ‘Back to Back Agreements’ entered into with one or more foreign parties. The US$20 million had not been remitted after Mr. Ameresekere filed the earlier petition on May 25th 2009 in FR Application 404/2009.

Mr. Ameresekere added that he understand Standard Chartered Bank has instituted legal action in the UK High Court, making a claim against CPC, while Deutsche Bank has filed for arbitration in the International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in the US, and Citibank has instituted arbitration proceedings in the U.K, in the London Court of International Arbitration. He said that to date, he understands the arbitration (defence) alone has amounted to around Rs.25 million which is public money.

StandChart Officer takes fall on hedging issue

The contract of a senior credit officer at Standard Chartered Bank in Sri Lanka has not been extended, reliable sources say adding that the move is seen as ‘taking a fall for other culprits over the oil hedging debacle’.

Credit officer, Nigel Beebe, a British national, was named in the fundamental rights petition filed in the Supreme Court in May 2009 by former PERC Chairman Nihal Sri Ameresekere on the hedging agreements the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation (CPC) entered into with five banks including Standard Chartered Bank. Sources said Mr. Beebe’s contract with the Bank which is ending shortly after two years has not extended, although in practice another year is granted to such contracts.

The sources said Mr Beebe was among some officers at the bank who had raised issues over the hedging deals when it was first negotiated and advised against entering into the contracts.


 
Top to the page  |  E-mail  |  views[1]
 
Other Financial Times Articles
> IRD to tax Golden Key and depositors
> Hedging case takes another turn
> SEC refers Eswaran deal in Asia Cap to CB
> Plantation Cos. fail to pay lease rental
> CB cancels Seylan sale deal, extends board term
> Job losses amidst worker shortage
> Rare flowers and seeds of the tea bush
> COMMENT- Whistle-blowing: Will it work?
> Corporate Governance: Lessons from other jurisdictions
> EPS measurement as company performance could be misleading
> Swine Flu economic effect global- MTI
> World leaders approve Global Jobs Pact
> Sri Lankan-born American scholar explores trade and peace
> World's first 'Fair Trade' rubber glove by Lankan firm
> Prof. Munasinghe at Biz Club
> Emerging markets are Nokia’s next growth area
> Need for whistle-blowing hotline facilities emphasized
> Haycarb sees prospects in India, Thailand and Indonesia
> Lanka Salt records 99% profit increase for 2008
> SEC to raise financial media capability
> CB's FIU gets membership in Egmont Group
> CCC meeting looks at emerging opportunities
> US interference in the IMF deplorable - Minister Amunugama
> Hayleys profit drops 26%
> Caritas completes tsunami work worth over Rs 11 billion
> Chartered Institute of Logistics celebrates 25 years by opening doors to youth
> Seylan Merchant shows sharp losses in 1Q ‘09
> Tourism industry’s ‘Small Miracle’ unveiled
> SC calls for discipline at SLI
> Private firms get access to more funds
> Carbon Finance to fight climate change
> NTB in major forex loss, share rise seen hampered
> Seminar on trade terms risks, obligations
> Pest, disease and drought resistant tea trees coming out
> Cost of doing business in Sri Lanka reducing with the end of war -- Amunugama
> Travel warnings against Sri Lanka on the way out, says tourism sector

 

 
Reproduction of articles permitted when used without any alterations to contents and a link to the source page.
© Copyright 2009 | Wijeya Newspapers Ltd.Colombo. Sri Lanka. All Rights Reserved.| Site best viewed in IE ver 6.0 @ 1024 x 768 resolution