Business Times

On Budget and the Deemed Dividend Tax

I refer to the article under the below caption published on Page 3 of your issue dated Sunday December 12, 2010. The writer is referring to the proposed amendment to section 61(1) (b)(ii) of the Inland Revenue Act No. 10 of 2006, whereby the existing ceiling on the tax chargeable on a company by reference to the dividends distributed is to be reduced from 25% to 1%.

The tax components under section 61(1) (a) and (b) are not separate taxes but constitute a single tax on the company. This aspect of local corporate taxation was clarified by the Privy Council in the Woodend case (SLTC Vol III, p 405). This is what the Privy Council said in 1970: “In Ceylon the dividends declared by resident companies is not the subject matter of the extra 33-1/3% but the condition of its being levied….)

The concept of deemed dividends is totally alien to the scheme of section 61 and the two things are as different as chalk is from cheese. Perhaps the writer is confusing section 61 with section 66. In terms of the latter section, an Assessor may, if he is satisfied that a company has unreasonably withheld the distribution of a reasonable part of its profits, deem a relevant part of such withheld profits as a deemed dividend and tax it on the company. A set-off is available for the tax paid under section 61(1) (b). True enough, the financial effect of the present provisions of section 61(1) (b) (ii) may have the same deterrent effect as section 66 on the corporate greed to withhold profits from distribution but the financial effect is not the same as the legal effect.

Another important criterion to be borne in mind is that the proposed amendment has the legal effect of reducing the corporate tax burden on the company and is allied to the reduction of the corporate tax rate to 28%. It is thus part of the development initiative of the government to foster the growth of corporate capital which is an important segment of economic growth. In this view it seems unfair to level a charge, however veiled, that the proposed amendment is by special favour. The writer’s spotlight on JKH, VPEL, JNS and HNB is, in my opinion, in bad taste.

In a quoted company, the small shareholder remains small whether the profits distributed are adequate or not. The writer’s concern for small shareholders is, like the love of animals, just a tender feeling and not a sound economic paradigm. The reference to ‘oppression of the minority’ is out of place in the context of the freedom that a person, big or small has, to buy shares in a quoted company.

The small investor like the poor voter in a democracy has Hobson’s choice. You invest small and get something small and learn to be content. You vote with the rich and let them share power and position in society while your ballot paper remains a piece of paper without any potential in the forward march of small democrats!

Tissa Samson Perera (ACA) Colombo

Top to the page  |  E-mail  |  views[1]
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
 
Other Business Times Articles
Bungalows for local tourists
Sri Lankan Facebook users face threat of Internet hackers
Mabroc Teas now part of Hayleys Group
Tax-friendly advice from Indian computer experts
Coconut imports could bring in ‘unwanted diseases’: Growers
CB affidavits to solve northern land ownership issues
Many IPOs could draw investor doubt in 2011
Comment - Independence of ‘independent’ directors
Feature - Nation Building Tax (NBT) - More progressive in effect
Feature - Politics of the budget and the ‘Left’
Migrants often compelled to do work on substandard pay: ILO
Virtusa re-enters 2010 FinTech 100 List
Microimage HR suite to mark 10 years in January
Uditha and Ravi appointed to COMBank Board
US-based Elon students to hold environmental summit in Sri Lanka
Plantation Human Development Trust (wins again)
On Budget and the Deemed Dividend Tax
Discrimination against PAYE employees on house ownership
Sri Lanka could be the 'Wonder of Asia' : World Bank MD
QAPCO to make Sri Lanka a major petrochemical marketing centre in the region
MTD Walkers Projects provide solutions to hydropower plants
Maldives to announce new tourism slogan shortly
Fibre glass firm, U.S.S. Services (Pvt) Ltd ventures into boat building
CCC’s guide to trade on FTAs
After 15 years, ‘lion-hearted’ Richard succeeds as ‘Entrepreneur of the Year’
SEC prepares draft rules on Share Option Schemes
Commercial Bank supports University of Jaffna
CCC's annual report awards
HSBS gets new Global Head of Commercial Banking
Power and energy: Getting the right pricing mechanism
Focus on private sector opportunities from 'Peace Dividend' : World Bank MD
LEED-NC Silver Certification for Ulagalla Resort, Anuradhapura
Lankan iPhone app is #1 free medical download

 

 
Reproduction of articles permitted when used without any alterations to contents and a link to the source page.
© Copyright 2010 | Wijeya Newspapers Ltd.Colombo. Sri Lanka. All Rights Reserved.| Site best viewed in IE ver 6.0 @ 1024 x 768 resolution