Creative
ads rejected by target audiences
By Akhry Ameer
Many Sri Lankan advertisements that have been hailed as creative
are being rejected by its target audience, a recent research study
has revealed.
The research
conducted continuously since 1995 upto last year by the students
of the Department of Industrial Management of the University of
Kelaniya has shown that a fair number of brands, including international
brands have failed due to bad advertisements.
According to
Professor Sunanda Degamboda who headed the research study, some
of the 'award winning' creative advertisements which have been rated
by the Sri Lanka Institute of Marketing (SLIM) Awards over the years
have failed in the market.
"In fact, an advertisement that was judged the best caused
a particular brand to get wiped out from the market," he said.
Explaining further he added, "Creativity is not the designer's
skill to inspire in his and his associate's minds, but it is the
skill of knowing the communicational preferences and value systems
of audiences and present a powerful and simplified message".
Some parts of
the research were not available as they are brand specific proprietary
information that have been submitted to clients. However, Prof.
Degamboda shared some of the general findings of his research. One
of the findings was that as a general rule, advertisements with
higher denotations were more effective. Denotations refer to the
direct messages given to the viewer as opposed to connotations.
Other general
findings of the research study suggest that food products projected
through humour using comedians from teledramas and films have failed.
Yet another finding was that advertisements not in line with local
culture have also failed in the long-term.
When asked the
reason for these failures, Professor Degamboda who now lectures
marketing communication and international marketing at the Informatics
Institute of Technology said, "The primary reason for failure
is that most organisations do not value advertising research. Research
is not being done in Sri Lanka".
He also observed
that advertising is not seen as a component of promotion where all
other elements should be blended to create an integrated marketing
communication and that promotional objectives are not in line with
corporate objectives of organisations.
However, some
of the negative trends are changing according to him. Most local
advertisements are now visually more powerful due to the use of
advanced technology. Yet another positive trend is the focus towards
a single message in an advertisement which otherwise had as much
11 messages in the earlier years. Asked for some of the negative
trends, he observed that advertising values in terms of ethics and
social responsibility are on the decline and that the local advertisements
are unnecessarily raising consumer expectation beyond the capability
of the product, annoying consumers.
Asked for his
opinion on the recently concluded SLIM Awards, Prof. Degamboda said
that the evaluation criteria needs to be looked at and suggested
the inclusion of ratings by a selected sample as a way forward.
He also observed that some advertisements that have been running
for many years without any improvement in the market share of the
product had won awards this year.
Letters
Don't tax terminal benefits
There are two points in the budget which seem to contradict one
another and do not make any sense - reducing and/or eliminating
excise duties on liquor and the taxation on terminal benefits.
People who are
retiring would have paid a lifetime of taxes. They have contributed
to society and the majority of them would not have obtained loans
against the sums lying to the credit of their EPF and ETF accounts
during their working lives. Successive governments, however, have
used these monies for various purposes.
Moreover, when
they retire their income would come to an end. It would be very
difficult for them to get even casual employment. It is at this
time that they are weak - physically, mentally and financially.
The government's revenue from this tax would be quite negligible,
but is would be a big slice off the final dues of a retiring person.
Imported liquor is consumed only by the upper classes of society.
Being a Dharmishta country, every action should be taken to curb
the consumption of this devil's brew instead of encouraging it.
So increasing the tax is certainly not going to have an impact on
those who want to consume liquor. The medical bills that consumers
of liquor have to incur are going to be tremendous and this is also
going to be a burden on government coffers. Go ahead and increase
the tax on alcohol and cigarettes as it will be a boon to society.
We appeal to
the Finance Minister and to the government to kindly abolish all
taxation on terminal benefits.
Zulkifli Nazim
Colombo 6
Customers
taken for a ride
In the February 4 edition of The Sunday Times, a reader (A.A.H.)
has written expressing certain misgivings about a bank lottery scheme
and asking specific questions which would no doubt be replied by
the bank.
This is welcome
concern and I too agree with theses views because I have also noticed
the names of winners being repeated in the advertisements with surprising
regularity. Another common concern is that the first prize is generally
won by a valuable customer, canvassed from another competing bank.
There was the
amusing case of car displayed for nearly six months in front of
the head office of a state bank running a lottery suddenly disappearing.
I assumed someone had won it but after making inquiries at the counter
as to the winner, it was revealed that the car had been taken to
the Kandy office of the bank to be displayed and no one in the bank
was aware when the draw would take place.
So all credit
to A.A.H. for having had the courage to take this matter up in the
media. Those like A.A.H. surely deserves the sympathy of all including
Central Bank officers who monitor these lotteries. But customers
have only themselves to blame because bank depositors of Sri Lanka
with a high level of learning and literacy ought to know that a
bank should be selected for capital strengths, financial performance
and convenience and not because of lottery draws.
Benize de Mel,
Pannipitiya
Rahaman
heads SLIM
Taslim Rahaman took over as the president of the Sri Lanka Institute
of Marketing (SLIM) from Nalin Attygalle at the institute's recent
annual general meeting.
He holds a diploma
in marketing from the Chartered Institute of Marketing, UK and is
also a Certified Professional Marketer of Asia-Pacific Marketing.
Rahaman is currently reading for his MBA at the post-Graduate Institute
of Management affiliated to the University of Sri Jayawardenapura.
His long marketing
career commenced in 1979 at Metropolitan Office (Pvt) Ltd. where
he is currently serving in the Board of Directors.
In his early
years he served in the Colombo Jaycees and was also a former president
of the Rotary Club of Maharagama. He joined the SLIM Executive Committee
in 1996 and since then has served in different capacities.
Emerald
sponsors Mahela
Emerald International (Pvt) Ltd, a top shirt manufacturer in Sri
Lanka signed a sponsorship deal with cricketing star Mahela Jayawardene
last week.
Under the agreement,
Jayawardene will appear in advertising and promotional activities
for Emerald International to promote its well known menswear brands.
The sponsorship agreement was handed over to Jayawardene by A.F.M.
Ikram, Chairman/Managing Director of Emerald International.
MTN
Networks signs up syndicated loan
MTN Networks, the second largest telecom operator in the country,
recently received a substantial funding boost of about US$ 21 million
with the joint lead arrangers and underwriters for this 8-year syndicated
loan being Citibank N. A. Sri Lanka and Commercial Bank of Ceylon
Ltd.
The other banks
involved were National Development Bank, National Savings Bank and
DFCC. The loan is secured by MTN Network's holding company, Telekom
Malaysia, a Citibank press release said.
This investment
will be utilised to spearhead MTN Network's innovative product development
efforts such as GPRS and other features, which is part of Dialog
GSM's strategy of persistent market diversification and aggressive
consumer-led growth.
"The company
is committed to maintain its standing as Sri Lanka's flagship technology
company, offering many mobile communication solutions to enrich
the lives of the end user," said Dr. Hans Wijesuriya, Director/Chief
Executive of Dialog GSM.
Kapila Jayawardena,
Country Head and Chief Executive Officer, Citibank Sri Lanka, said
they were pleased to work together with Commercial Bank and other
syndicate banks to provide this service for Dialog GSM.
Citibank and
Commercial Bank being the joint lead arrangers and underwriters
for this loan have contributed US$ 2.1 million each and further
sums of Rs. 304 million and Rs. 311 million respectively. National
Development Bank, National Savings Bank and DFCC have all contributed
Rs. 300 million each towards this loan.
The transaction
was completed despite stiff competition from many other leading
international banks within the country. Recalls Romesh Elapata of
Citibank, "We faced stiff competition from other global banks.
The entire transaction was done through a competitive bidding process
and the mandate was awarded to our partnership. Our success was
due to the commitment and professionalism displayed by our team."
Pizzas in a pouch
Pizza Hut Sri Lanka recently introduced the 'Heated Pouch' for the
delivery of their pizzas. "This new system enables customers
to receive their pizzas oven hot," said Sumithra Gunasekere,
Managing Director of Keels Restaurants.
"The pouches
have been bought down at a cost of Rs. 400,000 to help deliveries
in Colombo and suburbs from all Pizza Hut outlets," Gunasekere
said.
Speaking at
the launch he said that this is the first time in Sri Lanka and
in the sub- continent that such a system has been introduced. This
was first launched in the US in September last year.
The heated pouches
have been developed by the R&D arm of Tricon Restaurants International,
the owning company of Pizza Hut Worldwide. K.T.R. Bandara, Operations
Manager of Keells Restaurants explaining the workings of the Heated
Pouch, said that the pouches are plugged and pre-heated 20 minutes
prior to delivery. Once heated, the pouch reaches a temperature
of 90 degrees centigrade which is then retained for around 40 minutes.
"The usual
temperature of a pizza once out of the oven is around 70 degrees
centigrade and the heated pouch has the ability to retain this inner
core heat until the time of delivery to the customer," Bandara
added.
Shippers complain of war risk rip-off
Some shipping lines and "unscrupulous" freight forwarders
are still charging war risk insurance freight surcharges from shippers,
the Sri Lanka Shippers' Council said last week.
"We believe
that there are interested parties who would like to continue with
the war risk surcharge to gain short-term profits at the expense
of the image of the country," Ravi Ratnapala, the council's
chairman said in a statement.
It has asked
shipping agents to join hands with shippers to lobby for the removal
of war risk surcharges, he said.
"Due to
the continuous lobbying done by the Sri Lanka Shippers' Council
the war risk surcharge has been withdrawn by some shipping lines
on certain trade routes while DSR-Senator and Zim Lines have totally
withdrawn the surcharge on all trade routes," he said.
Members of India,
Pakistan, Bangladesh, Ceylon Conference (IPBCC) have withdrawn the
war risk surcharge on the Colombo/Europe route and vice versa, he
said.
"However,
some members of the IPBCC continue to charge the war risk surcharge
on other trade routes, which are serviced by the same vessel that
serves the Colombo - Europe sector," he said.
There have been
some instances where unscrupulous freight forwarders have charged
the war risk surcharge from importers in an unfair manner in an
endeavour to make quick profits, Ratnapala said.
|